We are trying this too. We just finished day 3 of the sample and I ordered it. My dd is loving it. She reads well and has done ETC for a few years, but never paid much attention to those rules. So I don’t see her paying attention to any spelling “rules”. But she does love to play games and word search puzzles. So I think she will figure out the patterns. She is doing well so far and we had a lot of fun with the optional “aye” yesterday, a word she says Felicity (American Girl) uses. But it will take more than the sample to know how well it will work.
Today was better for me getting the hang of teaching it:
1. “thin. My father was so thin… thin.”
2. Watch for them to finish writing the word.
3. Green marker, write “in” on board. “I hear ‘in’ in thin. Don’t you?”
4. Pick up blue marker, “what letters make the th sound? t-h.” Write th on board in blue in front of green in.
5. Have student check/correct word on paper.
6. Say and use finger in the air to spell together: “t-h-i-n” (I forgot this yesterday.)
Move on to next word.
At the end, discuss some homophones and have student make up sentences to use them in correctly. Write various spellings on board, with context drawings where possible.
She was already familiar with homophones from a great book called Dear Deer. We had fun with be/bee/Bea today. The sentence she made up was “Aunt Bea, thars a bee!” Then she had fun drawing a big bee flying towards Aunt Bea (of Mayberry). With all the drawings it took 25 minutes, but it was the most fun we ever had with spelling! Time will tell how well it works, but I did research before buying and read some great reviews at RR, CBD, and this forum. So I think you should give it a good try for a few months and see how well your boys do with it before switching to something else. It does work by word families and patterns and different colors on the board. We are not getting dvd, as I do not see it working as well.