I just finished Consider This and really liked it. It really helped me see the “why” of education the CM way in a very easy to understand language. I found it to make me think in a good way, not telling me what to do, but truly things to consider. The chapters were not too long, it was easy for me to fit into a busy schedule. I could see reading it again from time to time.
I have read both of these in the last few months and found Consider This much richer. (I confess that my opinion is partially based on how many entries into my commonplace book each of them required. hee hee!) I enjoyed them both, but Consider This really illuminated some CM concepts and the overall philosophy. It was an “aha” book for me. I enjoyed them both, but if I had to choose one to re-read, it would be Consider This.
This is my first ever post here though I’m a longtime lurker, and I think I have a dorky avatar that my oldest daughter made years ago. Bwa ha!
I finished Consider This and am trying to find the time to finish working through the Living Page.
I thought that Consider This was wonderful…it really was thought- provoking and readable. I am going to re-read it soon. I would read it before the Living Page simply because it helps you as the teacher/mentor to think through your purpose in choosing this philosophy/method of education. The whys of your goals matter – it is a way of inspiring, uplifting, and to help yourself avoid burnout. Then the Living Page can illustrate some ways to accomplish those ideals and goals of a classical education for you.
I personally am full of admiration for Charlotte Mason’s abilities and talents of making classical education obtainable for anyone. I am grateful to use her methods and read her philosophy with a deeper appreciation for her wisdom and experience as I try to more fully spread the feast for my family – with meaning and purpose. Both Consider This and The Living Page are great ways to encourage and show us practical ways to a classical education.
In addition to Charlotte’s 6 volume set, her biography titled “The Story of Charlotte Mason” by Essex Cholmondeley is an enlightening read. Totally worth the inter-library loan. =)