I am struggling with my Math choices for my 1st grader. She is I’d say average in Math…I haven’t seen her excel or do poorly…we didn’t do a lot in K5 though so I’m not sure once more is introduced how she will do.
I had planned on doing Saxon but now selling that b/c I don’t believe it’s quite right for us and it intimidated me for some reason. I have started Apples with her from Fred and we love it. I’m concerned, however, that it won’t be “enough”…I, of course, can add games and activities to reinforce but still unsure.
We are in the process of moving and our new state will require testing for 3rd grade…I’m not sure Fred will be enough, if nothing else but for how it’s presented.
I was looking at MUS but not sure that I “get it”…it seems confusing to me when I see the way it’s taught. I’m good w/ numbers but not really good w/ math concepts, if that makes sense.
Cathy Duffy’s review introduced me to Math Mammoth and it interested me. It’s not CM but I’m okay if it is really the right pgm. She is not keen on worksheets she says, but wouldn’t any kid say that? And MUS has worksheets also…but she likes that they have the minupulatives also. But she has no concept of what it’s like at all.
Any MM users out there to give me some practical experience. I read that it’s harder than a typical math pgm and I’m afraid it’ll be too much for my 6 y/o. I’ve also read that there’s a lot of mental math and while she’s doing some of this already she hasn’t memorized ANYTHING and does not know any place values. I don’t want her to feel overwhelmed or pushed too hard.
I am obsessing about this decision too much but I have already bought 3 math books…Saxon (which is on ebay right now), Math Lessons for a Living Ed (just not quite right for us), and Fred. Fred is STAYING but in adding more to that…that’s where I’m stalled out!
Any experience would be a huge blessing!