This isn’t a husband bashing post, I just need to vent and get advice.
I’ve been homeschooling my children from the start and my oldest are just turned 10 and 8.
The others are 5,2 and baby. Some days I am very overwhelmed and today was one of those days.
The baby was crying and refusing to be anywhere but my lap, there were dishes in the sink, the 2 yr old kept getting out of bed when she was supposed to be napping and my school age girls were doing their math work when my husband came home from running errands. My 10 yr old asked him for help with her math and though he was getting ready for work he agreed to help her and then he became frustrated with her and then with me.
He asked why they are only doing 20 minutes of math a day, he felt they should sit and do a whole chapter, no matter how long it takes. Then he said that they are both behind and my 10 year old should “really be doing multiplications and higher levels of math by now.” I’ll be honest, math is my absolute worst subject and I am awful at it and still intimidated by it. A combination of that and the stressful things and seasons of busyness we’ve been through (births, depression, deaths in the family, major moves) have all contributed to us not being on top of math. I feel completely awful about it on my own but him saying that made me feel truly terrible and I could see our daughters were upset too. I told him that we are where we are and we are just working through each step in our math books daily and that’s all we can do. I also said that one of the great things about homeschooling is we can go at our own pace so I really dont like saying that they have to know this or that by this or that age. He disagreed with me and said that between them being so behind and things not getting done around the house and our 2 yr old “doing whatever she wants” maybe they just need to go to school 🙁
I’m trying not to be completely angry, I know he has let me make the decisions regarding their education and I know the house and stuff is my job, but in this season of my life I just cant seem to stay on top of everything. Sometimes I don’t feel cut out for this life. I was raised by a single mom who was very career focused. I didn’t plan to marry, have kids or stay home and certainly not to homeschool or keep house. I really do try to do well in all these areas and keep things looking at least presentable but some days it doesnt happen. Schooling and babies take priority.
Anyway, I really do feel like my children have a wonderful well rounded education and they are becoming godly people, but they aren’t doing so well in math right now but I hope to get them caught up. Do you think that is possible without enrolling them in school? I love everything about homeschooling the Charlotte Mason way and being able to influence my children positively everyday so I feel like it wouldn’t be worth it to put them into school just because of Math. Or because we don’t always get all the house work done.
I’m so sorry for the rough day! It sounds like everyones frustration spilled over today. Don’t loose heart. You are doing Great! Do the older kiddos help with chores? (dishes, laundry, wiping down the bathroom, etc)My 6 year old has been such a help with putting away dishes, changing bathroom garbage and doing a few loads of laundry from start to finish each week. Maybe put Math as the second thing of the day to get down after Bible/Hist/Geog studies and then something you enjoy teaching to the older kids right afterwards to help it not be such a chore for you (art and music study have been my “chore” subjects lately).
Thank you.I really need some encouragement from other homeschool moms, people who get it. The older kids do help, they are wonderful helpers but still things aren’t always looking perfect in here. I will try changing up the schedule. I’m not sure if we should switch to doing so many pages instead of 20 minutes though. I don’t want math to take all day or for any of us to struggling with liking math even more 🙁
I have found that using a bribe to get math done without fussing is helpful! ?
Actually, I bribed the daughter that I have this exact trouble with……and timed her (without her knowing). So now I know how long it really takes her to do a normal math lesson. If she’s having trouble and needs help, we just work at it until the timer goes off, or until I see that she’s getting frustrated. It was eye-opening for my daighter to see that she could complete a math lesson in 30 minutes…..and then she could see how her not focusing was costing her play time and was more stressful, too.
Also, you could perhaps look into a different math curriculum. Maybe Teaching Textbooks or something that would be easier on you and maybe easier on them, too.
As for housework, try to figure out what your husband likes to see and do that. For example, my husband likes the mudroom tidy and the kitchen table cleared off. If he sees those spaces clear, he feels rested and peaceful coming into the house. He sees the mountain of dishes, but it doesn’t bother him, if those two spaces are tidy.
