Well ladies, I have made a decision that after today I will no longer be participating in this forum. I will continue to read until end of day as there is a post I am looking forward to reading a reply on. I will still use the organizer as it is a blessing to our family, but not this forum. I am sure many will not be at all bothered not to hear from me anymore, and that is fine, however I can no longer be a part of something where people are too narrow minded to be accepting of others beliefs without insulting them. I am not a Catholic, but I do not like to see the bashing of other religions, it is in extremely poor taste and as far as I am concerned not how the good Lord would want us to behave. I wish all of you the very best in your homeschooling, but I am going to a group where people respect people no matter what the belief is or lack thereof. I was taught to respect everyone, no matter whether I agreed with them or not, they are still God’s children – I have found some of the threads on here very disturbing as such I cannot be part of it anymore.
I’m really sad about that. Your experience, love for others, and helpfulness will be sorely missed here. I hope you’ll reconsider because your influence is needed.
I’m fairly new to this forum, but have noticed your avatar & “missingtheshire” on several posts. 🙂 It seems to me that you have a lot of valuable info and guidance to offer….I’ll miss seeing you.
I’m in shock. I’ve enjoyed your posts and learned a lot. I guess I havent read closely enough to see that. I would like to keep in touch with you. We think a lot alike on school topics. I’m sorry I do not know what your faith is. It doesn’t mean we can’t be friends. Please.. anyway to leave an addy to keep in touch?
MeadowLark… mom to 7 with 6 from Senior to Kindegarten at home.
Linda!!! I was looking back and you and I have been here from the beginning. I know that everyone at SCM (meaning Sonya, Doug, Nancy…) will miss you. I will not try to talk you out of your decision; that is yours to make. But, if you have read anything I’ve posted, you know I will want to make a point or two. I do not know which posts you are speaking of except the last one. I did not read it thoroughly; just enough to see what caused you concern. I am going to go WAY out on a limb (and maybe be asked to leave!) to suggest that some posts can take on a life of their own. We women are so weak.
Scripture calls us older women to teach the younger to love their husbands and children, not preach doctrine. The internet is a great place to air our beliefs, but it is also easy to type things we may never say face to face, or least with the same passion. I’m just speaking from personal failures, so no offence to anyone, please.
Bless you for the time that you have invested in the moms on this forum. If I could hold this burden for you, I gladly would. I can tell you have pain in this matter that stems from a real love for people. It reminds me of when Jesus wept. Jesus calls us to lift him up and he will draw all men unto him. Our call is to follow closely after the Lord. He will do the work through his Holy Spirit in another’s life. I agree with you in that I believe you to think that we cannot be the Holy Spirit for others. I believe that you think we can be passionate about our own faith without bashing others. Jesus is the Lamb of God; sweetly drawing us to his bosom. I know that he is also the avenger, but that is his job, in his time, not mine. One of the greatest commandments is to love you neighbor as yourself (I know you know this); so perhaps that is something we can all remember before we hit the ‘send post’ button.
Anyway, I would like to ask you to reconsider, but that’s between you, your husband, and the Lord.
