Advice on Simplifying/Purging School Room

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Brandi
    Participant

    Hi! Can any of you encourage me? I have several boxes of older teaching aids, supplies, books you name it. My gut is telling me just, get rid of all of it! This will be our first year of TRULY sticking with a curriculum, and we’re doing SCM, plus a phonics program I already have and Mammoth Math. I have 2 children ages 4.5 and almost 6. So we have a long road ahead of us! But if my heart wants to keep it simple, can I get rid of this stuff and not regret it later?! Someone share with me your experience and take on purging items you most likely won’t use…but just might! 🙂

    Sue
    Participant

    In my experience (my oldest just graduated, the youngest starts 10th grade this year), my need for some items changed over the years, so I certainly don’t miss those things at all, such as workbooks & readers from early years, crafty things for younger kids, curriculum that we’ve outgrown.  Other things we did save, and I’d have to say maybe only half of them got used at some point.  I think that in your gut, you will know what you might really, really use.  The rest is usually just “second-guessing myself” as I hang onto stuff as though I’m going to beat myself up if I need it and it’s gone.

    For me, that is really a mindset of poverty, or perhaps a fear of poverty, and as a Christian, that only serves to undermine my trust in God’s ability to provide.  I try (and keep trying!) to overcome that kind of thinking.  Giving things away–or selling them cheaply–has been a good way to both purge and overcome impoverished thinking.

    A few years back, a dad I had recently met told me his son’s story over a series of emails.  His son, aged 5, had just been diagnosed with type 1 diabetes.  With it came great difficulties in managing his blood sugar levels, and it affected his schoolwork, even at the kindergarten level. The dad recounted the struggle to work with the public school to both manage his son’s health during the school day, but they also insisted that the boy was having academic and developmental delays unrelated to his medical issues.  The dad felt that if the school could better address the medical needs throughout the day, his son would achieve much more in other areas.  As the school staff became more difficult to work with, he decided to pull his son out of school and begin homeschooling.  It would mean having his wife quit her job to stay at home, and they also felt overwhelmed at the prospect of directing and implementing their son’s education.

    I tell you all of this because, as I was made aware of the situation, I offered encouragement and suggestions of how to begin homeschooling, materials to read about it all, and I searched through those largley untouched shelves of things I’d saved “just in case” that I knew I really did not need.  I offered him a variety of books, materials, manipulatives, etc. that I thought a family homeschooling a first- or second-grader could use.  They were so blessed and grateful.  They started off on the journey, and several months later, the dad let me know that not only was school going well at home, but his son’s health was improving.

    That’s all I needed to hear to know that it was much better for me to let go than to hang onto too many things.  I think that most of us try to be prudent in what we acquire for homeschooling, but I also think we could apply that same type of thinking to the decision of what to keep. If the stuff we have is causing us more work and more stress as we have to dust it, file it, pile it, store it, sort it, store it somewhere else, spend time and money finding greater storage solutions…..then our stuff is controlling us instead of us controlling our stuff.

    HTH,

    Sue

    2Corin57
    Participant

    I used to be where you are now. I purged a LOT. And here’s why:

    50 years ago, 100 years ago… there was none of this stuff. Don’t get me wrong, all these nice manipulatives and workbooks, and other aides are fun, pretty and feel good to have, I think probably even many of us feel a measure of pride when we look at our shelves, seeing everything we’ve accumulated. But, I’d wager 99% of it is 100% unnecessary. Teachers (and parents) successfully educated their children with nothing more than a slate, piece of chalk, a book, a ruler, and some beans or pebbles for counters. That’s it. And honestly, educated them more successfully than most children are being educated today (arithmetic and reading was much better “back in the day”).

    We don’t need all that stuff. All we need are the aforementioned items, and confidence in ourselves. While the internet and support groups have their place, they also largely serve to create large amounts of doubt in our ability as teachers, and I can also see how they lead us to buy far more than we need. We see advertisements and discussion of this curriculum or that manipulative or resource, and it plants that seed of doubt, or sometimes just envy… and the next thing you know, we’ve convinced ourselves we need it.

    If your heart is crying out for simplicity, then perhaps that is God speaking to you, and trying to direct you. We are a culture of way too much stuff, homeschoolers are no exception, in fact, probably we’re some of the biggest offenders 😉 Let go of the excess, and get back to basics. If you find down the road you truly need something, then you can purchase it then. But I’ve learned in homeschooling, in life, there is no value in holding onto things because “I might use these someday.”

