Hi Kristen..
Thanks for asking this question; as I enjoyed reading everyone’s response.:-)
Early on, we decided to tell our kids the truth about Santa. (and every other holiday make believe character too) However, we do read St Nicholas and my kids seem to have no problem ‘imagining’ Santa is real and enjoying it. They really do enjoy the make believe of it all and we feel it is harmless since we do WAY more things to celebrate Jesus’ coming and birthday. I have no doubt our children know exactly what Christmas is about. We do a daily devotion with a Jesse Tree, we sing hymns, and we also do an advent wreath devotion on Sundays. (We are non-denominational Christian, but I grew up Catholic. I always enjoyed the teaching behind the advent month and preparing one’s heart for the coming.)
I like them to concentrate on giving. Some years we do Operation Christmas Child, Adopt a family, sing at nursing home, and this year we are making a goodie tin for neighbors, post man, ups man, piano teacher, babysitter etc… We made beeswax candles, and all paleo Christmas snacks. 🙂
Some years I definitely get into the decorating more than others. With little ones, their momentum kind of ‘lifts you up’ and gets you going. This year, my kids asked for Christmas music the DAY after Thanksgiving. (They know I don’t do anything Christmas, not even shop, a day before Thanksgiving.) ha! 🙂 Now that they are older, they know exactly what holidays are when.
However, I do teeter btw wanting less. Especially, when it seems the world has completely lost site of what is important. It really does drive me crazy.. We have discussed not having a tree, not putting up lights, but in the end, when I search my heart/soul and listen to the Holy Spirit, I hear that it is all okay as long as it glorifies God and brings Joy.
Like others, our house may be decorated and we may have snowmen and Santa decorations, but Christ and his birthday is weaved throughout all of it!
I think depending on someone’s year, the current state of the family etc… can effect Christmas spirit. Maybe some years there is more, maybe some years there is less. I think that is okay. I think anyone can still have a very merry Christmas without all the decorations; it is just up to the individual family.
Blessings!
Renee