OT: severe lack of implementation

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Jenni
    Participant

    I’m posing this under habits because I realize it’s a bad one for me. A bad habit, that is.

    I can plan and shop and research curriculum, books, and other materials ’til the cows come home. I can and do scan the forums, read reviews, email friends for their take, and pour over the Rainbow resource catalog for hours, but I find I have a dearth of implementation here.

    We are stacked to the rafters with books of every ilk and yet, most days school doesn’t get done to even half of what I’ve planned.

    Anyone else in this boat with me? Anyone been there and successfully climbed out to a more productive life? What can we do?

    Looking for words of encouragement and wisdom, ladies. Go ahead, be tough; I can take it. 🙂

    Tristan
    Participant

    ((HUGS)) Sounds to me like you need to start small with just absolute essentials. Maybe your big priority after scriptures, math, and reading is history for a while. Then shift to science/nature study for a while. You do not have to do all subjects every day all year long. We do many things in seasons! Right now we’ve got a composer study going but nothing in poetry, art, or Shakespeare. We often do science in seasons.

    Des
    Participant

    I’he been having the same struggle this year. I think starting small making sure a few things get fond would be a great start. I also think that really committing myself to my plan helps too.

    amandajhilburn
    Participant

    Sometimes my plans are just unrealistic….I’m often setting myself up to fail.  I am trying to make more “do-able” plans that I know I can handle for next year. 

     

    4myboys
    Participant

    This is a big issue for me and one of the main reasons I’m looking at MFW for next year.  I am discovering that even though it might not be fully cm or I may not be fully sold on all the books (there is still plenty of room for adding more living books from their book basket lists and other resources), my boys will be much better off (and I won’t be as stressed) following a laid out plan. Especially where I work part time, I don’t have the time or energy to really sort out all the day-to – day details.  I’ll try it for a year and decided how I feel about it after that.  

    JennyMN
    Participant

    Jenni, I completely understand.  I think that I just research things to death.  I love to research.

    The Planning Your CM Education has really helped me to stay more focused this year.  Too often we try to fit things into our lives – good things – that don’t even fit our goals.  I actually have a stack of books/curriculum that don’t “fit my goals” that I need to sell.  If I keep them they will just keep screaming “use me” and I will feel defeated.  Sometimes, less is better.  That’s what I like about SCM – it’s simplified. 

    As far as not getting to what you plan – maybe you are planning too much.

    my3boys
    Participant

    I am a researcher, too.  And a planner.  But implementation is difficult at times for me, too.  At times, I have to literally make myself “do” what I planned.  I usually have way too many things planned for one subject/topic and have to force myself to narrow it down to just use the one that I like best.  That is really hard when there are sooo many great programs/books to use. Add that to the fact that you feel like you are losing time with your kiddos.  Mine are getting big and I’m feeling the pressure.

    For instance, let’s say science….I have a co-op that may offer science for my dc, but instead of just using that for the year, I add in (on the fly) a class that comes up somewhere else or a book I want us to read or short unit study I think would be great to do at this time of year.  I feel like I can add those things in because we are homeschoolers and that we have time, but the reality is…is just messes things up.  OR. I can’t seem to manage it all OR I can’t see the beauty in variation, but instead feel regret in what we didn’t accomplish in what I’d already planned.

    Knowing that about myself, I should plan less in our homeschool and let those outside things come as they do, which if I know us, they will.  I fool myself into thinking that I won’t do a field trip our homeschool group sets up, which is just not true. 

    I think I see what others are accomplishing and think that we should too. Or we over-plan because we think we can.  I have so many plans for next year and way too many supplies that I need to get rid of.  I don’t like that guilty feeling of not accomplishing or using what we have, so I need to minimize big time!

    I think our family does a lot outside the home in comparison to others and thinking that we can do some of the great ideas I glean from others is just not possible.  I need to be okay with that.

    So, yes, I completely understand and I feel I plan too much as well.  I probably do that to make sure it’s all covered, but in the end, makes me crazy!

    I hear you too, Jenni. I hope this isn’t hijacking your original intent, but what JennyMN said her struck a chord with me on this topic:

    “Too often we try to fit things into our lives – good things – that don’t even fit our goals. I actually have a stack of books/curriculum that don’t “fit my goals” that I need to sell. If I keep them they will just keep screaming “use me” and I will feel defeated. Sometimes, less is better.”

