wheter or not to homeschool?

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • April
    Participant

    A friend of mine has been showing an interest in homeschooling, but cannot  make a decision.  I have offered her all the info I can, and she is still back and forth.  I could be completely wrong, but what I am feeling is that this is something God has called her to do, and she is basically just having trouble saying yes because it is not the norm, and while her husband supports her either way, the rest of her family and friends do not.  She had gotten really excited about it then made the mistake of asking everyone in her family and friends….none of which have any expirience with homeschooling and they all basically told her she was selfish and crazy for even considering it.  Now she still keeps telling me she wants to do it but…I’m not good at math, I want to see them in the school Christmas plays, etc.  Her excuses are all basically to justify her decision to send them to school…she told me this herself.  That is what makes me think it is God who put it on her heart and because it is not the norm she cannot say yes.  I by all means do not want to convince her to do it, if she is not called to but does anyone know of any articles, etc that could help her.  I have been searching and I know I read one somewhere about teaching math when you don’t understand it yourself, and I would like to find that one and send it to her.  But I am mostly interested in something that will help her recognize wheter or not God is calling her to do this.  Thanks for any help.

    MamaWebb
    Participant

    Hi April!

    My greatest advice to you would be this:  pray for her. Pray for her to have the strength to listen to the Lord and discern His will.  Tell her you are praying this way for her.  Then do it.

    Also, in the back of the FABULOUS book called Homeschool Supermom…NOT! by Susan Kemmerer there is a wonderful article in the appendix called “A Conviction to Homeschool.”  It is highly Biblical, as is the whole book.  There is another article in the appendix called “Questions to Discuss with my Spouse ABout Homeschooling.”  I think ALL homeschool Mamas need to read this book.  If you don’t own it and don’t know anyone who does either, let me know, and I will copy and mail these articles to you for your friend.  However if you are so inclined, grab your own copy.  I keep mine by my bedside or by my Bible, it’s that good!

    Another thought is that Lisa Welchel book, So You’re Thinking About Homeschooling?  If that is not the title, it’s something similar.  I liked that one when we were first considering homeschooling.

    THere is also A LOT of info online, and I am sure that you could do some Google searches and get some great hits that might be of assistance to your friend.  It is a tough decision, and not one to be taken lightly!

    Hope this Helps!

    Amy

     

    MamaWebb
    Participant

    oh another thought.  Send her to the MAth U See website.  Don’t worry about teaching math – Mr Demme does it for you!  I am not a Math superstar (in fact, I was an English teacher – as far from math as I could get), but watching Mr Demme, then following up in the teacher’s guide made it all pretty easy!

    I am certainly no math scholar and we are almost done with high school using DVDs and dad to help when mum could not – so that can be done and is successful.  Linda

    lakrueger
    Member

    Another wonderful math program is Teaching Textbooks (http://www.teachingtextbooks.com).  They start as young as 3rd grade and use more of a spiral approach than MUS.  We had tried MUS some years ago, before I realized that it wasn’t a good fit for our son at all.  Unfortunately I’m still trying to convince our son that he doesn’t hate math, just the approach that was used in MUS.  Teaching Textbooks have lectures for each lesson and are quite thorough.  Both MUS and TT are great, but one might be better for some than the other.  Just my 2 cents’ worth!

    Linda

    April
    Participant

    Thanks everyone for the suggestions! 

    MamaWebb:  I certainly will be praying for her!  And I am so glad you mentioned those books!  I am going straight to amazon from here!  I can’t wait to read them!  Thanks again!

    I am going to bring this back up. I have a friend who is hands down wants to homeschool.  She has no doubts aobut it. Her husband however does not want to .  Their oldest will start kindy in Auguast.

    They went to their Pastor and he advised them NOT to homeschool!!  It will take a bit to change her hubby’s mind. I told her to keep praying about it and I did when my hubby was not for it.  There are not a lot of similar thinkers where they are.

    I sent my hubby to our Pastor thinking he would tell him that we should homeschool.  Instead he gave him some thought prevoking questions and told him why he chose it for his family and told him that each man has to choose for his famiily.  She was not so “lucky”.

    Any good advice for her or info that is good for hubby to read?

    Thanks

    2flowerboys
    Participant

    A lot of men need facts. I suggest she supply him with some. Look up statistics about homeschool. Go to HSLDA’s website. Also each state should have their own organziation. I found a lot on Georgia’s site. For instance, he can read some books or a book that she chooses about homeschooling. Here are just a few that were listed. 

    • A Field Guide to Home Schooling, by Christine Field
    • Cultural Literacy, by E.D. Hirsch (grades 1-6)
    • For the Children’s Sake, by Susan Schaeffer Macaulay
    • Home Grown Kids, by Raymond and Dorothy Moore
    • Homeschooling by Heart, Kristina Sabalis Krulikas
    • How to Homeschool, by Gayle Graham
    • Language and Thinking for Young Children, by Ruth Beechick
    • Teaching the Trivium, by Harvey and Laurie Bluedorn
    • The Christian Home School, by Gregg Harris
    • The How & Why of Home Schooling, by Ray Ballman
    • The Three R’s (K-3), by Ruth Beechick
    • The Whole Hearted Child, by Clay and Sally Clarkson
    • You Can Teach Your Child Successfully (4-8), by Ruth Beechick

    Another good book that has some statistics is Mary Prides Big Book Of Homeschooling. She could also make a chart of pros and cons. Once again, men see things differently than women.

