Regarding “A Reason for Science” – I know that it is very work-booky looking, but I am thinking of it as more of an add-in to 106 Days. My thought is that we will do our 106 days readings and nature journals/walks, etc… and then work in the experiments with A Reason for Science. I am not sure how much of the journaling my younger kids will do, but I think the process of recording observations will be good for my older two kids.
I just felt that as my 10yo and 11yo are approaching General Science (in Jr. High) they needed some science experiments and terminology so that they aren’t lost in all the science lingo at that level (and beyond). To me, it looks very ‘do-able’ for all the kids together, short lessons and easy experiments,clear explanations of what you are doing and why, and I like that they point every lesson back to the Lord.
We had to venture away from Apologia b/c it was so dry – so I am sad to hear that God’s Design may have the same problem :(. I know from experience that if it is too textbooky, reading it will become a chore and nobody will learn much.