As your children get older and gain better reading skills how does the process of handing over readings to be independent go? Which subjects do you pass off first? Do you always pre-read the books before they read them? What independent reading do you require narration from? Do you always keep a literature read-aloud no matter how old they get?
Right now dd6 is ready to move on to easy chapter books. Some of our module 2 history books she could handle but I’m not sure I want to miss out on reading those together. So I could maybe have her read those aloud to me instead of by herself. Should I just assign her some good lit books to read apart from school studies and make a point to talk about them with her to make sure she is comprehending what she is reading? How much time per day is reasonable to expect her to read independently? We do an hour of quiet time each day so part of that could easily be reading time.
Sorry for all the questions! We’re just hitting a transition point right now and I’m not sure where to go from here.
Well, I’m not sure I do this the best way and I’d love to hear what others say. But my 7 and 9 yos read daily, alternating a fun/literature book like Little House on the Prairie with a homeschool-y book, usually relating to what we are doing in history. I have them narrate the former to me orally and the latter they also do orally but I write it down for them. My 9yo in particular is not the best with written stuff so he is probably a little behind on that. Even my 11 and 12yo only read for school every other day though they read longer things and do their own written narrations and do a pretty god job of it. And they choose to read a lot on their own for fun which the younger two don’t. Persoanlly, since I have 4 kids close in age, there is a lot we do together and it just seems easier if most of our work I read aloud to them all at once. Also I like that time with them so it is hard to give it up.
To get back to your question, if i had a 6yo who was doing well with reading, I woudl probably require one reading a day of maybe 15-20 minutes (or even 10) and then have them narrate to me orally. It coudl be either a “fun” book or something relating to what you are studying.
I haven’t passed much on for them to do independently (mine are 10, 8, 6, and 3). I assign them a literature book, one about their reading level (or slightly below). They read a chapter a day at some point when I’m busy with the other children. Right now, my 5th grader is reading “Becuase of Winn Dixie” and my 2/3rd grader is reading The Littles. I rarely have them narrate from this book…we save that for Bible, science, and history readings. They also read aloud a lesson from a McGuffey reader each week as well as portions of the Bible reading. I sometimes have them narrate from the McGuffey reading as well. My 6yo reads aloud daily from a phonics reader since she is just beginning to read…I like to continue this through at least 2nd grade. We also have a family read aloud, using the SCM literature modules (or other similar books). I hope to continue these readings through high school!
I don’t usually pre-read the books…I try to stick to quality books and only pre-read if I think there might be issues with the book. Sometimes I just quickly scan the pages. They also read on their own time, usually before bed. They tend to pick easier picture books or children’s Bibles, which is why I started assigning them a chapter book during lessons.
I generally read aloud the history books since I like my 8yo to listen as well…I may have them do the grades 4-6 books independently next year.
I think I read somewhere that Charlotte handed over the reading on their own at about year 4, so anyone younger than that would have their “school” books read to them. My oldest (8th) reads all of his own except I still have him with us for Bible/geo (SCM guide) and anything Fine Art related.
My 10yo really needs to be doing all of his own reading but he still likes to be read to (by me), listen in on what I’m reading to his younger sibling, or wants to read aloud to me. He will read some of his books to himself but he’d rather just with me. That is just too much for me sometimes. I love to listen to him read but I just don’t always have the time. He enjoys an audience, I suppose, and he has a younger sibling but that doesn’t always work out for reading to him. When next school year starts, he really has to be doing most of his own reading, if not all of it. I think he’s like Peter Pan and just doesn’t want to grow up and sees that as a move on my part in forcing him to grow up.
Anyway, my 7yo is still read to from all of his “school” books and will be for quite awhile. His reading skills have not caught up with his comprehensive skills, so it’s going to be awhile.
DD12 – completely independent except for spelling; also listens in to family read alouds and family Bible at night
DS9 – mostly independent; I read some history to him; we do spelling and some simple English concepts together. He listens to family read alouds and Bible at night.
DD6 – We will begin 1st in the fall. She reads at a 3/4 grade level (self taught in days – a wonder at my house). I will plan to do most of her 1st grade with her, but I expect that she will want to do some things on her own already.
Our goal is to create lifelong learners who aren’t dependent on me to tell them what’s next. I set their course for the year and will begin taking more input from dd12 soon, but once that course is set, they’re off. By 4th grade, we expect our kids to be mostly independent. We’re here to answer questions, help work through sample math problems, but the weight of learning is on their shoulders.
My oldest, 9 y/o and 3rd grade, is a struggling reader and I can’t give her anything to read on her own. It is frustrating at times tht she is still so totally 100% dependent.
My 7 y/o and 1st grader is advanced and able to do many things on her own. This year she has been assigned the Christian Liberty Nature reader to read 10 minutes a day. She has read the 1st, 2nd, 3rd and will finish the 4th this year. I have also assigned her a literature or history (not necessarily our time period being studied) book to read 1 chapter (unless long chapters, then we break it up). I have not assigned her to narrate them to me. Mostly because her sister is so time consuming. Sometimes she does on her own, sometimes she doesn’t. I think next year I need to make narrating a requirment. Maybe I’ll have her do a notebooking page or something.
Any actual “class books” we read as a family since I am reading them to her sister anyways. We use the SCM guides for Bible/histor/geo. This next year they will be in different levels, but I am just planning on us all doing the 4th-6th grade books. It will make it easier to just stick together. I might assign DD7 some of the 1st-3rd books to read on her own.
DS9 is almost at total independence. He still needs me to redirect him or point him back toward his work when he gets yawn-y or distracted, but he does a great job overall.
DD almost 8 is less independent, but can still do many things on her own.
The first thing I passed off to them was beginner reading. We used the Pathway readers, so they would read their next chapter and then come narrate to me. Occasionally, they read aloud to me or each other to work on elocution. This will be our last year to use the Pathway readers, as my children have outgrown them. Next year, I’m assigning various chapter books for them to read independently and narrate. Ds will most likely do written narrations; dd is still narrating orally.
Bible, history, and literature are read aloud by me and done as a family with oral narrations. Each child has their own separate, independent reading for history. When I do teach grammar, that is not independent. I sit down with the child and have a simple, parent-directed lesson twice per week.
When given a list (such as a print off from SCM), both children are capable of pacing themselves and working independently; however, I stay close by to give help when asked or redirect if they become distracted or distract one another. We have decided to keep our home office in our school room, so that I can keep track of the Organizer, browse blogs or Pinterest, or do my own research while they are busy on their schoolwork. I am nearby, but not giving constant help or teaching.
Thank you all for your responses. I’m feeling less stressed already. 🙂 Dd does read frequently on her own, picture books or easy readers from the library. I wasn’t sure how much to push (because I know she CAN do it) but it seems like a short daily reading time from an engaging but simple chapter book with an informal narration (What happened in your story today?) is a great start. Hopefully she will come to see that books without pictures are not scary. LOL
Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)
The topic ‘Independent reading for younger kids’ is closed to new replies.