I am the opposite! I need floors and counters tidy, but I have learned to get what bothers him tidied up before he comes in because it just makes him more comfortable. Obviously, it doesn’t happen every time he comes in (he’s a dairy farmer, and I just never know when he’ll be in for a meal or snack or whatever), but he knows I’m trying and that goes a long way to helping us both keep things in perspective.
Other than that, consider yourself hugged! I think we’ve all been there. Sometimes husbands walk in at the worst times, and in their desire to help, make things worse. I would encourage you to consciously think the best of your husband. (The “love thinketh no evil” verse.) If you go too far down the “he just doesn’t get it” path, it can be detrimental to your family.
Oh my goodness, do I understand the tough place where you are! I have 6 kids 8 and under so first of all we are a bit out-numbered aren’t we? :). Add in the fact that quite a few of your kiddos are younger and with that comes its own challenges! I want you to hear me when I say I have been where you are! In moments of frustration my husband has said similar things about the state of the house and homeschooling, although he is very supportive of me homeschooling! First of all, Take a deep breath and remind your self that this is just a season of life! Especially If you have a baby! My kids are 8, 6, 5, 4, 3 and 1! We have also had several major moves in the last few years so that is a major life change and a lot of extra work on top of an already busy life! It has been a season of life that has been full! Secondly, think of ways you can address your husbands concerns! Over the last year or so I have really felt like I just couldn’t keep up and with several “littles” including a baby and several kids I was doing school with, I just couldn’t keep up! My husband made a few comments! I spoke to him about it being discouraging and he very genuinely apologized! I told him I was frustrated too! I said nothing more about it but set about coming up with up with some real solutions! First, I set out to train my kiddos 🙂 My children would help when asked, but I needed them to have set jobs they did at certain times of day! Jobs I needed to be diligent to train them in! After a few weeks, we are still training but I am beginning to feel some relief! Also, another problem was we had too much stuff! We had way too many toys and I needed to go through it all and simply. Of course, this takes time, which is usually in short supply, but I remind myself that I will reap the reward and so will my children! My husband came home a few weeks ago and I had reduced the girls toys by half (with their help)! I mentioned to him that I was going to work on the boys room next and he happily freed me up one evening for that! I am working my way through the rest of the house! So, think of ways to address the issues you are having! Simplifying has brought about such peace for me already and I’m not even done! Thirdly, as far as Math goes….. I need to ask a few questions. Are your kids thriving in every area except Math? That’s what I’m hearing from your post. Are you moving at their pace? What are you using for Math? Are you spending too long on a concept or are you moving on once they get it? It’s hard to give feedback on this one without knowing more, but be encouraged, you don’t need to put them in school because of Math! Just evaluate and go from there! And btw… I always struggled in Math! We are doing Rightstart, although I don’t follow their curriculum exactly but rather use it as a tool! We are using a lot of Math: An Instrument for Living Teaching by Simply Charlotte Mason! I love it and it has proven to be very beneficial so far! Hang in there momma!
So, as for math… (haha, let’s get the monster dealt with first). So, while understanding that I despise those “expected outcome” lists, I will say that yes, your 10 year old should be doing multiplication by now. In fact, I would say by 8, definitely by 9, it should be starting to be introduced (introduced/learning…. not mastered! lol). So… I would say make that a goal for both of them if possible. And, while CM said short lessons, if you NEED to do 30 minutes to be able to better tackle math… then don’t feel you can’t just because of the “method”. Also, maybe you need to do math twice in one day – do a 20 minute session in the morning, and another one in the afternoon.
I understand about being overwhelmed in certain seasons of life. I’ve been there. It’s hard to manage everything you think you should be doing for “school”. Quite honestly, what I would suggest is cut back on some of the “extra” subjects for awhile, I would say even the rest of this year (going on the assumption you follow the typical school year), and instead focus your time and attention on JUST the 3Rs, and especially focusing on math. Quite honestly… it’s better to get behind on science/ geography/history/poetry/picture studies than the 3Rs. Being behind in history/geography will not have nearly the impact on a child, that being behind in math or reading will. Those topics are also ones that are easily studied/caught up on, in short time periods, later on. I also agree with the others, look at adding something they can do independently – Teaching Textbooks, even online games like Math Seeds, IXL, Khan Academy.
