Doug and LindseyD- So helpful to know about not worrying too much about punctuation.
She typically misses about two words and two punctuations -unless the whole thing is copied three days in a row.Doug SmithKeymaster
I was actually wondering how many words she doesn’t already know how to spell before studying and dictation. That’s an indicator of how well the difficulty of the material matches her skills. Once I know that I can give you a few tips for success.
Oh, ok. Well, depending on the passage, anywhere from one to three words.BookwormParticipant
This is NOT strictly CM, but here is one thing I do for longer passages for the punctiation part. I agree, punctuation is not a deal-breaker here, but I do like my kids to get a feel for where the punctuation goes. So I do the dictation through once, phrase by phrase; they write and spell the words correctly and put in what punctuation they can. I grade what they have done then, leaving the punctuation aside except to tell them when they do it correctly. THEN if necessary, I read through it ONE MORE TIME. They are not allowed to change anything but punctuation; I read the passage with expression and try to convey with the reading where the punctuation goes (easier with more modern passages, many older writers were very profligate with punctuation!) Then if they still don’t get it all, we just add it in as the passage was written and file the paper. I think over time this helps them get a sense of where punctuation OUGHT to go; I agree tons of good reading is also key, but just like it’s hard to find a place when you’ve only been driven there, and not driven it yourself, sometimes it’s harder to pay attention to the “signs” when you’ve only been led, and not done the “work” yourself. Just a thought in case it helps someone.Doug SmithKeymaster
One to three words is great. If she were up over four or five words then you might have to slow down or take smaller chunks.
If you’re not already doing so, make sure she first identifies words she doesn’t know how to spell when starting a new lesson. Then she can practice those words in a variety of ways to help learn them well. Copywork may be helpful, but it covers all the words. A little focus on just the unknown words may bring greater success.
OK! Thanks for your input. I think that this will work well.
I am starting to see the benefit now of using Delightful Reading’s teaching methods – teaches your child to use those vision skills from the very start.
We are using DR with our 6 and 4 year old kids. They will have those visual skills much more established. Thanks SCM!
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.