We like it well enough, but it does not hold the interest of my 1st graders at all. One thing we are doing is reading an entire chapter at a time.
Also, I found a FREE audio version at librivox and that made a HUGE difference. The kids will follow along in the novel sometimes, but listening to someone else read it gave it new life for us. I try really hard but I found it hard to read aloud. It is dry at times for sure. We are just in Chapter 6 though. Not sure how far you made it.
We had to put away Famous Men last year, so I get where you are coming from. Sometimes a book just doens’t work and if you and your DC are getting nothing out of it, it is time to read something else I think too.