I think your husband had a legitimate concern (my husband would also be worried), but…. definitely expressed it in the wrong way! That said – I can see how it would be frustrating for him, as he’s trying to help her all the while he’s supposed to be getting ready for work, so he was probably stressed out about getting ready on time, everything else that was going on, and then unfortunately took it out on you. And it was definitely wrong of him to talk about it in front of the children, I can imagine how hurt they were.
I would say that by focusing more attention on math and just the 3Rs, by trying to get them a bit “caught up” (not that I really like that term, lol), it might reassure him, and even yourself, because you’re obviously aware that they’re behind, and it’s bothering you, too.
As for the rest of it – we’ve ALL had those days, trust me! The days where the sink is piled high, one’s crying (or screaming or they all are), the laundry is in a basket, the dust bunnies are mating, the list goes on 🙂
I will ask this, only because, from the sounds of what you’ve written it sounds like it may be the case – are “these” days, becoming the norm? Is it more often that you are unable to keep up on the house work? If it is, then there’s probably ways of working on that.
1. Do you have a daily routine? You might want to look at setting one. While I realize that with young children a minute to minute schedule is not feasible, but an overall general routine may help all of you. For us we get up, get dressed, have breakfast, clean the kitchen, and immediately tackle lessons. After lessons I let the kids have some free time while I do a bit of cleaning. Then there’s lunch, clean the kitchen again, and family chore time. I’m going to assume there’s nap time in the afternoon for you, so that’s a great time to get some cleaning done (when they cooperate and actually sleep, lol), or tackle that extra math lesson. More free time in the afternoon for the kids here while I prepare supper etc… Just a general routine, try and get regular “cleaning” times set into your day. A few minutes here and there, consistently throughout the day, can go a long way. We always try to keep the kitchen cleaned up after each meal. I also have the children pick up all their toys before their father gets home from work. My husband really does not like walking into the house and seeing a bunch of clutter everywhere, so I try very hard to make sure things are picked up for him.
I agree with one of the other ladies – what housekeeping thing bothers your husband the most? Try to make that one a special priority to stay on top of – whether that’s keeping the laundry caught up, the dishes caught up, or the toys picked up etc… That said, my husband is also aware that sometimes there are those days, and if he values his life he’ll keep his mouth shut on those days (lol, I’m kidding). But seriously, he understands those days, but if it were becoming a regular habit, he would likely be upset. He has a stressful job, and coming home to a disorderly home day after day would definitely increase his stress load.
2. Are the children helping you? Your 5, 8 and 10 year old should most definitely be doing chores and helping you around the house now, which would greatly help your load. I would start a chore chart/routine, with set chores for everyone. At their ages, they can definitely wash dishes, put away dishes, set the table, clear the table, dust, sweep, vacuum, feed any pets (with supervision for the youngest), fold laundry, put away their laundry etc… Your 8 & 10 year old should be capable of preparing simple snacks and breakfast and lunch. This isn’t to say they should be doing ALL the housework, but quite honestly, they should be expected to help in pretty well all areas. Here, we have assigned daily chores: so for this week, their jobs are:
5 year old: make her bed, put away her folded laundry (I still hang stuff up because she can’t reach), keeping her toys picked up (with reminders from me), setting the table, clearing the table.
8 year old: make bed, put away all clean laundry, keeping toys picked up, feed the pets, put away the clean dishes and he’s also in charge of bringing up the firewood from the basement.
Then every day we have a designated family chore, so example: Monday we do our baking, Tuesday we clean the kitchen, Wednesday we clean the floors (vacuum and mop, sweeping is daily), Thursday is dusting, Friday is the bathroom Saturday is cleaning the entry porch. Sunday is rest.
So after lunch, we have “family chore time”, where we all work on the day’s cleaning job together. Working together it only takes 20-30 minutes.
