Gina, for someone without a love of reading, I do think that Any Novel could be a good option. I myself will most likely stick with Lightning Lit for my current 16yo as I am certain he is college bound and it is more like a college course. BUT I am keeping options open with ds#3. I am going to see how it goes and evaluate over the next couple of years with Any Novel, I think. I’m not certain I’ll be happy with it all the way through high school . . . but I do think the potential is there for it to be a tool to be used in high school as well. So I can’t promise you that it would be the ONLY thing you would need all the way through high school to be perfect college prep—-BUT I do think you can use it extensively in high school, and I’m not sure yet how much else you might want. Perhaps one LL course in senior year as “college practice”? I don’t know for sure, mostly because it’s so new to me we haven’t road-tested it yet! But I can see it being something you use for much of high school then see what you might need to supplement if you are sure they are headed to college.