Not wanting to tread on toes…thoughts please??

Welcome to Simply Charlotte Mason Discussion Forum CM Educating Not wanting to tread on toes…thoughts please??

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 35 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • It is nice to see the varied views on here – and it goes to show that people with different ideas can get along really well – taking with them from the group what is helpful and leaving the rest. I consider myself conservative politically but not to any extreme I do not personally like too far to right or left, those areas can be dangerous and I prefer a more tolerant middle….but each to his own. Questa 7 we were a military family as well, though my husband retired just over a year ago now after 20 odd years and he now works as a civilian on the base. It is hard to make and keep friends with so much moving about – so groups like this are valuable. I am glad that you will stay – you will not always agree with the views here, especially the ones on the Mom’s Porch part where there is just more lifestyle chat – I don’t agree with all views either – but in general one can glean a lot from everyone here – even people we think we disagree with. One of the biggest learning curves I have had to deal with since coming here, is over religion – in England/Germany we do not have anywhere near as many churches or denominations as here – we have the main denominations but not all the offshoots -and people who have faith in what is a more secular place of the world, go about their faith quietly, which is not because they are afraid or anything, it is just that we are a more reserved people in many ways. So I never heard anyone bad mouth another’s religion until I came here – and I was shocked when a friend of mine told me I was damned because I followed the wrong religion and I hear people being rude about other faiths too, which I do not understand. I cannot abide such intolerance in people – it is that attitude which leads to the horrors like the holocoast and other dreadful things. That lady is still a friend of mine by the way, I told her I thought she was crazy and intolerant and we now don’t discuss that anymore we have agreed to differ. I think that the labels we put on ourselves can easily be misconstrued – feminism for example at the start was a good thing to protect women and their rights, it has now become something rather strident and unpleasant with little tolerance for others. When I find intolerance, I am upset- it is that which causes most of the problems of the world, that and ignorance. So I don’t label myself a feminist, I don’t have a denomination but I have my Bible and am interested in all the faiths, and the one thing I hope to have taught our girls, is that you need to be tolerant of people differences in this world, and you need to stand for right anytime you see an intolerance, that is what is important to love one another, no matter the differences. I like that this is a welcoming group, that does not insist on anything other than politeness, that is the greatest strength and something I treasure. So enjoy this group and take what you can – just leave the rest..vive la difference – I say:)))) Linda

    Homeschooling6
    Participant

    First I’d like to say ‘Welcome’ =)

    At times I feel that I’m not the norm. I serve my children corn dogs, we eat at McDonalds now-and-then, my dd and I wear pants and love our Sunday School classes at church 😉

    One of my children will use Bob Jones textbooks for all his subjects this year too!

    We use many different styles of homeschooling at our house. Like mentioned one child will use 100% textbooks, while others will use parts of CM and classical. This is why I love homeschooling. We can cater to each child’s need.

    I can say that I do feel welcomed here at SCM forum. Everyone is so kind and ready to help.

    Blessings,

    Linda<><

    LillyLou
    Participant

    By looking at this thread, it’s occured to me that the “HS norm” or the “CM norm” is up to interpretation; we’re all using CM in some shape or form, and yet, everyone here has different beliefs.  Could it be that we come up with these “norms” just as we do the “standards” by which we constantly measure ourselves?  I would argue that there is no “norm”, but only a common thread here: the desire to do the best we can by our children, with whose well-being we have been given stewardship over for their time as children on this earth. And with the exception of the front porch forum, our discussions are on CM methods, only one aspect of our lives and homeschools. Just a thought.