I’ve learned the hard way that working in small chunks throughout the day, even 5 minutes here or there, makes it much easier to stay on top of the cleaning. Example: I keep Clorox wipes on the toilet. Once a day when I go to the bathroom, I take 30 seconds, grab a wipe, and wipe down the toilet. Once a day, the next time I go to the bathroom, I’ll wipe off the sink and counter. Again, 30 seconds. But it’s just a quick thing that helps me stay on top. Keeping the kitchen tidied up after each meal – whether that’s loading/unloading the dishewasher, stacking the dishes neatly by the sink for washing, making sure everything is put away. It generally only takes 5-10 minutes, but makes a big difference by the end of the day.
3. The same old advice everyone always says, that we always laugh at: “Sleep when the baby sleeps”. So okay, we both know a nap isn’t going to happen, lol. But, if at all possible, try and take even just 15 minutes to sit down with your feet up. Read, pray, just lay there doing nothing if you want. Just rest for a few minutes.
4. Make sure you’re getting enough rest at night. That may be hard, I’m not sure what kind of sleeper your baby is, but as much as possible anyways, make sure you go to bed at a good time.
Hugs to you. We’ve all been there. Laundry is my achilles heel. I do fairly well at keeping up on everything else, BUT laundry. My husband and daughter are the worst offenders because they create an insane amount of laundry. So, our laundry is often in baskets waiting to be folded. I’m trying to put through smaller loads, and put it away immediately, instead of doing giant loads, or waiting until night to then try and tackle 3-4 loads.
Some days are just plain crappy. They leave you second guessing everything. Sometimes, entire seasons are crappy. You’ll wonder what you were thinking, you’ll feel like a failure. But, just remember that God called you to this, He will give you the strength to get through it. Talk to your husband (calmly, without anger). Talk to each other about your feelings, what you want to see, tell him you’re going to try and focus more on math and that you’re going to try harder around the house (perhaps more specifically list something that you know he finds stressful to see undone), but ask him to understand that sometimes, there are hard days, that having 5 children means some days, there are going to be “those” days, and for him to please be patient with you, because they are just as stressful for you.
Maybe it would be helpful to take a few days off school and focus on getting caught up on the house and (if you’re not already doing this) teaching your older kids to do some chores? Then come up with a simple plan to keep things reasonably under control, and that will make your days go more smoothly and your husband happier.
20 mins a day is not just enough math for a 10 YO. My 10 YO 4th grader spends roughly 40 mins a day on math (though it would be less if she didn’t dawdle so much). She started learning long division last year, and is soon going to be going through it again (just to give you an idea of what 3rd and 4th grade math covers). She stared multiplication in 2nd grade. Like others have said, really consider cutting other things out to focus on getting them caught up.
On the 2 YOs naps…if you regularly have trouble with her getting out of bed, it may be worth it to sit with her for a few minutes while she goes to sleep and require her to lay still. I have had to do this with my now 5 YO and 3 YO for at least 2 years. Otherwise…naps won’t happen. It’s well worth the 10-15 minutes I spend every day making sure they go to sleep and I get some quiet time!
Just a quick note to say that my heart goes out to you. We have six kids and, although I really like things neat and tidy, it is very difficult with our 2yo in the house. That age is crazy bent on destroying the place. But also cute.
I liked the idea that someone had of asking your husband what gets to him the most and try to have that part cleaned up for him.
I’m sorry for your rough day. Been there many times. xo
Reduce school subject load; Do math 2x a day with the oldest
Also, start moving the 10yr to more independence in her schoolwork overall
Do only math, reading, grammar (for the 1o yr old), and writing for about two weeks, so you can have a breather, establish a chore list, and train the kids in chores, get the house close to the way you want it, begin catching up
Play classical music in the background and put up pretty artwork, have sturdy artwork books available for young ones to browse through on their own; let them be exposed to these arts by osmosis for a while
Also, if your children’s picture books are filled with actual illustrations instead of cartoonish figures or computer drawings, then they are being exposed that way, too; so don’t worry about the liberal arts stuff right now
I’d suggest having a serious talk with your husband; moms and homeschooling moms especially will second guess themselves plenty without the help of the husband or a friend making it worse
I would also stand firm on your timing and why; if she struggling with a concept, sitting there for an hour isn’t going to help her; if he got frustrated with her in that small amount of time, maybe he should try to look at it from your perspective, then
Sharing your plans for getting her “caught up” and getting a better handle on the house may help as it shows potential action; ask him if he has any ideas, like taking some or all of the kids out on the weekends to the park or wherever; something so you can clean or rest or both; 24/7 with all of them all the time WILL BURN YOU OUT!