    Also, if you’re on a journey for trying to simplify things in the home, I cannot recommend enough reading the book Simplicity Parenting.

    my3boys
    Participant

    I have been purging (selling/give away) a lot lately. I have not regretted one sale. It has blessed another family (especially if it was inexpensive) and blessed us financially. I have been able to purchase some other items/books we needed and get rid of the books we. are. never. going. to. read.

    Seeing our shelves a little less stuffed has been amazing and I can’t wait to see how far we can go with this and still offer a quality education to our children. (I have saved some special books for the grand-kids;)

    Plus, if you wait too long, the 1st, 2nd, 3rd editions will become harder to sell (unless it’s some obscure oop book that everybody has to have, today!). I figured I might as well sell while the books were still wanted and in good condition.

    I have no regrets and plan to sell more and more. Now, I’m asking myself if we really need this book or that book or maybe we’ll just get the free Kindle edition. I feel like I’m making better “quality” choices for my children, if that makes sense.

    And, I see the mound of books (mostly the ones that I thought I wanted in our “library” that my kids never read) as just a mound of books that I need to “deal” with. Not fun. I’m excited about this and as it has freed up my mind and space on our shelves 🙂

    Tristan
    Participant

    I’ll chime in a ping on the other side – I keep items that I’m pretty sure we’ll use in the future.  A hefty amount.  I do try not to have multiple resources for the exact same thing (ex: I don’ keep three early American history curriculums, I keep one. I don’t keep four science curricula for elementary ages, I keep 1 or 2 we love). BUT part of that is because I’m raising 9 children and the odds are huge that we really will reuse something multiple times.

    With that said, I do sell or pass on many items if we used them and just didn’t love them.  If I didn’t love an item for the first child or two I’m not likely to love it more on the eighth or ninth child. 😉  What doesn’t work for us may be exactly what someone else will love.

    erin.kate
    Participant

    We live in a very small space with two adults and four children and so saving much is not an option. A year ago I piled every home school resource I had onto the living room floor and made stacks of save, sell, gift. I only saved something if I was absolutely certain I would use it with at least one child and that it would not add to the same curricula that I already use and love … for instance, we use ULW for written narration guidance so I would not save W&R *just in case* I might follow that lead for writing at some point.

    I ended up selling about $2000 of “stuff” in maybe two days on various facebook groups … I have zero regrets about purging. 🙂

    I gifted many things to local friends who needed what I had more than I ever did.

    What I saved went into organized storage bins … one bin per subject … such as, history, biography, nature study, geography, art & music study, etc. The bins are labeled and they sit in a tiny storage space with holiday decorations and suitcases and things that are necessaries but are impossible to fit in our small home and they are books that I rotate, often depending on era of study or focus of science, etc.

    I found that last year was our best year of homeschooling yet … in large part because I used what I had on hand and thus came to know and love it well. I didn’t have endless curricula sitting around beckoning me from every room. 😉 I wasn’t pulled in this or that direction and I vowed not to buy *anything* unless something could be sold *and* I would not change course on what we started for school.

    I now have one large bookcase in the main part of our home with a dedicated shelf per subject … Bible, poetry, field guides, FIAR, mama resources, a shelf per child for daily work, read alouds, classic literature, historical fiction, natural history, etc. That is *all* of the school that holds space in my home and I adore the simplicity and tidiness of it. We also have a cute art cart/caddy with casters from IKEA that holds our art supplies. We school at the kitchen table or the couches and it works seamlessly for us, but until I let go of many many many books and resources it was a bit stifling here.

    God always provides, we just have to let Him go before us.

    Rebekah
    Participant

    I struggle with this one as well. With four kids, I figure I will be reusing stuff. But which stuff? This past year i did ancients with my oldest two kids. I’m sure at some point I will be doing ancients again with the younger two, so I need to keep the books we really enjoyed. But wait, will they be this young when we do ancients again? Or older? And what about the books I collected but decided were too old for my kids and we didn’t use? Do I save them for the older kids to read next time? Are they even books worth storing for six years?

    I need to purge my LA stuff, but can’t decide how I want to teach my last kid to read. Lol. I have all of AAR that I’m using with my second child, and have sort of used with my third. I’m tired of it and all its pieces (in fact that’s why I’m dropping it with my third kid, who is picking everything up on his own, and just continuing it with the kid who actually needs it). But after a break, I might be able to do it again. And it is open and go. I also have some pathways workbooks that my kids have used parts of (I should get rid of these, my older boys couldn’t handle the amount of writing and I’m sure my youngest won’t either), ABCs and all their tricks (never used), and of course Reading Lessons Through Literature- which I’m using for spelling, but obviously could be used to teach reading.

    I have (almost) managed to get rid of all math books besides MUS. I am trying to let go of stuff that isn’t working for us now, not keeping it just in case it will work in the future.

