I know what it’s like to have a struggling speller! My advice would be to try not to get too discouraged. My son didn’t make any major improvements until 8th grade (after 4 spelling programs – including AAS, Sequential Spelling, Phonetic Zoo, Spelling Wisdom and a few attempts at traditional speller/workbook types. It was an expensive journey, to say the least).
In the end, what “cured” his bad spelling was simply MATURITY! Around age 13 he started caring about school more, and started realizing that school WILL have an impact on how he’ll do in life. He’s still on a journey, of course, but overall he now takes more pride in his work. As a result, he’s more willing to slow down and put in the extra minutes it takes to stop and consider his spelling – and to fix it. All those junior years – grades 3-6 – of working on spelling did very little for this kid. All my planning and buying did nothing. I just needed to wait for HIM to want to spell well and for him to care enough to put forth the effort. Every child is a different personality, of course, and my situation may not apply to yours….but just wanted to say it is possible that patience, encouragement and time can cure a bad speller!
If you do choose to opt out of a spelling program, consider using The Scholastic Dictionary of Spelling as a mainstay on his desk. It can be used to help with daily writing assignments and is actually a very powerful little spelling tool! MUCH better than a “real” dictionary because it contains only words used frequently in daily writing. No definitions. Just words. Looking things up is a breeze (love it!)