My take on this has been to work on memorizing Scripture and poems diligently. Then, as my daughters make connections with the different memory passages, some of those passages will resonate with them and stay in their minds forever. (And when they’re little old ladies, they can regale unsuspecting children with all the poems, verses, and ditties they’ve memorized!)
My goal is to teach my children that they CAN memorize and to exercise that muscle. So that they can then memorize anything that the need or want to.
I’m not sure that CM really intends for us to make our children Champion Memorizers. Or that the children are to be able to perfectly quote years’ worth of passages. I think the goal is to fill their minds with the good, the noble, the true, the right so that they will grow to be people of worth – so that they will not have to fall back on mindless entertainment or the baser forms of “something to do” or “something to think about.”
As for Scripture, I’m firmly convinced it is a Living, Powerful “sword.” Therefore, my goal is not to create children who can quote whole books of the Bible, but children who, when faced with temptation or trial, will, without conscious thought, be reminded of a phrase or a verse or a principle that was addressed when they were young, and had been memorized.