    BTW, this is coming from a dress-wearing, head-covering, make up free, 12 passenger van driving, wheat milling, bread baking, made from scratch everything including animal crackers, home birthing, home schooling, 2nd generation homeschooler, who still can’t keep up with dishes and will not give up the use of words like “just sayin'” and “holy cow”, and who stays up into the night to watch Oceans 11, 12 and 13- actually entertained and amused.  Oh, and I have a 4 year degree from a *gasp* state university!  But guess what- I’m the only woman in our church who wears a head covering, I’m the only woman in our church who wears dresses or skirts all the time, we’re the only family who doesn’t send our kids to Sunday school, and we’re NOT the only homeschoolers.  My point is, just as there will never be an author you agree with 100% of the time, there will never be a “group” you will fit into 100% unless you and everyone there decides to become a clone.  And last time I checked, clones were man-made, not God-made, so I’m pretty sure that wasn’t His intention… My mom always said “there are as many ways to homeschool as there are homeschoolers”.  Smart chick, no?

    Welcome to the group-I’d love to have you stick around, even if we can’t make ourselves smoosh into the exact same mold.

    Oh, and I’m pretty sure I have a workbook or two in my stash, while we’re confessing…

    WinkLillyLou

    I have quite a few textbooks, they have their uses – I have found Abeka and Bob Jones literature books to be filled with wonderful short stories and poetry and we enjoy reading them, we don’t do the work – just read and discuss the stories. I have history textbooks too, some from my own college days, some by Abeka and Notgrass – we take what we want from them and leave the rest. LillyLou,I love your post, you have shown that we don’t need to be all the same, yet we can still learn and grow with each other – that is the beauty of homeschooling and of this group. Linda :))

    Everyone here has given wonderful responses. I just want to add that we all have one thing in common for sure, and that’s love for our families. We all want the best for kids, and CM is a big part of that in my opinion. 🙂

    Blessings!

    QuirkyMama
    Participant

    I would like to thank the original poster and all the responders to this thread.  This has been something weighing on my mind as well.  I have been feeling like I don’t belong…well, anywhere lately and this has been a breath of encouragement.  My oldest is only four, so I don’t even call myself a “homeschooler” yet, but I am also one of only a few people I know that isn’t sending their four-year-old to preschool.  We are living as an American family in Germany where I barely know any of the language, and it’s illegal for Germans to homeschool and most of the Americans here send their young kids to the German kindergartens or American schools.  I was homeschooled my last three years of highschool, and my sixteen-year-old brother (with a sister in the middle) has been homeschooled his entire school “career” so far.  I do know there is an ENORMOUS amount of peer pressure within individual homeschool groups.  Peer pressure is everywhere, it just changes form.  Even knowing this, I read things in various places and start feeling guilty because I wear pants, or my kids like Mickey Mouse, or I eat food from a box, or my husband and I are content with keeping our family size at four.  We are Christian, but the journey is deep for me, and I struggle with many theological issues so am not committed to any specific sub-culture withing the Church.  I do, however, love the simplilcity, yet depth and beauty, of the Charlotte Mason way.  Thanks too all who are sharing that it is an option for people from diverse backgrounds and viewpoints. 

    Hi Quirkymama, I spent many, many years living in Germany – in Northern Germany, Frankfurt, and then Ramstein -I also have family there and speak the language – but I know how isolating it can feel and I know how some send their children to German Kindy – so no wonder you are feeling a bit left out. I am glad you are encouraged by these posts, I don’t think anyone on here really would dislike any of the differences we have – disagree with choices etc, but not dislike us – to start with that is not Biblical and not very CM – I think sometimes the discussions can get a little heated because we are all learning from each other, and I am sure some of our ideas are shocking to others from time to time – but that is ok – we all have to live with our own choices and goals for our families. I love that I can glean information from people who live differently to me – I love hearing about the different faiths when it comes up – I don’t always agree but I love to learn. The peer pressure doesn’t just affect kids does it,lol, we are prone to it as well. I am now pretty content in walking to my own families beat and don’t pay much attention anymore – but it is still there. So I too am glad to see that there are others who have in the last few days found common ground in this forum – Sonya and Doug and the rest of the team do a fabulous job in allowing us the freedoms to speak on here – they are what makes this work and it is wonderful. I hope that everyone is feeling more at home now – I consider this forum a home from home, and it is the only forum I am a member of except for a curriculum selling one and HEO, but I seldom go there anymore. This place is the best…Hope you enjoy Germany, I love it and miss it so much….Linda

