As an update, my son is 14 this spring. We did read the GA Henty book, St George of England. While my son enjoyed it, I did not. There was way too much fighting in wars, and it was so descriptive of it. I even skipped over some of it as I read aloud. Since it was a kindle book, I am not sure of the number of pages, but it was very long.
We LOVED Little Lord Fauntleroy! And maybe we will read it again sometime. I highly recommend it.
We read Mountain Born and its sequel A Place for Peter. We both enjoyed these, and they had great character lessons and descriptions of working in nature with sheep, dogs/puppies, maple syrup, farm life, clearing a path (including rattlesnakes) and more. The main character is a boy growing up and trying to gain his father’s trust and approval. He is thirteen years old in the sequel and begins taking on more responsibilities and working alone.
Cinnabar by Marguerite Henry was a fun, quick read about a fox and his family.
We plan to read Little Britches this summer. I have seen this recommended here a lot.
I have found out that the books we read need to appeal to us both. If I don’t like the book (Henty), I tend to dread it. This bedtime reading should be something we both look forward to.
Here is a blog post I found to be helpful too. There are links to other blog posts at the bottom, including Ann Voskamp’s.
https://wheremytreasureis.wordpress.com/2016/06/01/stories-for-summer-jonathans-top-picks-for-boys/
Thank you all for your help. The only problem now is deciding which book to read next. So many books, so little time!