I’d like to thank Cindy for her humble response….truly her words were seasoned with grace. The 2 1/2 years that I’ve know you here, Linda, have been a blessing. I too will miss you greatly ..if you choose to leave. ~ Heather
Thanks ladies, I am thinking hard on this matter and praying about it. I know the easy answer is to just not read the posts that become unpleasant, but it is hard for me when I see someone’s genuine faith being badmouthed. I am a Protestant Christian – and I do not believe that makes me any more or less worthy than anyone else. I do not believe that my faith is better than anyone elses or more true. A lot will consider me non Christian for saying that – but none of us can or should judge another’s faith. A Muslim, Jew, Catholic, Hindu, Mormon or whoever, even atheists have the right to their beliefs and I think that has to be respected – and I love my neighbor even if they have different beliefs – we are all human beings on a journey, what is true for one may not be true for another. I agree to disagree on many issues – but I cannot come to terms with what was said in the post this morning about the Catholic faith – I find it deeply disturbing, especially as I know there are Catholics on this site, who deserve better – it completely confounds and grieves me. I was really upset this morning, and decided enough was enough – attacking another person’s faith is not the sort of thing that a forum like this should be about – faith is tremendously personal, and I think respect is in order for all faiths, even if we do disagree. I too have enjoyed and benefitted from this forum, and I appreciate the comments in response to my decision – maybe I will just decide to not read these kinds of post – or maybe as you say, we should ALL think twice before hiting the send button. We ALL, me included need to remember that we are all God’s children and we all owe each other a certain respect – this forum is for helping one another in educating our children in the CM way – maybe we should stick to that. I do note that wiser souls than me on this forum stay out of these controversial issues – that is my lesson for the day – keep out of them – however, it is hard when you know that other people may be hurt by what is written and that is where my big mouth, or my typing fingers get me in trouble – because it hurts my heart to think that others are wounded by careless words especially about faith. I remember in school many moons ago, we were taught that in polite society religion and money should not be discussed as it generally caused ill feelings. I went to a school where we had prayer and religion taught – but that was the advice – and another piece of valuable advice from then was, that if you have nothing nice to say, then don’t say anything. I have hit send on this forum before and I should not have, and it is easy to do – I hold my hand up as being imperfect – and if I do stay, I hope that we all consider who we might be wounding with our words before we hit send. Linda
I have guests arriving and can’t read fully, but I just want to echo CindyS. As a mom of medium length , I enjoy the wisdom offered by older moms. I hope to hear more from you in the future.
For the record, I have Catholic friends. I was trying to say that we need to let the Holy Spirit convict us. And sin is sin, no matter what “religion” you follow. We are to love the PERSON but not the sin. As for me agreeing with MP, it was directed at the verses from the Bible. And the world hating Jesus etc.. sorry I did not clarify that!!
Doug, you are right about not seeing face, hearing the words, or knowing the heart of people who post. I have by email got in trouble with that before! Even when I expressed several times that I loved this person and was there to help. They read what they wanted to read..and the other lines were omitted! Thanks for reminding me of that!
To missing the shire, I hope you stay..we do love older wiser mom’s advice.
Linda, I have not been on much today and didn’t even know of what had happened until just now. Linda, I’ll personally miss you very, very, very much if you leave. I can understand sometimes needing a “break”–I know I’ve sometimes needed that when emotions run high. I so agree with what you have said–to me it is enough to know that we are all striving to be Christian. I know I’ve at times been the recipient of hurtful comments (not here, though) and I try so hard to watch myself and not accuse someone of not being a Christian–unless they do not believe in Jesus Christ. 🙂 IMO that is the only “qualifier” I believe I am called to worry about. Other than that, if someone says they are Christian, I assume they are my sister and go forward on that assumption unless otherwise notified. 🙂 I would actually like to run over and give you a hug for your kind words and your standing for a kind, gentle, magnanimous community, as that is the kind I enjoy here and hope to continue to enjoy.
So if you need space, I can understand, but I will surely be praying you don’t need to leave us totally. I’d miss you a great deal.
Michelle, you are one of the main reasons I would stay – because we both have teens and have high school to deal with I have often felt you were one person to ask if I ever had a worry, no disrespect to those with little ones, but those moms with high schoolers have been a great comfort and help to me on this forum – none of us know everything and it has always been a pleasure reading your posts and your answers to my questions. I am taking time over the weekend, but I will stay on the forum because I am now hopeful that with Doug’s very eloquent writing everyone will try hard to keep this as a gentle, kind and loving as it has always been – Charlotte Mason’s teachings are gentle, and nurturing, this group of ladies has always been like that – I would hate to see that change into something else. Many other forums are not so nice and gentle – and I avoid them – we are all capable of making errors in judgement, I just hope that now we will all take pause before we post and that we return to what this group does best, and that is to encourage each other in the education of our children. Michelle I appreciate your words and I thank you – I hope everyone has a wonderful weekend. Hugs – Linda
I appreciate having such lovely role models on this forum. I have learned so much from you high-schooling mamas! I didn’t know anything was happening until just a little while ago. But wanted to say that I’m glad you’ll be staying around Linda. And wasn’t Doug’s message wonderful?
Have a restful and peaceful weekend. I hope that your daughter is doing well. I often think of her and pray for her often.