I’m having difficulty deciding how to manage the time my children spend on the computer in their free time. Right now I have five children at home. They each get computer time one day of the week (Monday through Friday) for half an hour, although the two oldest (14 and 13) now get 40 minutes. Since they all watch each other play, it works out so all of them are getting at least half an hour a day of participating in that time. This is waaaay less time than any of their friends get, but I feel like it’s waaaay too much. I monitor what they may play, so it isn’t as if they’re playing anything violent, but my ideal would be no mindless computer games. (I gave myself away with the word ‘mindless’) Really, I think my mind is already made up that computer time should be worthy of their time and bad habits have crept in — my fault!! It’s just so difficult when all of their friends parents (who are my friends and who I appreciate mostly) allow so much more than we do. So, why am I writing on here? I suppose because I’m hoping you’ll all jump on my bandwagon and tell me I’m doing the right thing in pulling the plug. Or maybe, I’m all wrong and a bit of mindless activity in the day isn’t all that bad. What do you think?
Well – I don’t know… I became a computer programmer starting with “mindless time” on the computer…. but that said it was in the 1970’s that I started using computers a fair bit (My dad had a very early computer store), so what was available to do on the computer was a lot less…. but I started programming at about age 10.
That said, I do think my kids get way too much tv and computer time… and they get a lot less than most kids out there…
We had a better homeschool day when we were unplugged. I only let them use educational games. My rule is if it isn’t educational then they can’t play it. Now of course this doesn’t mean any mindless games or killing games. I don’t allow those at all! I laughed when one of my children tried to convince me that a certain game was educational because they had to take care of animals… LOL.. I told them if they wanted to take care of animals they could go in the back yard and do it. 🙂 so you see anything can be educational. Tee he he.. So if you schedule certain games for certain times while the others are working on other homework then maybe you will feel at peace. LOL
I do the workbox thing so if I wanted to break up their day maybe I would put computer time in a box. I try to limit it now to 1 day a week. This is when we go to the library. It is usually at the end of the week. We only go when all the chores and all of the homework has been done for the week. You can make it a reward at the end of the day or in the afternoon too. I found that my children read more books if we don’t have computer time during free time or any other time during the week. I know they need computer time but mindless game time robs them of their book time. This is just what I have noticed in our house. I do let them on to practice their typing program or math practice or vocab. practice but that is part of their homework that they don’t know I am sneaking in.. 🙂
I could have written suzukimom’s last paragraph. I feel your struggle b/c I am there too with 6 kids (though little one isn’t on the computer yet thankfully).
I have created a blog where our children know any link on there is acceptable, but then they find links on there that are NOT (one particular free site has some great educational games but then they have some that are not at all educational).
I also had to put some stringent parental controls on the computer b/c of the LEGO.com site. Of all things. One child in particular just could not find balance there and kept going to the same videos. Not bad in and of themselves (LEGO after all) but mindless and he had seen them anyway.
So now the kids when they have their 30 minutes computer time are to go to this site and explore any links from there. For now it is working and I am adding (and deleting) as needed. The nice thing is that if I see one site being used too much, I can just make that post private and it won’t appear for a while. In that way, I can regulate where they are spending time. I was pulling my hair out before.
My 2 children are 8 and 5 and they use the computer together once per month for a few hours, at the beginning of the month. I help them each make a calendar on starfall.com and mark with stars the days that we have plans to go somewhere. They look at it each night in their room and mark off the day. They know when to expect we will go somewhere again. After printing their calendars, they can play games on starfall or pbskids.org. They don’t know any other sites and I think my 8 year old is getting too old for them. My 5 year old sometimes asks the next few days and I say no and follow through on that, and she accepts that she gets to play it only once in a while. They have to manage their own time and learn how to share.
We also limit tv time to educational shows, 0 to 60 min. per day and about once a month a family movie. Wii games are about once a month as a family. Dad sometimes watches Andy Griffith or Leave it to Beaver, etc. a few evenings a week.
But if the tv is off, I find them reading books on their own, or playing with their toys, playing games, or drawing. I don’t have to tell them what to do, but we have discussed how to “occupy yourself gainfully” instead of wasting time. We have discussed what twaddle is and how twaddle can be found in books, tv, and toys and that it is best to avoid them. This is what works for our family.
We use Accountable Kids, they are allowed to use 1 ticket/day for 20-30 minutes of computer time. They can use 2 tickets/day on weekends. It’s a lot better than the old way, with them constantly bugging me. Now I just need to turn MY computer off ….
I would love to go unplugged! Unfortunately, my dh is not entirely on board with that, so it’s a bit of a struggle. I try to control what they can play and when, and also what they can watch and when. I’d love to ditch the cable altogether, but dh works as a technical producer for the Cable company, so I get vetoed on that one pretty quick 🙁
Also, if I’m out for the evening I often come home and find the boys still watching tv or playing a game with dad (usually Wii NHL hockey), or while I’m trying to get the boys ready for bed, he’ll slip off to the bedroom and turn on something. Not helpful, especially because the boys will find an excuse to make their way in there at some point, and what he’s watching is seldom appropriate for the boys. (Did I mention how much I hate having the TV in the bedroom?)
Anyway, I try to set rules about TV and games; I try to explain to my dh my reasons for setting the rules, but mostly I just need to keep praying that he’ll get on board. I know that’s how he likes to unwind at the end of a long day, and he usually doesn”t get home until 6 or later.
Me — I don’t watch much TV at all. I much prefer reading. Ocassionally I’ll find a movie to watch on netflix, but there isn’t much there, either. The only reason I turn the tv on in my bedroom is to check the weather network or see if his live program is over so I can guess about when to expect him home or give him time to get back to his hotel room so I can call to say good-night.
ANY suggestions on how to get THIS family to unplug would be VERY appreciated!
I use to feel so guilty coming here and reading how so many were tv/computer free. I finally realized that my family isn’t everyone elses… It also seemed that some of those who were no computer (mindless) seemed to have mainly younger children.
My boys are 14 and 12 and we got them each laptops for Christmas. I think it is just finding that everchanging balance that works for you. While I do not allow my boys free reign over it and it is only in our living room, I think they need some exposure and guidance in setting limits to it. I really don’t want them getting to college and suddenly having this unending smorgasbord before them and gorging themselves on it. Does that make sense? My boys do TT Math and current events (studentnewsdaily) on the computer each day. For the most part no extra “fun” computer time during the week (sometimes they earn some time for something extraordinary). On Friday and Saturday, they get an hour of free play time. It use to be lego.com, now it’s combat arms… always war–they’re favorite pasttime.
Dad likes to watch tv with them at night. Not my favorite thing for them to do, but he’s the dad and I respect that. He likes to rent netflix movies that he use to watch–old war series, etc.
I like to “veg” in front of the computer sometimes too–reading here, FB, blog surfing… I don’t really see much difference.
Thank you all for your replies. I can see that I really do need to pray about this and come to peace.
On a slightly different note — I read the book “Endangered Minds” many years ago and would recommend it. Can’t remember the author right now, but she cited many studies that showed the effects of screen time on the brains of young children. Too much television at too young of an age actually produces brain damage in children. Mark Hamby, of Lamplighter Publishing also cites studies that have been done on how too much screen time alters our brains.