In a country so full of material blessings, how do you guard your children from materialism? Does anyone have any advice about how to keep a healthy balance?
I don’t know how good we are but we try to keep out kids very real. So like when grandpa/ma said oh, we’re going to buy legos, movies etc for Easter, I went .. you know they are really excited about fishing this summer. Some new lures and jigs would be a much better idea. She was grateful to spend a lot less and do this. These are just some of the simple ways we try. When they fish then.. to continue this.. they have to do it all (age wise) themselves. They have to decided what to keep knowing what they keep they clean and cook and eat. They don’t like fish they don’t fish. LOL
Also, we have really tried to keep out of the “toy” sections and in the sports (you have to understand we don’t do, watch or particapate in any sports so for us it’s just to get new things for home) sections, the tools stores (with 5 boys) is great and the art/crafts stores. That way what they get/want/need is useful and can either be kept or given as a gift.
Just a couple short ideas. Maybe that isn’t what you were looking for? Also, no clothes with “stuff” on them, we shop at Savers (all donated clothes), buy everything we can at garage sales, and boy now you know I’m cheap, and used! I will keep reading this post as this is a great question Misty
Homeschooling and a home-centered life in general helps with the “gimmees”, as the kids don’t see and hear the other kids talking about all of their “stuff”. We have said no to any and all video games, cell phones, and limit TV to almost nill. We also shop used clothing, sales, and make some clothing of our own. We live on a farm and raise some of our own food too. Christmas and birthdays are times to get books and craft/science kits for school and Easter only brings a bit of candy…not presents! I don’t know if this will free them from the “want” bug, but my kids seem very content.
I have 18 year old twin daughters, and they do not have a cell phone, never wanted one, they borrow mine (a cheap tracphone) if they go out without us with a friend’s family or something. They do not yet drive, because we have only just paid our van off and bought a 2nd second hand car for them to learn in, and they never complained. We have nice clothes, but only a few, we are not fancy dressers to be honest, and I am glad they have no interest in fashion or makeup. They did both get an ipod nano for their birthday, and they get $10 a month from us to buy music with, occasionally I give them an itunes gift card as a treat, but not too often. They never complain, they don’t ask for things, and I believe that like Heather says it is because of homeschooling. TV has not been an issue for us, overseas for many years when they were little we did not have one, and in recent years we have one, but to watch select movies on. They never got bombarded with advertising, and I avoided taking them to places shopping that would encourage the gimmes. We also had a family rule that gifts would be books or book gift cards, that way they could always go to the bookstore and get something they really wanted. We have tried to put a spiritual emphasis on Easter and Christmas, and so that means for Easter a little chocolate and a book certificate, and at Christmas they always get three gifts, to signify the gifts of the Wise Men to Jesus – I think over the years this has made them very content – they are happy and don’t feel the need to want for things. Another thing that may help is we have always taught them to really value money and not waste it – we repair things, we don’t just throw away and buy new stuff, they know what things cost, and they know they cannot have everything. They were so sweet when dad said he was going to get another little car for them to learn in, they said, don’t worry we can learn later, we don’t need a car right now….that is their mindset, and I hope they will always stay that way. The world is a mess these days. partly because we live in a society where a lot of people feel entitled to everything without working for it. We were determined to try and avoid that if we possibly could.
You know, we’ve always gotten our kids 1 gift at Christmas and Santa gives them one. That’s all they get at home. The kinds of gifts they get are slippers, flannel sheets, paints and brushes, chess. Our kids are VERY content. Every year at Christmas, my in laws like to spend $50 on each child. That’s way more then I spend. Anyway, when they ask us what to get the kids, we never know. The kids can’t ever think of a thing to ask for. I love that about them.
I think it helps that we don’t have a TV-so no toy commercials–or ever buy anything but food and books!
I think this is a vital question for Christian families. Thanks for raising it, Amanda.
The values of parents are shown loud and clear (to children) in their choices.