However, you need to find out if his expectations are even realistic, considering the ages of your children; you cannot be expected to be perfect or even close and run yourself ragged in the process; plus, in the future, these conversations must be done in private
Your job is just as stressful as his; the kids and the home are entrusted to you and if you are faltering, he needs to find out what HE needs to do to support you and listen to your frustrations, too, not just complain, which just adds more pressure on you; he is to help strengthen you, not weaken you
His job probably ends for the most part (depending on his career) when he gets home, whereas parenting doesn’t end, so you have to keep going; that’s something that should be considered, to, IMO, in determining what will help things
Does he ask you what HE can do to help take off some pressure? Have you told him what you need to help make things run more smoothly?
You mentioned depression in your original post; I assume from the last child? That needs to be addressed, too, as these types of situations aren’t helpful if you are prone to it
My dd couldn’t, developmentally, do multiplication at 10, no matter what we did; now she is 14 and she is doing it easily, but she does a lot of math now, so she can get her math and science meeting up together in high school
Teaching Textbooks, BJU, and Saxon have classes online (Virtual Homeschool Group) and in DVD form that would take the pressure off, if they would work for your child, too, that would be great
BJU has major sales on their online classes ($99 for online class) in the early winter and new year; I know that doesn’t help now, but it might be helpful in the future
Blessings to all the generous mothers on this forum who took so much time to support and offer advice. I can’t think of anything to add – it’s all been well said above. But just wanted one more hug sent to you, and to be one more voice assuring you that “those days” do happen.
I always hesitate suggesting someone change curriculum -because I know it’s a big deal. But I must tell you that my “those days” almost disappeared when we switched to Teaching Textbooks. Hands down, best homeschooling decision I’ve made. It was like someone gave me three extra hours to better manage/enjoy my day, and three extra hours of sleep at night (due to the unmistakable decrease in stress!)
Ladies, thank you all so much for giving me a lot to think about. Your responses were so honest and thoughtful and I appreciate them. I want to address some of the things said and asked.
I’ll have to have a serious sit down talk with my husband. I’m honestly not sure what exactly he needs to have looking nice when he gets home to feel ok. I was a neat freak myself, so things being messy, especially clutter, makes me crazy.I can barely function in a messy space, so it is something I have been focusing on more, along with making the space more beautiful. Not that my husband seems to care much about that part and my 2 yr old definitely doesnt lol
My children all help with chores as best they can, but I’ll be honest, we don’t have a good routine established. They have their own chores but I am awful about staying on top of them because I like things done a very specific way, so I end up trying to do it all myself. Like a crazy person lol I know this is a real problem and I am going to try training my children to do the job better so I’m not going insane over it. I own Laying Down the Rails, maybe that will be a helpful read and I should get to reading it 🙂
I’ve really struggled with depression since my life changed so much and I started staying home instead of working full time, this happened when i got pregnant with child #3. I love being home with them and homeschooling, it just overwhelms me at times. It has gotten better as I’ve gotten help and we’ve made more friends and got involved with more things.
Now, about Math. We currently use Math U See. I like it, it does have a dvd option but we havent used the dvd, maybe we should. Honestly, I am not sure where to go from here with getting them caught up. Personally, I was introduced to multiplication in 4th grade in public school so I didn’t think they were horribly behind. Now, I am wondering how the heck I am supposed to get them caught up. Many of you suggested just focusing on the 3 Rs and nothing else (I’ll admit, it’ll be hard because I love all the other stuff). Still, I’m not sure what I should do. I do think I may be spending too much time on a concept. Only recently did I realize that I don’t have to finish an entire book or chapter, after someone mentioned this on a homeschool blog. I know we didn’t when I was in school but it feels odd and wasteful to me to not finish a book all the way through. What are your thoughts?