    She could find some homeschooling families to talk to and introduce him to. If time is not a factor, she could take him to a homeschool convention. Lots of great people, info, and encouragement there! Fears can be melted away!

    Are they considering PS? She could get statistics on PS children and things they are taught and exposed to in today’s world.

    A great website, books, articles for just dads..author who happens to homeschool..is http://www.familymanweb.com  Todd Wilson is a down to earth kind of guy that sheds truth on life and family.

    I would be interested to know why a pastor is so against homeschooling. There are a lot of misconceptions about homeschoolers. We are all backwards people, ya know?? LOL! Maybe, if she is concerned, she could provide her pastor with some info!!

    I have recently heard this about my friend’s pastor. Their church has a Christian school..could it be that he is a little biased because they have a school? My friend’s pastor commented that the con of homeschooling puts pressure on the wife, a.k.a. she has too much to do and gets burned out! Not sure if this was his ONLY reason.

    I can think of more ideas..will PM you later. We have been so sick at our house. Time for me to wrap this up!

    Hope this helps!

    Wanted to add, I am sure she knows this! But to approach hubby with a loving attitude and prayer! 🙂

    Doug Smith
    Keymaster

    You’re right, men do think about things differently so here’s a little bit of a guy’s perspective. There are some good books in that list, but back when I was first learning about homeschooling I probably would have balked at a book with a title like “Homeschooling by Heart”. Smile Actually, I might have preferred just the facts without having to read a whole book.

    Here are some of the kinds of things I would have responded to. It’s all based on data and well footnoted.

     

    lgeurink
    Member

    It took about five years of devoted prayer and fact finding missions on my part to get my husband on board.  He still would prefer our kids to be in school but has told me that he trusts my decision regarding this and thinks I do a wonderful job.  He came from elementary in a Christian school and middle/high school in a public school where he was a great athlete and that really shaped his thoughts on school even though he admits he only graduate b/c of he was a good athlete.  Anyway, I think what helped him was my not nagging, my constant prayers, athletic options for homeschool kids, and our local education stats for both the public and private schools in our area.  It included things like teacher’s wages, how much money is spent per child on their education, test scores, graduation rates, college bound students, GPA’s, etc.  It was shocking to see how much money is spent for kids who end up dropping out, barely graduate, or just have bad grades.  Things are much different in school today then they were fifteen to twenty years ago and once my husband saw that, he started to see the benifits.  We have also decided to take the “one year at a time, one child at a time” approach.  Maybe that would help your friend’s husband if he realized this wasn’t a life long commitment, that they can change their minds if they decide to.  My husband would not have read any books about homeschool either.  Just a list of facts, short, simple, and quick.  Focus on the Family has information about various types of school choices including homeschooling at this link:  http://www.focusonthefamily.com/parenting/schooling/school_choice.aspx  It walks through all kinds of choices and may help.  God Bless.

    Thank you 2flowerboys, lgeurink, and Doug for the man’s perspective.  I will give her that info.

    They will public school as a private school is not in their means at this time.  She doesn’t even want to private school although she admitted it would make her feel a little better.

    She doesn’t think homeschoolers have social issues, but of course that is one fear of her hubby.  I told her that if he saw my kiddos and those of most of our church he would not think that is an issue at all.  It is abnormal at our church if you don’t homeschool as nearly every family does.  I can think of only 3 that don’t off hand and some have children that are now graduated from homeschooling. I realize that it made it easier for us. It is easier to be in the norm.  Now my hubby is even against private schools…go figure.  I told her she might have to send him and just keep praying that her hubby will change his mind.

    Well, thanks again for the info!!

    I just wanted to add my testimony here.

    The Lord put it on my heart to homeschool when my oldest was 2 (she’s now 15). My dh said no way. Both his parents were ps teachers, so that was going to be out of the question.

    Do not underestimate the power of prayer for your friend. In my case, I said Yes, Lord immediately, as I felt it was what I was meant to do. 

    I got trouble from several pastors (whose wives were ps teachers), so I had every possible thing against me, as well as getting slack from my own extended family (I have a PhD and was constantly told I’d be wasting my degree). 

    But I decided to trust the Lord and pray. By the time my oldest got to Kindergarten age, dh said I could try it, but he would not allow me to purchase any homeschool books. So the Lord showed me how to homeschool with my library card. We moved across country after that year and being in an apartment in a not so nice area until we were able to buy a house, I was able to continue to homeschool, never ceasing my prayers to change my dh’s heart.

    Although he was never thrilled with it, dh had to admit I was doing a good job. 

    Three years ago, my 3rd child was diagnosed with Aspergers, and that was the clincher to dh finally realizing homeschooling’s the best thing. He actually thanked me for homeschooling because he knows the bullying and trouble my son would have faced in ps because of his issues! we are now in our 11th year of homeschooling, thanks to the Lord’s intervention.

    All the while I remained respectful of dh, which I know is the key to the success of my prayers.

    Prayer moves mountains of opposition. Pray that she will hear the Good Shepherd’s Voice and not listen to the “excuses” of the enemy.

     

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • The topic ‘wheter or not to homeschool?’ is closed to new replies.