BF has wonderful book selections that could certainly form the main curriculum or be additions to another curriculum. DS11 will use their Modern World and US History as his curriculum next year for 6th grade. We will tweak the guide as we see fit, but use the book selections. DD8 will finish their Primary History as her curriculum next year. She will begin the Geography study (4 books) and use the Barefoot Meandering 50 States guide with them. This will be a 2-3 year study for her. My older kids simply read and narrated through the Holling books, but I have since found the 50 States guide and think this dd will enjoy it.
I LOVE the Visits to books. We have completed Africa, Middle East, and will do Europe next. We are now doing geography as part of our CM co-op and the Visits books are the basis. We modify and do the study in 24 weeks in the co-op, but it works very, very well. All kids age 6 and up complete the study.
Either the BF Geography study or the Visits To study would be enough. DD8 will simply get 2 studies, but one spread out quite a bit.
I have used all 6 of SCM’s modules as written and have thoroughly enjoyed them. I could have used them a 2nd time through as they are intended, but simply chose something different for no other reason than wanting to try something different. I think the SCM modules are one of many excellent choices available to us.
Hope that helps.
Christie