Misty-As I mentioned before, the sentence diagramming can get a little confusing. We are going to complete Book 1 and then see how my daughter’s retention is. If she’s still struggling with the material, I may switch to Our Mother Tongue. My daughter is gaining a good understanding of grammar but neither of us can remember all the diagramming rules at this point. I take a very relaxed route with grammar. We only do grammar 3x a week and I keep the lessons fairly short-15 min or so.
I used Easy Grammar Plus with my son around the 8th grade. He did well with it but my daughter wasn’t retaining the information from that program at all. It was too easy to do the worksheet without any real comprehension.
My son worked through Simply Grammar before using Easy Grammar Plus. My daughter has had a smattering of grammar through the years-Grammar land, GUM drops grammar, some Language Lessons for the Intermediate Child and one of the Queen’s Language Lessons books as well. We just started Step by Step Grammar this past year and she is finishing up 7th grade.