    Rebekah
    Participant

    This will be our first year of TRULY sticking with a curriculum, and we’re doing SCM, plus a phonics program I already have and Mammoth Math. I have 2 children ages 4.5 and almost 6.

    This part of your post struck me… This past year was our first year of truly sticking with a curriculum, and there’s a certain peace that comes with just sticking with something that works for you. I’ve finally come to realize: 1- there are lots of equally good options, 2- I won’t be able to use them all, 3- if I stick with one of the good options, lI can use my energy teaching and enjoying my kids instead of researching curriculum.

    If you have just two kids and SCM is working for you, stick with it. You know your family dynamic and that’s not going to change much (unless you have more kids. Lol). Maybe some day, like middle school or high school, you may need a change. But even if you do, will it really be this old stuff you have stored? You don’t know what will work for your kids that far in the future. And even if it would work, is it worth storing for 6+ years? Or can you repurchase it used then, if you really wanted it?

    I’m tempted to say if that old school stuff isn’t working for you now, it’s not going to work for you later either.

    Brandi
    Participant

    Thanks a million times for all the help above!!

    I feel empowered to go face those boxes now. I was given about 10 bank boxes, and while I immediately purged about half, I still have too much down there.

    My sister taught 4th grade for 11 years and is now in her 5th year of principalship. Although she is very conservative and also supports my homeschooling 110%, I hear her dropping certain lingo that makes me totally second guess if I’m going to be giving them the best education by doing so minimally!

    I mean, the amount of curriculum, resources, manipulatives, books, techniques….ugh!! I’m trying so hard not to let myself drown.

    You’re all correct. I need to get back before The Lord with this and allow Him to charge this thing!

    Thank you so much for guiding me back to the Holy Spirit’s past promptings as well.

    ((HUGS))

    Brandi

     

     

    Aimee
    Participant

    Since we’re on the topic…Do I remember a blog post from Erin.Kate that showed her beautiful house and school room? Or am I thinking of someone else? If so, I’d love to see that again if anyone has the link.?

    Michelle
    Participant

    ” I hear her dropping certain lingo that makes me totally second guess if I’m going to be giving them the best education by doing so minimally!”

     

    My MIL is also a teacher and has been for YEARS. She is always telling me about the latest online program they are using in school and games and stuff. She even mentioned that she worried about my oldest (8y) being behind math because we only use Life of Fred. Never mind that it took me 3 years to find a curriculum that worked for us and she spent all  last year going over all the LOF books.

    I recently gave her back all the school (out of circ) textbooks because I don’t need them.

    We homeschoolers know more about HOMESCHOOL than a public school teacher does so we should not second guess ourself. Of course they use manipulatives in school, they are attempting to teach multiple kids and keep their attention and do not get the amazing opportunity to let God lead them for a few kids (by few I mean the 4 I will be teaching because I am due in December!).

    I too have gone on a nice declutter/ KISS method and this year we will stick mainly to SCM. I even choose to skip our history that we loved so much because it was pricier and I wanted to give SCM a try and get more living books. You will learn much in the next few years. I keep things for a year or two, but as it was mentioned, if one kid didn’t like it, should I keep it for the next one? -Maybe…maybe not.

    erin.kate
    Participant

    Oh, thanks, Aimee! This was the post from a while back, and since then I’ve actually cleared out the dining room so it’s just that, a space for family means (and school at the table). We no longer have a bookshelf or any baskets or the timeline in there … all cleaned out. I should take a few new pictures. 🙂

    http://marmaladesorrow.weebly.com/blog/an-atmosphere

     

    erin.kate
    Participant

    I just took these (on my phone). In case you’re curious, we live in 1300sf with 2 adults, 4 kids, 2 dogs, and 10 chickens (well, the hens are outside, ha).

    Space is at a premium around here and creativity is a must … so is trusting the Lord with our needs now and later.

    http://marmaladesorrow.weebly.com/blog/multum-non-multa-at-home

    Rebekah
    Participant

    That looks so nice! We are in a similar situation, two adults four kids a dog 1200sf. Now I feel like decluttering. Lol. My dining area is lined with book shelves, but it works for us. It’s a room with a lot of walkways and wall space, so it doesn’t work for much, but it does work for shelves. On the plus side my living room is school free 😀

    erin.kate
    Participant

    I love that, Rebekah. I think having a space … any space … dedicated to living well without school stuff can especially imbue the atmosphere of your home with peace. If only I could get that art caddy out of the dining room, lol.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • The topic ‘Advice on Simplifying/Purging School Room’ is closed to new replies.