We have done some of the Pixar films…but not any of the ones that include magic, scary villains, or other things that stir up fear in our children. And some of the content of children’s programming is just too grown up for kids. I don’t like the ‘romantic’ angle that is becoming more and more common in the Disney films. Our girls, especially, don’t need to see curvy cartoon girls who are out to capture the attention of boys. We don’t need to reinforce the world’s standard that a girl’s worth comes from her appearance and her ability to flirt.
We have let our boys watch the old movie superheroes – some of the old westerns, sports movies, and comedies with actors like Gary Cooper, John Wayne, or Jimmy Stewart. ‘Sargeant York’ is one of my boys’ favorite films. They have watched it again and again! Boys need heroes to emulate, but heroes of their faith and heroes of character.
How can keeping your standards in line with God’s word be too idealistic? Give them the real things in life, and they won’t crave the conterfeit.
We do watch Disney movies. But our favorites are fox and the hound, Robin Hood, jungle book, sleeping beauty, and we love tangled. I prefer old musicals. We watch Oklahoma, the music man, or What’s in the Bible. We have been limiting screen time to 30 min while I cook dinner.
With that said a shave war bed Cinderella, sleeping beauty, little mermaid. They are not our favorites by we do watch them occasionally.
A friend recently gifted us a bunch of non-Disney animated movies based on classics. Whew…I decided that the Disney ones were probably less scary and certainly had better, more attractive animation. We are not keeping the non-Disney versions. But, as with all things, moderation is the key both in watching and discussing! A few appropriate and light discussions can be very enlightening for a person.
I was thinking about this authority issue last night, and wanted to give a little food for thought about the family members who are trying to undermine your authority. I mean this gently, so please read it that way! =)
I am very aware of family members who truly are trying to undermine others. That is wrong. However, I have noticed that when I put resistrictions on something that is a “traditional” item that “all kids” have, it really helps to offer alternatives so that people who are trying to do something nice for my family can. It can be frustrating for both sides! Sometimes in our zeal to proctect our children, we can make our family members into “uncaring monsters” without meaning to and our decisions can sometimes inadvertently make the grandparents feel alienated and deny them the joy sharing things with the grandkids…
My suggestion is to give lists of affordable, approved items and where to get them to your family members/friends and see if that will help in this area – and this goes for food, clothes, toys and other entertainment choices. Most people will happily buy something that you approve of – if you let them know there is an alternative!
Loving all your replies! I’d like to respond back specifically to a few of you but for the sake of time right now I’ll respond to sheraz. You know, I’ve offered lists to my mother of toys, books, movies she could purchase and she commented that she doesn’t like that I have to give her a list and that it’s controlling. I honestly never thought of her as undermining my authority but the more I think about it, you are right. I feel disresecpted and disapproved. Something I’ve lived with my entire life. She is a very controlling woman, and I need to add that she isn’t a believer so we don’t see eye to eye on quite alot of things. I’ve been praying for a Titus 2 woman to come into my life so that I can have a mature Godly woman to teach me and to whom I can ask all my questions, lol…It’s hard sometimes but I try my best not to let her steal my joy =)
We actually told my family (my husband’s family doesn’t give gifts, they never have) that we were trying to limit ourselves to giving our children three gifts for Cmas and for Easter and for birthdays. We asked them to try to limit thmselves to one or two gifts per child per holiday. That worked for one year….! *L* I think we need to mention it again.
Frankly, we can’t afford to give more than that – our children have all their needs met; we try to encourage their “wants” to be lasting things (maybe a camera, instead of a stupid toy; maybe a book, instead of another stupid toy). We don’t take vacations like normal people(!), we do the occasional “day away”. Or allow ourselves to go out for ice cream a couple times during the summer instead of a longer vacation.
I’m trying not to over-react to my brother and sister-in-law who have no children (and no other nieces/nephews close by) who buy my daughters very nice, expensive, many gifts for their birthdays. Now, my brother and sil have started giving a group (For all my daughters) gift a Christmas, so perhaps that’s why they went “overboard” for the one recent birthday.
I guess we all have this trouble because everyone is different and has their own reasons for doing what they do. That’s usually a good thing! *L*
Thanks for this question – I am interested in the answers as well.
So far, my 5YO has only seen Lady & the Tramp and Secret of the Wings in full. Both were given to us by my mom. There are a few odd things in L&T, but Secret of the Wings seems pretty harmless as far as I can tell.
The only princess movie she has seen is Beauty & the Beast, and we fast-forwarded through a lot of that and never made it to the end. She is easily scared. I didn’t mind that one so much, since Belle is into books and good to her father, but I still have trouble with the whole “princess” culture. She knows who the other princesses are, at least most of them, from other kids, but has never seen any of the other movies.
We try to keep TV / video watching to a minimum in general, which has helped so far. There are really only a small number of shows they have seen, and most weeks they have no screen time at all. I do wonder how this will change as they get older. I’m hoping I can stick to it as much as possible. I’m also hoping that if I can keep them interested in more wholesome, intellectually stimulating books & movies, they will be less interested in the junk. We’ll see. I will say that their favorite is The Sound of Music (which I allow even my 2YO to watch, when she is sick, minus the very adult parts and the war-related parts), so I feel like that’s a good sign. 🙂