I have several titles we have used often. With young children, don’t be afraid to read the poems you find over and over. Just because you’ve “done” a poem or a book, young children like to hear their favorites again.
We like: Favorite Poems of Childhood, ed. Philip Smith, Dover
Poems to Read to the Very Young (a Sonlight choice) ed. Josette Frank,
The Children’s Classic Poetry Collection, ed. Nicola Baxter
are three that we have. I also have simply ranged through large collections like Favorite Poems Old and New, and any of the Poetry for Young People series–some will be attractive to young children, and some might not. I’d just wander through and pick and choose.
Young children love to have some stability and repetition; a good thing is for Mommy to learn a number of poems, and then keep them around. We had poems for saying at bedtime and in the morning and at lunch and when we saw a butterfly and when we found a snake and when it started to rain, etc. 🙂 It’s pretty cute to have an excited 3 or 4yo come running in for the “butterfly poem” because he saw a butterfly.