I have Map Trek from KQ and I have tried for a year to get it to “work” for geography, especially for my oldest. It’s not. Great maps you can print from their cd but I have found similar ones on the web. Not trying to bash, but it’s not what I thought it would be when I ordered it.
I have checked out the confessionsofahomeschooler and it looks promising for my two younger boys (6 and 9). Also, I browsed the Trail Guide through the US from Geo Matters looks okay (not sure how CM it is) but it doesn’t look as “fun” as the confessions curriculum.
Just thought I’d throw this out there since I’m kind of in the market for the same thing.
For the confessions’ curriculum, I wish I could see the booklist in the appendix that goes by state. I like that there are famous people, landmarks, and Presidents included by state and I like the activities and foods. It looks like the coloring page of the state is very similar to the Dover coloring book I have. I think you would be using library books a lot for this one. It does look like fun, but I hope not too much plannning work and hunting down books.
Well, that book looks nice, thanks for sharing it. Not too busy….I get kind of dizzy looking at children’s books with too much info on one page, kwim?
Maybe the mom at confessions would share the book list it if we/I asked?? It definitely looks like something I’m after. I don’t want a work book with all the same info (I don’t want to have to buy 2 or 3) and I don’t want to have to make copies. I already have a book I could do that with, but geez, that takes too long. I’d burn out after 1 or 2 states, lol.
I finally had a chance to look at the free sample, and although it looks thorough, it lookks like a lot of work on my part. But, I would like one place to go to (my downloaded copy) for printables and then just do what I’d like to do for a binder. I know the boys would like it, but I would definitely NOT use the whole program and would probably omit the very things that she says could easily be omitted. It is a unit study, which I’m not crazy about (always seems like a lot of work on the parents’ part), but I think that I could make it work in the way I’d like.
We’ll see….maybe it’s too much for me. I’ll have to look it over again. I’m really just looking for state symbols to color, some help in teaching the regions and capitols, hmmmm.
I admit that I did not read all the posts, sorry. Hope I am not repeating anyone’s suggestions.
We have found a fun inexpensive way to learn about states and what is there by going to their Secretary of State and the tourism departments websites. (Missouri’s is full of fun stuff – games, info, pictures, coloring books with all the symbols, etc. See here: http://sos.mo.gov/kids/) Tons of fun things, places to see, historical things…all in one place. Be sure to look at the educators site for the links in the websites.
Then I get the states notebooking pages from http://notebookingpages.com/ which cover everything I wanted to cover and more. State flags, mottos, birds, trees, top industries, famous people, etc. This is a fun way to cover the US geography very economically. =)
Here is the link – http://notebookingpages.com/shop/geography-notebooking-pages to the pages. You can purchase all the state pages (each state has 44 pages) for $3.95. If you keep going down the page, you will see other things that may interest you. She has pages for all the US presidents and the first ladies under famous people, as well. I love the convenience of a membership because she is always adding things, and I just get them. I download it all to my computer and have it anytime I want without even using the internet too. One of the things that I like is that she has both Primary and Regular lined papers in each thing to make it easier for me to use with multiple children of different levels.
I have come to one conclusion about my dc. My oldest is just not interested in what my other two are and I hate for them to be stuck doing something over or under their heads. My oldest doesn’t mind doing more independent work (he actually prefers it, but I still have check up on him once in awhile), so he’s going to do the BF guide with the Holling books, by himself. I couldn’t afford the maps for all 3 dc and my youngest would’ve been too young anyway. So, now I can “splurge” on them for my oldest. Whew!
So, now it’s just finding something for my two youngest that they will enjoy together (with mom). This will be much easier.
I didn’t see this in any of the posts (although I only scanned them briefly), but we have enjoyed this “Place the State” online game where you drag and drop the outline of a state into its correct place on the U.S. outline map. It then tells you how many miles, on average, by which you have missed placement or if you’re correct. It also times you if you wish.
We’ve also enjoyed using the Rand McNally Kids’ Road Atlas. It has a map of each state and accompanying games/puzzles to help learn more about each state. It wasn’t in-depth geography but fun facts, and having the maps all in one book was helpful.
Just wanted to share my experience with using the state books by Sleeping Bear Press. Our library had some, but not all. So when I planned out our year, generally when we would use them, I would buy 2-3 at a time, used, on Amazon or through Bookfinder. Yes, over the course of the whole year it was a big investment, but if you like the books (which we all did) and you’ll be using them for multiple children in different years, it may be worth it. There were only a couple I thought were not terribly well-written. I also got lucky and found a couple for $2 at a local used book store. For the young kids, we just did the rhymes but as they get older, they can advance on to reading the more in-depth stuff in the margins. Our week looked like this (for a K age child):
Day 1: Read the book, look at the state on the map, point out border states
Day 2: Look at the state on the map, write state name on blank map (we use Uncle Josh’s Maps CD-ROM…a great resource), and look at pictures of the state on the Internet (state parks, beaches, famous landmarks, etc.) or in a book
Day 3: Look a the state in an atlas and add in lakes, rivers, parks, or anything else interesting to you (I usually did 3, worked for copywork, too!)
Day 4: Read the state book again, then have him draw something he learned about the state (drawn narration, his choice)
We really enjoyed this study and I’m excited to do it again next year, adding and tweaking how we do it. One thing I’m excited to add is to occasionally make food associated with that state from this book, and to do a state by state scrapbook (still working on these plans).
Thanks Sue. I played that game and got 88%. I can see how it would be helpful to the kids.
I like your ideas blkateri14. That is something like what we’ll do. That cookbook is used in the Simply Stated link on Kreative Simplicity. I don’t think I’ll get their guide, but I do like some of their books. Thanks for the tip on the used books, I might end up doing that. It’s good to know that you think they are worth owning.
We used the game, too, and it was actually pretty hilarious. My oldest ds and I were competing against each other, I won’t say who won. I saved that one for sure.