    Claire
    Participant

    Amanda!  What an awesome post and all the wonderful threads after …. There is room for everyone under the CM umbrella in my mind.  I do have to train myself to look for things I can use in my method and philosophy and not to focus on the other too much.  I love your outlook on equality.  Have you ever read a book called Raising Cain?  Two male psychologists wrote it about the issues surrounding our raising of men in this culture.  I enjoyed the perspective it gave me on what our culture “tells” boys. 

    Jenni
    Participant

    How timely! Just bumping up this incredible thread so we can all remember to enjoy and be thankful for this forum and our delightful differences. Wanted to make sure in particular that following the election, we haven’t alienated anyone. Let us all polish off our welcoming attitudes.

    Have a joyous and blessed Thanksgiving all!

    Jenni

    ps: blog update coming soon

    jeaninpa
    Participant

    Thanks for bumping this.  I hadn’t read it before.  I would be very disappointed if people left these forums because they felt they didn’t “fit”.  I NEED these different viewpoints and appreciate hearing differing opinions on things.  Iron sharpens iron.

    Rachel White
    Participant

    I would also like to add that sometimes there aren’t as many differences as one thinks. Sometimes it’s just the labels and terminology used that creates a preconceived notion based on others use of those terms or it’s meaning changing over time. Also, there are areas of common ground where we can meet, though not agreeing on everything. That’s okay.

    As much as possible, assumptions should try to be avoided as result. Although there are wonderful cultural differences between people-which should be cherished- try to get to know the individual.

    Happy Thanksgiving!

    clay1416
    Participant

    Hi Questa7! We all have different ideas for what is best for our families and that is great, that’s why we hm! Just like you, we decided to homeschool for other reasons other than religious, we are Christians but that wasnt our only priority when choosing this lifestyle.

    We also dont choose our children toys, my daughter loves to play to her brother’s cars and dinosaurs as much as she loves to play with her dolls. We also encourage our son to play pretend with playdoh and “cook” to his dinosaurs. I dont see anything wrong with that…we need men to know how to cook, and women to know how to change a flat tire.

    You are very appreciated here, hey! it was you who gave me the information for the weighted blankets site and that has been a blessing to our family! my son can finally sleep!!! a big thanks! So hang in there! we are all different, but if we all respect others we can all learn something new… 😀

    Questa7
    Member

    Wow…thanks, Jenni, for bumping this….so encouraging to read the new replies!  And all of you are right…I think we all have very similar lifestyles and practices, just some different underlying cultural beliefs/convictions.

    And clay1416…YAY!!!! I am so very thrilled that he is sleeping!! The blanket may all the difference in the world for us, too, when we started using it.  Hearing this just made my day! 🙂

    csmamma
    Participant

    Okay, ya’ll have my interest. I’ve never heard of a weighted blanket. Can you fill me in on the benefits. Thanks :).

    Questa7
    Member

    Csmama…the weighted blanket is a therapy tool often used with children with sensory issues, sensory processing disorders, autism, etc.  Many of these children like “deep” touch and pressure, and also have trouble sleeping.  The weighted blanket provides the pressure and effect of a “deep hug”, and thereby gives these children the secure sensation they need in order to sleep.  We started using one with my son when he was three and a half, and there was an IMMEDIATE difference.  He went from waking up ten or twelve times every night to just once or twice.  It has been an enormous help to us.  Since we ordered a relatively small blanket, we also use it for reading time on the couch or other times when he needs help settling to focus.  HTH!

    Amanda

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 35 total)
  • The topic ‘Not wanting to tread on toes…thoughts please??’ is closed to new replies.