    This is my current struggle. I have boxed up some, but really want to be…brutal? Well, maybe not completely brutal, but at least somewhat brutal. I feel like some of the joy of the journey has been sapped from having too much “good” …if that makes sense. HOW do you let go of the good books? What guiding decisions or principles do you follow? Even with goals set I feel like I can justify too much. We are very limited on space and facing yet another move, so I need to let go of more. But once I start looking I get paralyzed by memories of certain books, reminders of good intentions with others, or I pick out up and thumb through it and think, “oh yeah, this looked really good (or was when I used it with my older ones)…we should really use this!”

    But ultimately, not much has changed at the end of the day. How does one really LIVE the less is more concept?

    Feeling your pain….

    my3boys
    Participant

    Oh, and I mentioned Unit Studies in my post…I hate them and am not good at doing them.  I just passed off some to someone else because I’m never going to use them.

    I like to have a lot of supplies because it’s makes things more easier when we need them, but at the same time, the additional supplies can be paralyzing to look at. 

    I totally get it and need to be “brutal” in getting rid of some stuff and not over-planning. 

    I don’t know if this is helping you at all, Jenni, or if we’re sharing our struggle with “stuff” and not the doing of the “stuff”.  Hmmmm….Sometimes I have to start fresh, clean the storage area, gain perspectives, take a real break, discipline myself in my morning routine (if that is off, the day may be off) and get back to a good schedule.  Sometimes I think that for myself it’s how I have my schedule set up…if it’s on the fridge, I forget about it, if it’s on the counter and we check off what we’ve done, etc., makes me feel like we’re working through what we’ve planned.  Anyhow, I do know how you feel and have to work at that sometimes too.

    missceegee
    Participant

    There was a wonderful post about this topic some time ago. I thought I’d saved it, but I didn’t. It dealt with the over planning, never implementing. I’ll link it if I find it.

    ETA – I just found the link I was looking for. Maybe it will help.

    http://simplycharlottemason.com/scmforum/topic/overcoming-perfectionism-in-homeschooling

    So glad you posted that link — since it was just bumped a month ago, I remember it (now that I see it)! Anabetica’s post…the second post on the first page?…is just so wonderfully insightful and encouraging.

    I am my own worst enemy most of the time, honestly. One thing I can say with certainty, for me at least, is that I have a tendency toward what Jenni expressed and I really need to watch myself, know myself. 

    My most “successful” periods of time over the years for getting done those academic plans are when there is a definite flow/routine to our days (not time slots, but just the overall flowing sequence of the day), coupled with some planning like what is described in the SCM’s Planning book and a listing of family and independent work that *my kids can readily see*. 

    The other thing…and maybe this is seen as a tangent… is that when the household things have a similar structure (basic meal plan and cleaning/tidying routines — nothing fancy! we’re talking simple here) then *I* am a much happier person and can enjoy my children sooo much more. Then I feel like I can enjoy the book, look into their beautiful faces instead of thinking about the weight I feel of things that need to get done, wander off the path and enjoy it, etc. 

    MamaSnow
    Participant

    I read a really good article last week which doesn’t speak EXACTLY to this issue, but perhaps is somewhat related. She is talking about “fitting everything in” by keeping it simple and not trying too hard (with some practical examples of how to do so.) As a recovering over-planner, I found it really beautiful and inspiring.

    http://ohpeacefulday.blogspot.com/2013/04/fitting-in-nice-bits.html

    Jen

    HollyS
    Participant

    I overplan as well.  I have a long list of resources I want to get to and recently have been realizing how little I should do in a CM education!  I’m trying to back off our plans a bit so my DC can make connections with what they learn.  

    I also spend too much time looking ahead…It’s so fun to curriculum browse and organize books for the next year.  When I actually go to HS my DC, it doesn’t always live up to my ideals of HSing.  My DC complain and get rowdy instead of listening intently (like I imagine they will).  Our lessons are constantly interrupted by phone calls, DH needing me to find something at the last minute, illnesses, etc.  The reality of HSing is hard work!  I’m also a “schedule-holic”.  There a running joke in our family about how many HS schedules we’ve had for the year.  Ideally we are supposed to change our scedule with the new term…I change ours every week or two.  Granted, they aren’t big changes, but it takes quite a bit of time to type a pretty new schedule up.  Time I could be spending on much more needed tasks (like housework, laundry, or just reading a book).

