60-day returns • free shipping on USA orders $129+
Homeschooling recommendations for slight learning disabilities.
- This topic has 10 replies, 5 voices, and was last updated 13 years, 8 months ago by
.
Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
- Posts
I am seriously considering homeschooling my 7 year old daughter. I have long had interest in homeschooling and have researched it for years but due to my own health problems, I took the easy way out. Now, my daughter is paying the price. The teachers at her school are kind and attentive but the curriculum chosen for the school is so ridiculous that even the teachers can’t stand it. The children are all struggling with it and my daughter specifically has problems with abstract concepts so she is totally floundering.
I am wondering if anyone else has had experience with working out a plan for a child with some disability?
My daughter is categorized as having learning disabilities; however, she has a slightly above average IQ that the docs figure would be much higher if she could read. She struggles with reading because she has a very hard time remembering anything that isn’t concretely related to something that makes sense to her…such as the symbolism of a letter and as it pertains to a sound etc…>.<
She has made great improvement this year but she is hating school daily.
Her entire life is homework and she fails spelling tests mostly because by the time we are done with math, reading and dinner there is no more time to study spelling before bed. This is after I’ve already demanded that her homework be reduced.
She is actually quite good at math but has a hard time retaining what she has learned without some kind of refresher so no matter how well she ‘gets it’ before a test, she often fails. You can imagine how well the story problems go if there’s no one to read the problem to her.
I’m so frustrated, for her and for me. I hope I can do this. She is actually very bright but mix dyslexia, memory issues (which cause reading issues) along with the most ridiculous curriculum ever and I see no positive outcome.
I’ve literally sat with their parental instruction sheets and not had a clue as to what they were talking about but being fairly brilliant (hehe) I did know the math so I just taught her the old style way my Granny taught me. She didn’t understand what she’d spent all day in class supposedly ‘learning’ but she quickly understood the basic, old skills.
So, any pointers on how to do this? I’m thinking of starting her fresh next year although I’m tempted to jump in now as she’s still 7 but assuming I wait until next year for a clean break, I’m not sure where exactly to start her. I’m wondering if I should do something modified…sort of a mix of 2nd grade so she can actually learn something and 3rd grade so she doesn’t get too behind but I don’t want too much for her. Especially while we are figuring things out.
Oh, I’m so sorry your little one is going through this. I think if it were me I would take her out right away and end the stress now.
There isn’t much time left in this school year, and I don’t think I would try to make up anything in the next few weeks. I would just de-stress and read to her and play math games and have fun. She’ll probably learn more in the next weeks doing that than if you were to leave her in school or try hard to “teach” her for the rest of this year. My advice for next year, also is not to use a boxed curriculum. It doesn’t sound like that would bring the kind of change she needs.
Also, I wanted to tell you that a lot of us homeschool moms have health problems, and sometimes the kids suffer because of that, but I don’t think mine have suffered as much as they would have by being away from me all day. There is so much more to learning than academics.
You’ll be able to cater to her needs for concrete concepts so much better than a teacher at school. I’m really excited for you! Just think how pleasant your evenings will be, and this can start today if you remove her now!
Best of luck,
Angela
Really sound advice from Angela, but I thought I would chime in by agreeing with her that you ought to consider pulling her out of school now. It has been shown that children need time to “de-school” when they transition from brick-and-mortar school to home. (I believe the recommendation is one month for each year they have been in school.)
If you want to start your academic year at home in mid-August or early-September, you’ll need the time for both of you to adjust and later, to prepare for the school routine. This is a beautiful time of year to spend a lot of time outdoors and to take advantage of less-crowded conditions at parks, museums, zoos, etc.
Sue
You know, this is interesting because last year, something I noticed with my daughter was that contrary to what is taught…she actually was doing much better after a solid summer of doing literally NO school type work.
We had played, gardened, cooked, she had played with her older sisters a lot, we had read stories and done reading as play but not like work and she actually had a much greater retention than during the previous year of constant drudgery and pattern of constant failure.
The school and University of Washington (who had done extensive testing on her because she is atypical in her disabilities) were both pushing a continuating program of reading etc during the summer but both my mom (a retired English teach from way back) and myself have been adamantly against this because of her lack of time to simply be a kid. The reading teacher who works with her individually this year seems pushier than the one we had in previous years and she wanted us to continue a rigid reading program with her over Spring break but we told her that while we would read with her, it wouldn’t be in any rigid format because as it is, she hardly has time to be a kid.
I will talk with her dad tonight about the idea of pulling her out early. He is concerned about my ability to follow through (because of my health) but he is willing to allow me a solid year to see what we can accomplish, understanding that what is going on now is certainly not helping our daughter any.
