geography book Sailing alone around the world and frustrated

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • tamaralynn
    Member

    Just started reading this book.  I myself find it a little hard to grasp.  MY almost 10yo son isnt digging the book.  In fact he’s not liking anything we are doing for homeschooling.  I know it’s a change from public school.  He’s not listening to anything I’m reading.  I ask for a narration he says I dont remember.  I tried reading a paragraph and he cant even put anything together It’s all scattered.  But he can sure tell me what is going on in his diary of a whimpy kid.  I also am hs my 6.5yo which is not doing to bad.  They both  have really bad attitudes and are very rude and disrepectful.I almost felt like stopping schoolwork altogether and just hang out with them and just read.  I’m a single mom trying to give them an good education.  I’m going crazy.  I’m angry I’m hurt.  Thanks for listening and for your advice.  Tamara

    amama5
    Participant

    Dear Tamara, I’m so sorry you are feeling frustrated and hurt.  It must be very hard to be doing what you are doing.  It’s hard enough when you have support and compliant children.  I think stopping schoolwork and hanging out just reading is fine for a while, and also taking a break to work on respect/attitudes towards you. 

    Regarding the book Sailing Alone, here is my old post for advice when I didn’t like it either:)  http://simplycharlottemason.com/scmforum/topic/sailing-alone-around-the-world-book-question

    The great thing I’m learning is that you are free to do whatever works for your family, if your kiddos don’t like it, do something else.  I would really look at Holling C Holling geography books, and my kiddos enjoyed listening to Stowaway on audio CD.  Do you have a good library to borrow from?  That’s where we get our books, and I’m sure your budget is tight too, so it’s great if you check out a book no one likes, just take it back and try something else!  If you don’t have a good library, I get very cheap books on http://www.abebooks.com or http://www.half.com, sometimes http://www.homeschoolclassifieds.com.  Here is another post about books for a 9 year old boy who didn’t like to read: http://simplycharlottemason.com/scmforum/topic/boy-who-is-9 

    With the narration, try asking a specific question, like tell me two things you learned, etc.  Sometimes that helps more than just having them narrate the whole passage.  Maybe you were already doing that, and I’m sure other moms will have more suggestions on that topic.

    Hope that helps, just perservere in your goals with your children and know you aren’t alone, there are many kind women here willing to help if they can!  Adrienne

    suzukimom
    Participant

    Tamara, when did you take him out of public schoo?  Did you take any time to “de-school” him before starting homeschool?  It is a huge transition, and takes some time…  they estimate about 1 month for every year of school, including Kindergarten and preschools…   So assuming you took him out recently – at age 10 he was probably in grade 5, assuming there was a K year, there is at least 6 months of deschooling he needs to do to get PS out of his system so to say.  Of course that varies from child to child some, but is a good rule of thumb.

    Not much should be expected during the deschooling time – it is a good time to work on attitudes, respect – as well as having fun doing things like going to zoos or the museum… time learning to do chores… and a fair amount of free time.  I’d try to wean him off of twaddle books and onto better books during this time too (not sure the best way to do that…)

    HUGS!

    2flowerboys
    Participant

    Tamara, I am sure more experienced moms that had their kids in PS will know more. But I think it would be a good idea if you de-schooled them for a while. I noticed on your other post that it hasn’t been long since they were in PS.

    So your feelings about stopping and hanging out is a good thing. They are not going to miss anything important! Just read some good books, listen to some great stories(try librivox.org or Jim Weiss), listen to some classical music, love on each other, and if weather permits take some walks. Enjoy this time together and build up your relationship. Then when you get back to your schedule do it in small chunks. Are you doing your subjects for 10-15 min at a time? Slowly work up to more time. And most of all set those ground rules for respecting you and each other. That is hard for all of us..and I believe it is a daily thing!

    That is awesome that you are trying so hard! I am sure it is not easy being a single mom! You are making a difference! May God give you strength and wisdom during this time.

    EDIT…I was writing when everyone else was too! 🙂

    tamaralynn
    Member

    Thank you so much I am crying.  You have been of a great source of encouragement.  My 6.5yo has been hs for a year I tried ps but only for a couple of months.  My 10 yo has been in ps since k only in 3rd grade so 4 years.  I do have the holling books already and I so liked the post on the book Im having trouble with.  Im just going to take a few weeks off with my 10yo.  My other one probably still needs the consistency of phonics and math.  Love you guys thanks so much Tamara God bless!!!!!!!!!!

    Sue
    Participant

    The “Sailing Alone….” book soooo did not work well for us, either. I know in the thread Adrienne mentioned I spoke about using “Stowaway” in its place (which was much easier for all of us to grasp and enjoy), but I would probably start with the Holling C. Holling books instead. We especially enjoyed “Paddle to the Sea.”

    If you really need to study South America and/or Australia right now, though, then “Stowaway” would be better for you. There is really no absolute that says you have to study the continents in a particular order.

    4myboys
    Participant

    Hi Tamaralynn;

    It seems you and I might be in similar situations in that we are both new to HSing kids who have recently come from PS.  My boys are 11 and 7 and I am feeling the pressures of working PT, being a mom and wife and teacher.  I am a little stressed and finding “school” tricky. I’m feeling my way around and trying to sort it all out.  There is definately a learning curve here!  I’ve not been doing a lot this year — my focus has been on math and copy work.  I’ve felt these were the areas where my older son was lacking and my younger son excelling.  I do literature fairly regularly, but reading to my boys is always somthing I’ve done regularly, I just have different reasons for picking some of the books I have.  Many of the books we’ve read are not typical for boys — we started the year with Anne of Green Gables of all things because we spend our first week of school on a week long field trip to PEI (my dh had to be there for work and we were able to take the week and go along with him).  We’ve been reading books that take place in Canada as that’s where we are from.  They enjoyed Owls in the Family.  I will soon read to them Margy and possibly Margy Misunderstood after that as the woman who wrote them is my sisters’ Godmother — I plan to have them interview her after we’ve read the book(s). 

    I agree with the deschooling thing, but it’s so easy to feel like you are wasting time with them not doing anything, like you’re letting them fall behind.  My kids would rather play video games all day long, and certainly would if I let them.  We are still working on habits, and I have come to the conclusion this evening that habits and chores are  more important than science and history, etc. at this point.  They are still young and have plenty of time to learn all of that — and most of it cycles anyway, especially in grades 7-12 — but habits are foundational.  If I do nothing else with them the rest of the year but teach good character traits and habits, I think it will take them much, much further in the long run.  I think I’m about to go reconfigure the rest of my term with that in mind.  Certainly something to pray about and consider carefully.

    Tracey

    mom
    Participant

    Just wanted to say, on the narration topic, sometimes it helps if *you* model it for him for awhile. Ask specifc questions also until he builds confidence. You can always use a different medium as well…drawing, acting the story out, etc.

    Hth a lil.

    Enjoy your deschooling time! 😉

    When we took the girls out of public school after 6 years, we took almost 8 months of where we read, did art, nature, traveled and did some basic math…it was all very relaxed and it was necessary – they needed to get that schooling experience out of their system and then relax gently into our new way. I recommend a period of decompression as well. Linda

    Kelly Bond
    Participant

    So much great advice, I won’t repeat…but also wanted to reassure you that my 6yo son loves, loves, books of all kinds and neither of us really liked this book, either!

    tandc93
    Participant

    Oh I am so glad to hear we aren’t the only ones! We stuck it out for a llooonnngggg time unti I finally called it quits. We just couldn’t go on. Thanks!

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • The topic ‘geography book Sailing alone around the world and frustrated’ is closed to new replies.