Shakespeare with a 5th and 2nd grader?

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Chantelle
    Participant

    I know SCM recommends maybe 1 play every 2 years, but how do you acutally do this?  I have found many of Shakespeare’s play downloadable for free from http://www.gutenberg.com but I just don’t know how to slowly study a play like that or if my boys can even follow along with it…

    Please Help!

    briedell
    Member

    Hi,

    I thought I’d share our experience.  Years ago, I bought a book from Rainbow Resource called Stories from Shakespeare by Usborne.  It is a big Red book with a dustjacket.  Inside are different Shakespeare plays with colored Illustrations.  The stories are easy for my kids to understand.  This is a starting point for us, and when they are older(middle school on up); they will have an easier time reading the actual Shakespeare.  Now, in terms of CM; this is probably considered a dumbed down approach; but we’ve all enjoyed it.

    We actually use it during Term 1 and Term 3 once a week.  On Thursdays we get out the book and Mom or the oldest child reads aloud a few pages of the play we’re working on.  I do not have them narrate this; but you could.  When we finish the entire play over a few weeks time; then I have them reenact the play for me.  That is a lot of fun for them and me.

     

    Hope this helps.

    my3boys
    Participant

    I am so glad someone brought this up!!  I found a nice picture book at the Friends of the Library and was hesitant to pick it up because it probably is a dumbed down version of Shakespeare, but very much like some of the suggested reading for Module 5 for my 2nd grader.  I think I’ll go back and see if it is still there and ease my kids (and myself) into it.  We do have a more mature version of his plays, but I can barely understand what’s being said:)  I will use it in the future, as I know it will benefit us, but I have to start somewhere and I feel more comfortable with this as we slowly convert over to CM. 

    Blessings to you all.

    momto2blessings
    Participant

    I will also have a 5th and 2nd grader next year.  This year we read a few plays together using Lamb’s Shakespeare.  It was a good level for my 5th grader.  Some was over my 2nd graders head, but he enjoyed most of it once I explained a bit.  I also made/had the kids make little drawings of the characters to keep them straight—permanent marker on the back of an old cereal box.  

    Next year, I think my plan will be to read just one play for the year.  First semester using Lamb’s for both (it’s a great version, easier to understand, but still some old language to gently acclamate).  Second semester I will do the original with my eldest using No Fear Shakespeare (it has side-by-side original with modern language).  We also watch a short youtube video from BBC.  I have a link if you are interested. The one we watched had been edited for children—there was one borderline questionable scene, but not bad.  Got most of these ides from Ambleside moms, so I can’t take credit if you like any of them:)  Blessings, Gina

    Chantelle
    Participant

    Momto2Blessings – Do you mind sharing a little about Lamb’s Shakespeare?  I found it on Amazon, but no reviews or details and it’s calleds Lamb’s tales from Shakespeare…. is this the same thing?  How many Shakespeare stories does it include?    Which play would you recommend for me to attempt with a 2nd and 5th grader?  I loved Shakespeare in highschool!

    Also, for everyone else, do you use abridged versions of other classics so youngers can read and understand them?  For example, Treasure Island, etc.?

    my3boys
    Participant

    Okay, I knew I had a book titled Shakespeare something, but wasn’t sure until I went to the book shelf.  It is titled Tales from Shakespeare by Charles and Mary Lamb.  Is this the book you are talking about?  I think I found this at the Friends of the Library, but not sure. 

    Anyway, I have looked through it for a few minutes and first of all just by reading a few paragraphs I am hooked!!  This is going to be fun.  I think that I would rather use this than the picture books (as nice as they were, maybe for my 41/2 year old to look at?) that I was thinking of using.  This book states that it is Complete and Unabridged, but I think that with discussion my (almost) 8 yo could understand. 

    I had no idea until now as to what I was going to use in the fall, but at least I have a starting point and already have a book:)  Now other than reading and discussing these plays what else would qualify as a study of Shakespeare?  Maybe there will be a play we can take our kids to, wouldn’t that be fun?!

    Each play/story has one picture/drawing in the beginning and the stories are 12-13 pages long. Not too much on each page, but enough. 

    I have to admit that when I got the book I just grabbed it to have something in the house with the name Shakespeare on it.  I have been overwhelmed by this book (and it’s just a little book) for weeks now,  but now I feel more confident about this study.  Even if someone suggests using something else because this is not quite CM enough or of a good quality, I am excited, not intimidated by this subject. So I thank you, cj, for posting the question:)

    Sonya Shafer
    Moderator

    Lamb’s Tales from Shakespeare is excellent. So is Nesbit’s Beautiful Stories from Shakespeare for Children

    We like to read the story version of the play from one of those books, then read some or all of the original play in Shakespeare’s own words, then watch a DVD of the play. A live one would be great, but be careful; some of the newer productions of Shakespeare are modernized and raunchy. We’ve been very pleased with the DVDs from Ambrose Video. Our library carries them. As with anything, preview!

    my3boys
    Participant

    Yeah!  My *good book vs. twaddle book* radar is improving!

    I know I didn’t post the question, but I’m so glad it was, as I feel so good about adding this to our schedule in the Fall. I had left that subject with a question mark until now.

    I appreciate the heads-up about the *live* plays and will check out the dvd versions for now. And, I think it’s a great idea to draw pictures of the characters to keep them straight.  My 8yo would like that:)

     

    zami
    Participant

    Regarding the Shakespeare books by Lamb, and Nesbit, the Ambleside Online advisory had a little insight that helped me choose one [Moderator’s note: The Ambleside Online site license agreement states that permission is required to link to their site, and even then only linking to the home page is allowed. We have removed the link to honor their wishes.]

    Also you can read both books at mainlesson.com

    Beautiful Stories from Shakespeare, by Edith Nesbithttp://www.mainlesson.com/display.php?author=nesbit&book=shakespeare&story=_contents

    Tales from Shakespeare, by Charles and Mary Lambhttp://www.mainlesson.com/display.php?author=lamb&book=shakespeare&story=_contents

    What a great question.  I got some good ideas from this thread.

    -Laura

    Chantelle
    Participant

    Can anyone recommend one of Shakespeare’s play that would be good for us to start with based on a 5th grader and 2nd grader (boy boys)? Our library does have Tales from Shakespeare by Lamb and some of the Ambrose Videos, so I will plan to use that at least to get us started. 

    Sonya Shafer
    Moderator

    They might enjoy The Comedy of Errors.

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • The topic ‘Shakespeare with a 5th and 2nd grader?’ is closed to new replies.