Thank you ladies…I greatly appreciate your ideas and welcome more:)
I don’t know what your health problems are, but I’ve had my share too. And I know you can do it, even with health issues. Especially if you use the Charlotte Mason method instead of a rigid curriculum. If you haven’t done much research on the method, this website is the best place to find out. Here’s a good basic info page. Don’t be overwhelmed by the number of things to do, because the method is quite simple once you understand it.
Really you just read and discuss, and use real things to teach. Then you enjoy nature, poetry, art and music.
You can do it.
Thank you, I appreciate your encouragement. I am nervous but passionate. I have long wanted to homeschool my older daughters but my ex-husband, who had previously agreed to them being homeschooled once the private school they attended (run by their own Grandparents, both teachers) closed, then decided to not allow it so I am very late to the game.
I was very excited to begin with my youngest daughter but during her pregnancy, my chronic but manageable health problems got entirely out of control, I lost my job and generally just fell apart, as did my dream of homeschooling. I did get to finally have the home birth I had always wanted although that was touch and go the entire pregnancy as well. I have severe fibromyalgia, two types of arthritis, and I get knocked out sick constantly for whatever reason plus add on kidney problems >.< and of course, depression issues I won’t go into but certainly not made better by these things. I struggle with really low vit D that doesn’t respond to supplimentation and we get like, no sun here in lovely, lovely Seattle.
I’ve spent the last year working on revamping my world. I had teetered over into severe obesity, diabetes and just plain yuck. I’ve lost a ton of weight now, my fibro is MUCH better, I’ve totally halted and reversed the diabetes and after a huge kidney scare a few months ago, even they are behaving very well. I still get sick constantly so I’m working on immunity. I have to go tanning constantly because my vit D levels have to be up or I get sick, sick, sick. I’m so thankful…I spent 2 years drugged, in massive pain and asleep. I am endlessly thankful to be through that and now having to go through significant humility while rebuilding my relationships with my family and God.
So, that’s me:) I have four daughters, 19 years, 15 years, 12 years, and 7 years:) I’m passionate about alternative food choices, natural health, beauty, food politics, my kids and now, if only I had a housekeeper:)
Kittenbites I don’t normally chime in but here I go 🙂 I also have health issues fybromyalgia and chronic daily migraines. So there are days that I don’t function very well. On those days my son is a trooper and does his work quietly! But when my son was doing just what your daughter is doing my DH gave me permission to homeschool him!!! I jumped right in here and was like a sponge and the lovely ladies here give some of the best advise. I also have a friend who has been homeschooling for years she has 8 children and two have graduated and one graduates this year. She sat me down and said first because he hated school and lost his love of learning, and it was the last quarter of school, she suggested using 5 in a row, and supplement math. That way he could see that learning can be fun again. My son loved reading the books and activities, we did them together. We read about Thomas Edison, we had a timeline, a lap book, learned about three states, three presidents, etc. It was a gentle way of getting back his love of learning. This year we did middleages through SCM and he has loved it and the books involved. I am so glad we pulled him 🙂 I have a daughter who also has disibilities she has a receptive/expressive language disibility so what is taken in isn’t always processed and spit out like it should be. Right now the public schools are playing well and she gets special education support ie: speech, occupation therapy, a special education aide in the classroom just for her etc. As long as that is occurring she will stay there, our insurance won’t cover the speech or ot, and its expensive.
Ok I’ve babbled enough – check out five in a row it might be just right for the end of the school just like it was for us 🙂
I just wanted to encourage you in your journey. I, too, would consider pulling her out now. You can do some basic things with her now. You could do some basic math games or worksheets that are short and simple. Also, do reading with her. Even if it is not to further her reading instruction but to just keep her reading. I love the Pathway readers suggested in the curriculum guide for my DD’s.
My oldest DD who is 7 years old has not been diagnosed but I believe she struggles with ADD, Visual Dyslexia and maybe an auditory disorder.
Reading is a huge struggle for her. It doesn’t help that her 5 y/o sister has caught on to reading and is reading up a storm in the 2nd grade level. We have changed our instructional materials several times to find the right fit for her. I have also several times gone back and repeated stuff that she already knows just because it builds her confidence. She sees that “this isn’t so hard and I can do it!!” Also, after the phonics instruction time she has a book she reads to me. It started out being Sally Dick and Jane books and we may do some more of those. That greatly boosted her confidence to be able to read a book!! She is now reading the first Pathway reader, First Steps.
It is okay to go back and review if need be. It will help her feel better about herself and maybe breakdown some of the “this is too hard and I can’t do it” walls and help her to progress faster. Also, to move at her speed and not be rushed through when she isn’t ready will be a big boost for her.
I often have to remind myself that my DD is doing great, even though she is probably 1/2 year behind in reading. She has progressed and isn’t being overwhelmed by being rushed.
