narration question

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • petitemom
    Participant

    When a child does his narration, be it oral or written, do you point out important points they missed?

    Also I think I read somwhere you should not interrupt a narration, I might be in trouble here!!

    ruth
    Participant

    You do not want to interupt a narration.  The child will then loose thier train of thought.  The point of the narration is for the child to develope thier own relationship with the work.  The things they remember and make connections with may be different then what you had in mind.  If there is some information you want them to remember as well start by asking an open ended question about the topic, then discuss it.

    petitemom
    Participant

    So if they miss the main point of the chapter you just say “good job”!?!

    ruth
    Participant

    No, I would ask open ended questions about it.  I might have to give a few prompts, but usually once I say “tell me about____” my ds will usually be able to fill in the rest.  When we first started narrating he would occasionally get hung up on one point in the story and it took some time to teach him that the had to pay attention to the whole story and tell me about it.  If he couldn’t tell me anything about a part of a story except whatever he was thinking about, I would put the book aside, and when we should have been done with school work, I would pull it out again and read the section again and request another narration.  It took a while but he did eventually get the idea that unless he wanted to do it again he had to listen to everything the first time.

    Anonymous
    Inactive

    SCM has a book called Hearing and Reading, Telling and Writing:  A Charlotte Mason Language Arts Handbook and there is a very generous sample you can download. In that sample, they include a chapter on narration with general guidelines and lots of quotes from CM. It is very helpful and might answer your questions.

    It is my understanding that there is a place for mentioning key points/ideas the student misses but only AFTER the student has narrated.

    Here are some various links from the SCM blog that discuss narration:

    The Charlotte Mason Method of Narration

    Narration Ideas 

    5 Steps to Successful Narration

    Charlotte Mason Answers Your Questions about Narration:  Language Arts, Part 4

    To Narrate and Discuss

    Hope that helps!

    petitemom
    Participant

    thanks to both of you! I need to learn how to do this better!

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • The topic ‘narration question’ is closed to new replies.