Heather,
This was used in the co-op my girls and I were in last year. We chose not to do this for various reasons, but I was able to listen in to the leasons as the students did them in the class. This class did not use the history portion that goes with this because there was a history class offered already. Having said that, there were several interesting discussions that took place. Though there are questions to answer in the book, the class did discuss their answers and the thoughts behind them – in some cases defend their position Biblically if there were questions as to how they arrived at that answer. It seems to be very well done.
Do note that there is a LOT of work and reading in this, so if you are having your older son do this in addition to family history, he *may* be overwelmed by the amount of work depending upon his personality. Having said that, I think it is a worthwhile study.
While I realize that you won’t have your son in a group like I mentioned above, I think the discussions that could arrise from this will be very good. I would like to do this with my girls at some point, but I’m not sure how I’ll work it in yet. I think perhaps that my 17 yo will to through this next year, though I’m not sure about that yet.
HTH’d in some way.
~jacqleene meyers