Would you use "Meet the Great Composers"

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • delightx7
    Participant

    by Montgomery and Hinson? I am trying to stay focused on truly using CM’s methods for my 13,11,9,7, and 4 yos.

    http://www.christianbook.com/Christian/Books/product?item_no=16908

    Would you or have you used this resource?  Is it CM friendly?  Or would you just scrap it and do something completely different altogether?

    I could really use some imput!

    Thanks, Robin

     

     

    Sonya Shafer
    Moderator

    Robin, at first glance the writing in the book seems more textbookish. You might be able to spend more time getting to know each composer if you do something like the Opal Wheeler biographies combined with simply listening to music by that composer. Zeezok has republished the Opal Wheeler composer biographies, and some of them come with a corresponding CD as well. You might take a look at those as a possible alternative.

    Hopefully, someone who has more experience with Meet the Great Composers can chime in here with more details. It’s so hard to get a good feel for something with only 1 page to read.

    We did not care for Meet the Great Composers, we found it rather too brief and too workbooky.  The girls wanted more information and thought the book just skimmed the surface – so requested something different.  We just listened to music from the composer we were studying and read Spiritual Lives of the Great Composers among other books we found for that subject.   It was easy for us because as someone who loves classical music I had a lot of CDs and DVDs of music and opera etc – however the public library will usually have a lot of CDs that can be borrowed, and music can be heard online as well.  We spent a lot of time on the composers we really liked and skimmed some others.  Some composers like artists, led rather controversial lives, so it pays to be discerning about books and bios if that bothers you at all.  Maybe someone else has another idea on Meet the Great Composers, but for us it was not sufficient.  Blessings, Linda

    delightx7
    Participant

    Thanks, Ladies.  I really appreciate your imput.  I think it is tempting because it appears to be an inexpensive way to cover the composers (whom I personally know nothing about), but I really want to stick to CM’s methods.  Thanks again.

     

    Robin

    Sonya Shafer
    Moderator

    I didn’t know much about composers when we started either, Robin. (And I had taken piano for several years.) It really helped to change my thinking from “covering the composers” to “getting to know” one composer at a time. So we found a CD with the music of one composer. (I think we started with Beethoven, because he was one I knew from piano lessons.) It wasn’t all of his music, but it was enough to give us a feel for his style. We listened to that CD in the van when running errands or sometimes during lunch or sometimes I played it while I was fixing supper and the kids were within earshot. I just told them, “Let’s listen to some Beethoven,” and started the CD. After about six weeks, we switched to a different composer and repeated the process. Nothing elaborate or formal. Just getting to know each one’s music and style.

    If I could find a good living biography about the composer we were listening to, I would read it aloud one or two days a week. But usually we just listened to his music. With this method, we got to know about six different composers each year. Multiply that times five or six years of doing this simple technique, and you’ll get to know thirty or thirty-five different composers. 

    Oh, and even if you can’t find a good living biography, be sure to put each composer in your Book of Centuries. That’s a fascinating exercise to see what was happening during each one’s lifetime. You can find out their life years by checking Wikipedia or some other online reference.

    If you want a list to get you started, here is a list of many of the composers that we listened to over the years (and still do). Many of them have become “old friends” now. Smile

    hsmom22
    Participant

    What a great approach!  So simple and effective.  It makes me realize that I may be over-thinking in other areas, too.  Time to simplify!  What a relief, and a savings!  Thanks, Sonya!

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • The topic ‘Would you use "Meet the Great Composers"’ is closed to new replies.