Should we switch to the next books (Currently my children seem bored and keep asking why they have to do this stuff that they already know and just did)? A new curriculum? (Online classes really sounds amazing, I’ll be honest)Should I have them start working on memorizing the multiplication facts? I would like to know what you would do to get your child caught up.
We use MUS and I can’t imagine not using the DVD’s. My kids love him and it helps me so much to stay consistant. I rarely need the teachers guide, because the DVD walks us through.
It takes only 10-15 min per lesson but know it will start taking longer as books progress, do 20 min in our house is plenty.
So she is in Beta in 4th grade? Gamma introduces multiplication and Delta division. My DD is in 4th grade and in Delta so doing long division.
If you look in pasts posts for MUS tristen had her DD switch to MUS later and has talked about how she caught up. That might give some thoughts to help.
Is she struggling with concepts, the how to, or just memorizing. I will be honest, my kids might not be the fastest but they know how, so I did not prevent them from moving on and with time they are recalling faster and faster the math facts.
And doing an entire chapter in MUS at one sitting would be way too much. We do one page front & back. Usually we only need a page or two (A, B) for the new concept and then do all the review pages (D, E, F). So it takes about one week for each chapter
I also did multiplication in 4th, so she really shouldn’t be stressing about this; she doesn’t need to feel like there is something wrong with her
When you talk to your husband, explain that MUS is a mastery-based program that is used successfully in private schools, too. Contrast for him why that is different from the spiral curriculum normally used in public school
You also need to pay attention to whether the MUS approach is working for your child, with or without the DVD.
What is she actually struggling with?
Is she actually struggling, or is she just “behind” due to life’s events?
Is the mastery approach working for her?
I would try it with the DVDs (take some teaching pressure off of yourself!) and see how she does for a while before deciding to switch; diagnose the problem first and increase to two times a day.
For ex: as first independent subject of the day, watch DVD then do A; then after lunch or free-time, do B. Then, the next day, 1st Session: C, 2nd Session: E. If she does stupendously, give her the test on the 3rd day, instead of page F (my son never does G), if yo think she needs more practice, do F in the 1st Session, and then the test on the same day for the 2nd Session.
Also, I skipped the extra ‘new math’ nonsense (my opinion) that exists in MUS, that I believed made adding and subtracting multiple digit numbers unnecessarily complicated. So, check and see if that may be an issue.
I tried MUS and the only thing it helped with my dd was place value. After that, his approach confused her and, even with the review pages, the complete mastery approach caused her to forget previous lessons. It irritates my son, too, who is finishing Epsilon
I had also tried TT, but even though she got the answers correct on the computer, deeper scrutiny showed me it wasn’t sticking.
So, with that knowledge, I switched to Christian Light Education Sunlight ed; it is semi-spiral, so she gets the direct instruction, very incremental new stuff, and covers previous material extensively within each lesson, which has worked for her because she needs a lot practice, but can’t do long sit-down math sessions. No ‘new math’, it’s a simple, straightforward, traditional approach.
I think it was a combination of mental development and method for my dd.
Thanks for reassuring me I am not totally off. I felt a chapter should take a week, not one sitting.
My daughters are truly behind because of math just not getting done consistently for a log stretch of time, unfortunately. They don’t have any learning issues and thrive in all other areas. They were even doing very well in Math and right now, they are getting what they are learning and sometimes i wonder if I should just go ahead and move them on but they do not have math facts memorized. They can explain a concept, work out problems (definitely on paper, but also in their head if you give them a moment) but i thought they must have math facts down pat and we absolutely must finish every page of the book.
Now it seems like they are getting tired of doing the same things over again.
Moving forward, I will definitely use dvds. It sounds like it would be worth it for me since I am not a math person myself and could use all the help I can get.