Our situation is unique because we don’t live in American culture (although we are Americans). We don’t own a home or a car. Instead, we spend a lot (relatively) of money on traveling, dining with friends, and books. So for us, memories, relationships, and learning are more important than possessions.
Another huge thing that keeps my daughter from being (too) materialistic is her awareness of poverty. She has seen true poverty that makes her understand crystal clear just how blessed she is on many levels. I think that many American children and teens really need to travel to developing and 3rd world countries to get this revelation. We ARE RICH. So we should be first thankful and second generous.
Now, I’m not saying my Sprite is a mini-saint. She admitted last time in USA that she couldn’t handle another trip to the Target. It was causing her far too much pressure to WANT those wonderful TOYS and CANDY (which we just don’t have here). So she struggles with it like anyone, young or old, but the best part is that she recognizes that temptation and fights it! She was 8 at that time. We’re going to visit USA at the end of this month. Now that she’s 10 it will be interesting to see how she deals with the temptation.
Whenever we find our children struggling with difficult issues (like materialism), we find that turning to the Scriptures and showing them how God feels about the matter softens their hearts and bears much fruit in their lives. It’s not that they don’t respect what mom and dad have to say about life, it just that when they realize that their Maker and Creator of the Universe has specific thoughts about their behavior, it seems to carry a whole lot more weight (if you know what I mean!). It is absolutely amazing to me how reading, discussing, and meditating on oneBible verse can far outweigh any “loving lecture” I may give them (and believe me, I’ve done my share of lecturing!) But we much prefer using God’s Word as our guide for training.
Certainly any topical Bible concordance will help you find Bible verses that go along with materialism, but I would also highly recommend Doorposts’ For Instruction in Righteousness. This is a gem of a resource. It covers so many topics such as pride, discontentment, selfishness/greed (materialism), laziness, anger, etc. My favorite aspect to this resource is that not only does it list Bible verses relating to each topic, but it also includes verses that show the blessings that will come from obedience, and verses that show the consequences from disobedience. For example, a consequence for materialism is found in Proverbs 11:28 which says, “He who trusts in his riches, will fall.” The book also gives many Bible stories that illustrate the point. An example would be Luke 18:22-26 which talks about how a rich man who was unwilling to give up his riches will find it hard to enter the kingdom of God, etc.
Didn’t mean for this to turn into a sermon! Just wanted to share with you what has worked in our family!
My first line of defence is to stay out of stores as much as possible. We do not do any recreational shopping as some families do. Now my kids are only 9 and 6 so as they get older I know it will be a bit more of a challenge.
I had a real eye-opener the other day. We have basically been without TV since the signal switched to digital – we just can’t tune in a signal. About a month ago I got the idea to take a tiny tv around the house and see if there was a spot where I could get a signal, and I found one, so we started letting the kids watch Sat. morning cartoons. My almost 6 year old son said enthusiastically, after watching a couple of hours of cartoons, “Wow, Mom, how would I know about all these cool things if I didn’t ever get to watch TV?” How, indeed. Want, want, want. Not just toys but junk food – and toys from the junk food restaurant. (This morning – the fifth Sat., probably, since we started watching the cartoons again, I asked if they wanted me to try to tune them in – NOPE they said as they sailed out the door – warm spring morning trumps cartoons )
I can forget that commercials even exist if I never turn on the tv because I use Firefox with an ad blocker online LOL. The ads on some of the kids sites are shocking – we looked at Nick Jr with the google browser and I couldn’t believe all the ads.
I think there is a difference between wanting something new because we have a need for it – Mom I want some more Little Pet Shops for my birthday because I am starting some new families and I need some aunts and uncles (she actually told me this – she makes complicated family trees for them all – this is creative play and it is good and healthy) and wanting something new because we have suddenly become dissatisfied with what we have (Mom I want some more little pet shops because XYZ kid has more than me, or because I saw the commercial for them.) I think that is materialism. I guess I am trying to feel out the difference between enjoying things – toys clothes tools books even food? – and having a greedy desire for these things.
I don’t want to discourage enjoyment and valuing things – but I do want to discourage greed and materialism. It’s hard . . .