Amy,
I’ve used both TQ and BF and found strengths/weaknesses with each. I have blogged about our use of each extensively, including book reviews. Most recently, I’ve been combining BF and TQ and I think it’s the perfect fit. However, this was after much trial and error so I would not necessarily recommend it to a newcomer. You can read that post here to see what I like about each program…
http://reflectionsfromdrywoodcreek.blogspot.com/2015/07/combining-truthquest-history-and.html
You can also click either Beautiful Feet or TruthQuest on the side bar labels and see all the other posts I’ve done regarding these programs.
With that said, I think for your first year of CM, I would recommend BF or SCM. This will allow you time to focus on basic CM methods such as habit training, narration, and copywork, rather than worrying over which books to choose. As you go along, if you find the reading too light, you can always add more. However, if you’re overwhelmed with choices from the get go, it will be frustrating.
One other suggestion I have is A Visual American History Timeline of Books…
http://reflectionsfromdrywoodcreek.blogspot.com/2015/07/a-visual-amercian-history-timeline-of.html
This gives you cover images of great American history books from the earliest settlements to modern times. Not only does it make it easier for you to find books, but your kids will remember the books you read and be able to sequence them in history. Our dd, age 11, has memorized the timeline for fun. She’s very knowledgeable about historic events and where they fit time wise. It’s like a visual Book of Centuries.
Hope you find some help here…
Many Blessings,
Melissa