If she is only 7 (and even8), there is no reason that she HAS to be beyond 2nd grade. Just start her where she won’t be overwhelmed but will gain confidence and joy. Then move on. Remind yourself that she is where she should be and don’t rush it.
Thank you ladies! 🙂 I guess I need to hear it…Szadie (my 7 year old) likes to read easy books but nothing more challenging right now. I am SO thankful that she doesn’t have a younger sibling who is reading better than her because I’m not sure how she would handle that! hehe Kudos to your daughter, Pangit, for being able to handle that!
My kids have run the gammut. My oldest, no problem reading. My 2nd, I was a bit concerned although for the life of me, I can’t remember why but absolutely no problem reading. I mean, with those two, I didn’t even have to sit down and try…they just magically ‘did it.’ My 3rd caused her teachers all kinds of angst. We continually got letters for interventions and special services etc…I never worried. I knew that when Lilah wanted to read, she would read. I told them all this repeatedly and other than that, I ignored them, much to their consternation >.< When Lilah (my little slugchild) wanted to read, she read and now does so voraciously. But Szadika…I could tell early on that she was having some kind of trouble that the others never had. She also has a different father than the other three and he has a history of dyslexia of which I have a touch myself. I also struggle with ADHD, as do all my daughters and my mother…or call it rampant hyperactivity…wild creative lack of being able to shut our minds down…whatever:) We have it. SO…here was the baby, unable to remember things in a very atypical fashion. Then in school, far more obviously and of course, the teachers were noticing it as well along with dyslexia and probable ADHD although after all the heavy duty testing at the UW, they are wondering if it will prove out to not be the case once other things are sorted out.
Anyways, I am SO glad to have found you all! I love this site. I’ve been researching homeschooling for years in various forms but I’ve never really looked into Charlotte Mason. I’m loving it though and it is exactly what I have in mind. I was raised with my Grandmother (and my parents, we lived together). She died just a bit ago at the age of 99. She was a highly educated teacher and her methods had deep impact on me and made sense. Charlotte Mason’s methods remind me so much of my Grandmother and I love it, I love the connection.
I am going to go look up the resources you both mentioned. I’ve been looking at books and curriculums etc…I am trying to not go crazy as I’m very short on money right now. Do any of you have ideas on specific math programs? I’ve seen what is recommended on this site. Szadie would probably love the manipulatives but I’m very leery of anything that uses oddball language to explain math concepts, if that makes sense? I understand math very well but I have been wholeheartedly NOT impressed with many modern curriculum because of the language thing. I think I am going to have her redo most of 2nd grade math next year to solidify what she is good at and catch up what she never did get. I am pretty sure that we would be able to start 3rd grade math next year as well. I’m just afraid of spending a bunch of money on something and her not understanding it. Or worse, me not understanding the instructions >.< hehe
Confidence and joy…I wish you could follow me around whispering this to remind me:)
We use Math U See and are really enjoying it. I find that it has simplified things a lot. It is something like $35 for the workbook, $20? for the teacher’s book/dvd (we just watch the DVD and Mr. Demme explains it all) and $35 for the manipulatives that you use every year. There are some online things you can use and I think there is even a free one that some of the families on here use. I’m not much into online, I like the real thing in front of me. You can look at a demo online of Math U See (mathusee.com) and decide if it would be a good fit for her or not.
For phonics we are using Progressive Phonics (progressivephonics.com) and it is free. You can use it online or print off the books and flash cards to use. We print them off. You might try her reading Sally Dick and Jane which you can buy or get at the library. Also, the Pathway Reader’s are simple to read. First Steps (the first one) has you read the first part of a story to her at the beginning, to “set the stage” and then she would finish reading the story in the more simple language that is easier to read. You can get them at Rainbow Resource (rainbowresource.com) for $5-6 each.
Paperbackswap.com is a site that you trade books on. You put on books that you are willing to send to others and they put on books they are willing to send. You pay shipping to send your book, but pay nothing to receive a book. That is a good way to get inexpensive books. You can also buy credits to get books. I look for books at second hand stores that I put on there or books that we aren’t going to use anymore.
bookfinder.com compares different sites to help you find the best price on books.
Hope that helps.
I’ve been looking at Math U See and Right Start, among other things…so many choices! I love the Progressive Phonics site, thanks for that!
I’m already a long time member of Paperback Swap, just never thought of using them for this…hhmmm…hehe I’ve also been slacking there so I set my account to ‘vacation’ mode so I wasn’t too big of a disappointment to other members when I couldn’t ship a book. >.<
I’ve been looking at so many things I feel like I need a week’s long nap at this point but I SO appreciate all your help and ideas!
Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
- The topic ‘Homeschooling recommendations for slight learning disabilities.’ is closed to new replies.