    One thing I’ve done to help get it all done is have a must-do list: phonics, math, literature, scripture memory, SCM history guide, and narration.  Then I have our “must get to a few times a week” list: science, Latin, lanuage arts.  After that, I try to add at least one “fun” topic: nature study, picture study, art, poetry, etc.  Then when interruptions happen, I feel like we’ve still accomplished a lot.  The 2nd helpful thing has been to let go of getting it all done.  I used to dread science, but then I gave myself “permission” to skip over parts I didn’t want to do.  If there is a very involved science experiment or notebooking page and I’m too tired to get it started, it’s okay for me to skip it!  Now, I don’t dread pulling out our science book and it actually gets done.  

    I’ve also been re-reading how to implement CM’s methods.  So often I make them more complicated then they need to be.  Picture study doesn’t have to be about adding in related art projects, biographies of the artist, or a long detailed coversation about what everything in the picture means.  Nature study doesn’t have to involve lots of field guides and art supplies.  Yet I tend to think we need all the extras for it to be carried out.  By re-reading what it “should” be, I have been able to simplify our day quite a bit.  I’m still working at this!

    Well said, Holly! I know that I build things up in my mind to be harder/more involved than they need to be… particularly when I’ve gotten out of the habit of doing them. 

    I’m picturing in my mind the way I feel when the kitchen table (or whatever obvious flat surface) is cluttered. The feeling I get when I walk into a room — and definitely when I walk into our home — and am greeted with all of that clutter. Ugh. Even if the stuff has a reason for being there: It weighs me down, dampens the light within me. Contrast that “ugh” feeling to walking in to a room and my eyes beholding a clear flat surface with perhaps a well-chosen thing of beauty. (I just bought a bunde of daffodils for such a purpose and I never do that! But why not?? Surely even on a tight budget I can justify spending $2-$3 even just once a month for a thing of beauty?) Or just have that empty space. The resultiing feeling is that I feel uplifted and open and joyful. 

    I think it’s similar for me with having too many books. (Yes, I cannot believe I actually said “too many books”!) Of course everyone is different, and I really love having books around, but I think for me there is definitey a line of “too many” that is a similar overload. Too many choices; too many things left undone; too much sensory clutter. Now I would put actual classic literature in a separate category, but for curriculum choices and even children’s books — the “up to the rafters” that Jenni mentioned is counterproductive for me. And my kids. 

    Case in point: my 8yo was with me for a bit at the hs convention last week and we were wandering through some vendor booths. We came across Clare Walker Lesley’s “Keeping a Nature Journal” and my dd commented on how pretty it looked. OK, seriously? That book has been on one of the most frequented bookshelves, at her eye level, since this past AUGUST and she has never once looked at it. Didn’t even know we owned it. Of course, on the bookshelf you are looking at a 1/2″ green binding among oodles of other bindings…I mean, the font for the title is pretty, I guess, but ya…never been pulled off the shelf.  Now of course I specifically put it there because I wanted to be more likely to use it this school year, but that hasn’t happened. And with so many books, this example typifies the issue. 

    I feel a surge of clearing out coming through my home today.

    I read a really good article last week which doesn’t speak EXACTLY to this issue, but perhaps is somewhat related. She is talking about “fitting everything in” by keeping it simple and not trying too hard (with some practical examples of how to do so.) As a recovering over-planner, I found it really beautiful and inspiring.http://ohpeacefulday.blogspot.com/2013/04/fitting-in-nice-bits.html

    Jen…this.is.so.good. Thanks so much for sharing! My better “seasons” of homeschooling look a lot like this and I really want to be back there. And stay there. All the time. Love the specific examples she shared as well.

     

    ETA: I am so sorry that my posts ramble on and get so ridiculously long. Another thing to work at improving! 

    Jenni
    Participant

    Wow! You all came at that from so many different directions, all of which sound just like me. Thank you each for sharing this burden and sharing your tips. Lots of amazing ideas and info here. The one thing I always am, consistently, is overwhelmed. I think the decluttering as we face yet another move is definitely key. And I do think I have a “perfect” way of how school should look lurking about in my brain. I know our schooling never looks like this ideal way that I hold on to, but it does certainly get the job done pretty well most of the time. Academically, my dds are both in great shape. Habits are lacking (good ones, anyway) for all of us, so besides elimnating the excess, I’m going to focus on habits all summer.

    Looks like LDTR for Children is in my future! Perfect timing as usual!

    Thank you again, everyone! What a great help and encouragement!

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • The topic ‘OT: severe lack of implementation’ is closed to new replies.