Is this narration too long?? Please advise.

Tagged: 

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • my3boys
    Participant

     

     

    This narration is from my 9yo.  I wrote as he narrated, then typed it out so he could put it in his notebook.  Is this narration too long?  Should he be or not be “speaking” for the characters??  And,  is this considered “in his own words”?  And, he loves changing his voice to fit the characters and “how” the characters would’ve sounded if they were really speaking.  I put the “speaking” parts in quoatation marks because he asked me if I got that “so and so” said whatever.   If you can make it through the whole narration, please give me some feedback.  He also gave me a 3-4 sentence condensed narration that he will copy and draw a picture from, as well (his choice).  Thanks in advance.

     

    The Runaway Water Spider

    There’s this spider and she has some eggs and they are all going to hatch soon.  She needed to go get some food before they hatched all the way, where they came out. Well, they came out while the mom was still getting food.  Mr. Stickleback told Mrs. Water Spider that her babies were crying for her.  And she said, “Oh, no, I need to get over there real quick!” Well, she still needed to pack up some food and it took her a while to finish. 

    The baby water spiders were crying for a long time and they wanted to go out of their house to go see where their mom was.  So the oldest baby of them all said, “How ‘bout we just go out and find our mom and we’ll be safe with her.” But all of the other water spider babies said, “No, we can’t because mom said, while we were in our eggs, that we have to stay until she comes back from getting food.” The oldest water spider baby said, “No, she didn’t. You guys are just too scared to go out there, aren’t you?” They all went out and got lost.  They ended up on a lily pad.  And some ducks passed by them and some dragon flies flew over them.  They all said, “Aren’t you babies too young to be out here without your mom?”  The babies didn’t answer at all.  Why they didn’t answer was because the babies knew that the ducks and dragon flies were not their own kind.  They jumped off the lily pad and swam over to where Mr. Stickleback is at.  And Mr. Stickleback said, “Hey, I just met your mother over there and she’s getting food for you guys. She told me that you guys are such good little babies staying at your home, but now I’m going to go tell your mom that you guys aren’t at your house.  And, tell her that you guys are over here with me by the turtle pond.”  And, Mr. Stickleback said to stay there and he would get their mom.  The babies said okay. And, so he went off over there to where she is at and told her, “Mrs. Water Spider, your babies are over by the turtle pond.   You might want to go over with me to see what’s going on.” So Mrs. Water Spider said, “Okay, Mr. Stickleback, let me go put my food in my house and I’ll be right there.”  

    Mrs. Water Spider followed Mr. Stickleback to the turtle pond where her babies were.  And she said to her babies, “Babies come over here and let’s go to our house.  Thank you Mr. Stickleback for taking care of my babies while I was gone.”

    They were at their house and Mrs. Water Spider told them, “None of you shall do that again or you will not get any supper.”  She wanted to know who was to blame for going off into the water, since they were just little babies.  And all the water spider babies said, “It was the oldest, he’s the one that told us we could go out there.” She said, “Okay, so you’re the one to blame.” And he said, “No, we were just peaking out the door and the water pushed us out into the big, open world.” She said, “Okay.” The little water spider babies said, “No, mama, he’s lying.”  The oldest water baby said, “They’re right, I lied.”  And the mom forgave him.

    The End.

    suzukimom
    Participant

    It looks great to me. I haven’t read the original, but it looks like a good amount of detail and it looks like their own words. I’d love to get a narration like that from my son.

    Bookworm
    Participant

    This is delightful.  I love that he does voices, too.  Did he make up the dialogue, and you are wondering if that is OK?  Did he invent things that never happened, or did he just explain them in such a way that the characters talked with each other even though they didn’t in the original?  If that is the case, it is FINE.  It means he’s thinking imaginatively about the reading.  If he makes up wholesale lots of events that never happened, I usually wait a little bit, then bring up casually in conversation “Did this-and-that from your narration REALLY TRULY  happen in the story?”  Just to make sure they are really clear on what did and did not happen.  I will sometimes (my son that did this the most is my oldest and he hasn’t done it for a while) tell him that I want a narration of what REALLY happened, then I’d love to hear him say what he WISHES happened, just to make sure he is clear on the difference.  He usually is, but imaginative kids do sometimes like to add their own flourishes and I’m OK with that if they know the difference (probably because I do that myself, lol)  To cultivate the habit of truthfulness, you do want to get him to say what REALLY did occur and what he  made up.   But if he is just “explaining” the story by adding dialogue between the characters, with funny voices, because that is the way he likes to do it, then that is just fine. 

    my3boys
    Participant

    Oh, man, I just wrote out a huge response and my computer froze, ugh!

    Oh, well.  Thank you so much for your responses.  And, yes, those were my concerns, Michelle. He can barely give a narration without the additional dialogue, but this one really did have dialogue and he said it was true to the story (I didn’t actually read the chap.) We’ve been working on truthfulness (within the narrations), starting at the beginning and working our way through the narration to keep on track. It seems to be working, yeah!  He is definitely my imaginative child…he wants to be a ventriloquist, plays with puppets and always using voices for his characters (whether they’re his own creations or from our reg. readings). 

    I just wasn’t really sure if we were on the right track.  We’ll just keep doing what we’re doing, thanks so much.

    Now, I may send one of my oldest’s narrations….his are much more fact-based, not a whole lot of imagination going on with that child.  He’s 12, so I’m guessing his should be more true to the reading, with some additional thoughts/feelings incorporated???  He has a more difficult  time with words (written or spoken) so I need to work with him more, which I am.  I know he can do it,  he just needs more time and sometimes the right book, it seems, to narrate from.  Would you agree??

    Thanks so much for the feedback.  This information is so helpful to me and I’m sure will be to others:)

     

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • The topic ‘Is this narration too long?? Please advise.’ is closed to new replies.