easy readers vs regular picture books

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • mama_nickles
    Participant

    My DD is 5.5 and we have been working our way through the Pathway Readers this year. She enjoyed the first set, and we recently started Busy Times, but she is becoming resistant. I have several of the leveled easy readers, and she doesn’t seem to enjoy them much. Maybe she knows they are kind of fake? Anyway, I stumbled across having her read “regular” picture books and she is so excited about it! I think she likes seeing progress (she can read one in 1-2 days) and she feels like she is reading “real” books. Is there a downside to having her work on reading this way? Obviously it’s not systematic, but she does have a good foundation of vowel and consonant blends, and seems to be able to work through multi-syllable words (today she read “following”). Can we just keep this up?

    FWIW, I also have a “spectrum phonics” workbook that we do a few pages per week that she seems to enjoy. So she is getting some reinforcement there.

    retrofam
    Participant

    I am not an expert,  but I say go with her interests! My oldest used young Children’s picture Bibles for reading.

    Like you said,  she is also using a phonics workbook, so that should be fine.

    Enjoy the freedom of homeschooling:)

    Wings2fly
    Participant

    We have used Sonlight readers which are “real books”.  We did most of them, but not all.  You can get many of them at the library.  My children also enjoyed reading Eric Carle books.

    http://www.sonlight.com/subjects/readers/readers-2/

    http://www.sonlight.com/subjects/readers/readers-3/

    Melissa Wolfe
    Participant

    Early in his reading journey, my son really enjoyed and benefited from early readers (namely Miss Rhonda’s Readers — he loved those! — and some Rod & Staff readers). He started becoming less enthused and a little resistant to other early readers; he even started asking if this was a “real” book or a book for kids learning how to read!

    He turned a corner when we got a collection of Usborne phonics readers — they are a lot of fun and have a story line. We cozied up on the floor together that night the book first came, him reading on and on so we could find out what would happen (staying up way past his normal bedtime!). From then on I changed my focus from “let’s sit down and practice reading” to having a fun and relaxed time of sharing a story together. So we pulled out picture books and read together. For longer ones we’d take turns; he’d read a page, then I’d read a page.  Or we’d pick a verse or a short psalm from the Bible. It wasn’t long before he was reading anything he got his hands on.

    I do like Miss Rhonda’s Readers and the Usborne phonics readers for a start, which are fun and build confidence. Beyond that, now I heartily believe in using “real” books for learning how to read, once a foundation has been laid with phonics.

    Happy reading adventures together!

    Melissa 🙂

    BlessedMommy
    Participant

    I’m so glad I read this thread. I have been humming & hawing over a new reader set since my 7 yr. old really needs more fluency practice before progressing further in her current readers (Reading-Literature by Free & Treadwell). But, the more samples I read online, I know they will not spark excitement for her. So I was already leaning towards using regular books.

    I love the idea of using the Sonlight list via Library. Are there any other lists that would work well too?

    I just LOVE your input Melissa! My ultimate focus right now is to bring that spark back for my daughter. She used to have so much joy and excitement over waking up and starting school and she would beam with pride over reading & she would read & read. Over the last 18 months or so, she has lost most of that spark. (I think a lot of it had to do with moving away from home (to TX from FL…18 months ago) but, now we are back home, praise God!). So I’m really backing up a bit and re-evaluating EVERYTHING aside from Math & handwriting.

    Anyways, I’m excited for the changes I will be making and thankful for this thread which is in a way validating what my heart has been leading me to do. ☺️

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)
  • The topic ‘easy readers vs regular picture books’ is closed to new replies.