Swiss Family Robinson edition

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • ourLittleFlock
    Participant

    Could anyone point me to a “good” edition of Swiss Family Robinson?  I didn’t realize it was such a can of worms.  Also, it appears on Amazon that the reviews for it are the same on different versions of the book, so I’m not sure how reliable an Amazon link is.  I would prefer a book over an ebook.

    Thank you!

    Kim

    Angelina
    Participant

    bump.   We are just about to begin this wonderful read.   I bought my copy ages ago, thinking that all that mattered was that it was unabridged.  Is there more to this story?  Robin P?

    Angelina
    Participant

    I’ve just read the early pages in my kindle version and see this quote:

    “…the book has been rewritten so many times, by so many editors, that it can legitimately be said that no complete edition of the books exists in any language…”

    I would love to hear from someone here on the forum on this.  I have two copies:  my kindle version by Pink Tree Press, and a paperback hard copy by Signet Classics.  I had hoped to have my older boys read this while following on librivox…so I suppose I will need to check which version has been used by the audio recorder on librivox, but if anyone here on the forum has advice or experience on this I would greatly appreicate it!

    Blessings, Angie

    Kristen
    Participant

    I am currently reading this to my children at lunch time and we are using the Windermere Readers edition.  It’s Copyright says 1954.  It and several other Windermere Readers were given to me by an old family friend that had them for her children.  It IMO is a good edition.

    ourLittleFlock
    Participant

    I was able to borrow a couple copies of Swiss Family Robinson from our library.  I thought I would share the first section of each book.

    Penguin Classics – this is not the same Penguin Classics edition that shows up first in the search on Amazon, as you can compare by “Looking Inside.”  This book is over 400 pages and includes the original author preface. 

    “Already the tempest had continued six terrible days, and far from subsiding on the seventh, its fury seemed to increase.  We had wandered so materially from the right track, and were so forcibly driven toward the south-east, that not a creature on board knew where we were.  The ship’s company were exhausted by constant labour and watching, and the courage which had hitherto sustained them now began to fail.  The masts had been shivered to pieces and cast into the sea: several leaks appeared, and the ship began to fill.  The sailors forbore from swearing and were now employed in prayers, or in making the absurdest vows as the condition of their release from danger.  Each recommended his soul to God, but at the same moment thought of contriving the best means for preserving his life.”

    This next selection was published by Children’s Classics, is printed in a larger font and is just over 250 pages.

    “For six days the storm had raged wildly, and our situation became more dangerous every hour.  Driven out of our course, we no longer knew our position, and the ship had lost her masts and was leaking.”

    –As you can see, this is a largely edited and sanitized version of the former, with hardly a mention of God in the story, from what I could see at first glance.  

    Hope that’s helpful.

    Kim

     

     

    ourLittleFlock
    Participant

    I apologize, the book that shows up in the Amazon search is for the Puffin Classics version, not Penguin Classics.

    Kim

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • The topic ‘Swiss Family Robinson edition’ is closed to new replies.