If you learned that your child was best able to process and learn through “hands on” activities what would that mean to your lessons and how would you accomplish it? (with the understanding of ways in which CM is already “hands on” in some subjects but the challenge aspect coming in to play by thinking this through on the other subjects) –
Would you make every lesson hands on? A few a week? Rotate them through the subjects?
Would you really feel confident that they were learning the material in this manner?
Where would you turn for ideas for each subject?
Would you still use CM methods in addition to a hands on activity for a lesson?
How would you avoid being mired in twaddle activities?
So CM does include nature study and handicrafts. I would try to alternate more hands on and less hands on subjects. I don’t know how hands on your child needs to be. Narration need not always be verbal. They could draw for it or perhaps do some other more hands on activity. Things like labelling maps, writing and drawing in a book of centuries are all good. I am not a huge fan of lapbooks but if you can make them substantive and not too twaddly that works too.
I have 2 children who are extremely hands-on. My 3yo everything is basically hands-on anyway at this point, but for my 8yo, she has done surprisingly well with this method exactly how CM describes it. She has to touch or do something while listening, but our cat who likes to sit by us is great for that. She gives the best narrations! If she wants to do something hands-on, she does it herself in the afternoons. Like nebby said, there are hands-on things mixed into a CM education already, and I mix up the subjects so it’s not using the same part of the brain for too long, and it has been great for her.
I mix CM method with tried and true hands on. While I adore nature study, handicrafts, etc they do nothing for learning about, say, how a radio works or how chemicals work together. Buying a few well selected science kits or utalizing a sciene experiment book once per week or month (what ever works for you) will only enhance your lessons. A book like My Body (I don’t know the ages of your children) where you make a life size copy of your child’s body outline and add photo copies of organ printout patterns one at a time while learning their function can be fun and very educational.
I don’t know if my dd would ever learn math without lots of hands on .
After graduating 3 children, yes, I am very confident in this method.
Can you tell me more about that ‘My Body” book? Is it the one by Patricia Carratello? What is inside it? I can’t get amazon to show me the inside pages. How much detail is there and what types of activities? Thanks!
We do a lot of hands on, but not for every lesson. For example after reading time my son narrates back to me and sometimes we leave it at that, but often we do an additional activity, like making one of the characters out of beeswax clay or painting a watercolor picture of a scene in the book. For science we do a lot of drawing of what we saw while we explored the woods and bring back treasures for our nature table. To answer your questions: I can tell the hands on gives my son time to process the concept or subject he is learning and therefor it sinks in. For ideas, I look on pinterest or blogs. Sometimes I just think of them myself and then post the hands-on activity to my bog for others to see and as time goes by, I build on the original activity. (You, in a creativity spurs on more creativity kind of way.) I do till use the CM method as the hands-on activities are meant to supplement the method. An easy way for me to tell if we are getting caught up in twaddle is if I feel compelled to toss out the activity as soon as we are finished.
My Body is by Teacher Created Resources (yes, same author). It is a 40 page book that is mostly made up of printable patterns with a diagram to show where each go on your child’s body outline. I plan to use shipping paper to trace my dd. For each organ there is a discription of what it looks like, where it is located, how it connects, and its function. The child should color each organ before pasting to the outline.
I’m still not sure how I could add hands on activities to every subject every day. There are only so many hours in a day and I hate to do lessons all day long. I’ve done the body (super fun), some chemical experiments, lots of art of every kind for all the subjects, etc.
I like the idea of tearing apart things and getting tons of lessons out of it. I suppose I just need to bite the bullet and design such a thing myself! There is a book idea ladies, right?!
Susie can you send me your blog? I hate to reinvent wheels!
Sorry! It was “luxiii” who blogs her hands on things … please share here if you are willing!
I still have this idea of a book “Tearing Things Apart & Learning While You Do It” …. toasters, radios, phones, lawn mowers, hair dryers, light bulbs …. math, science, chemistry – the lessons would be endless and amazing. CM style narrations and such on various aspects too. Writing assignments galore. Sign us up! 🙂
We did the body book and DS has loved it! It is hanging on the door still for us to go to when we start getting into the body parts in 106 days of creation.