Well, first off, even those who are homeschooling legally can end up with someone from child protective services (or whatever it might be called where you live) showing up at your door….all due to an unfounded complaint from perhaps a neighbor or relative who disagrees with homeschooling or simply dislikes how you have chosen to raise your children. If you subscribe to the HSLDA Weekly Update e-newsletter, which you can do even if you’re not a member, you’ll see reports of this happening in states across the country. You’ll also see how often the HSLDA attorneys are able to resolve the issue for their member families in a relatively timely manner.
Why not simply call a private attorney? Well, first, you would have to know for a fact that the private attorney thoroughly understands homeschooling laws in your state and is in agreement with your right to homeschool. When someone is standing at your door, demanding to come inside and/or speak with your children, you probably won’t have time to search the yellow pages and make calls to lawyers. However, a call to HSLDA will get you someone on the line who is adequately prepared to deal with the issue at hand. Their staff of attorneys has researched homeschool laws in all 50 states and has the information they need at their fingertips–it’s what they do, day in and day out.
I’m not as familiar with HLA, but if cost is an issue, their organization is probably just as willing and able to help at a lower membership cost. However, HSLDA offers a grant program to pay for membership fees of those who have a financial need and cannot afford the membership cost.
There are also other benefits HSLDA offers, such as webinars and articles on a variety of homeschooling topics, including homeschooling a special needs child (and there’s a special e-newsletter about Homeschooling Your Struggling Learner). If I were you, I would consider subscribing to their Weekly Update newsletter for awhile (easy to cancel and they won’t keep pestering you) and you can read brief articles about how they are helping homeschooling families around the country….even internationally.