I am in no way an expert or even a CM purist/expert 🙂 but from what I have read and been learning, I don’t get the impression that CM was a “relaxed-do-school-whenever” educator. I get the impression that she had a schedule, a pretty set schedule of short, focused work, and within that schedule school was completed. Upon completion of school that is when “free time” came up for all the extra things. A mix of schedule and freedom. And I might have it totally wrong too as I have no read all her writings (just starting to work though them), just learning as I go.
I am a big fan of schedule for school. When it is school time, we do school. There is no wandering off to play or dawdling because I want to have my free time too, LOL. The kids have simple coloring books with their school books, if they need help but are waiting for me, they can color while they wait, but they don’t wonder off to play during school time.
Now my 1st grader’s school is going to go much faster than my 6th grader so when he is done with all his work, he will play quietly as the older kids finish school. He does not sit there the entire time just waiting, but they don’t leave school things until their school is done. That said… I stay with them. I do not wander off either. It took “training” for me too 🙂 I don’t do cook a meal, clean the house, write emails… during school time. I am trying to do my best to lead by example (not always successful but I am working on it). I want them to understand that with focused attention and doing their best the first time things will go smoother and there is more time to do what they really want to do.
When it comes to free time and “Masterly Inactivity” I think it will look different for every family and child, same as our school day will look different than others. For my kids Masterly Inactivity is learning how to be creative and play on their own with out entertainment, but really just looking around and using what they find be creative. For the past two weeks my kids have been working on a play that they came up with. We have a very simple house, but they are finding props and all sorts of things, on their own, to create their play scenery and props. It is a lot of fun, but yes can get messy at times, which is fine as long as they keep it contained. For us that is Masterly Inactivity, at least at the ages they are at.
I know for our family it really starts with me. If I am with it,focused, prepared and ready for the day the kids do so much better. But if I am distracted and not staying with them they will be distracted and have a harder time. I remind myself that HSing is really like a job. When I worked my employer would not have been happy if I had just wondered off during the day or spent time browsing online or emailing… my employer wanted me to be focused and do the best I could. I need to treat HSing in the same way because that is what my kids need. They are almost like my customer and I am there to serve and help them succeed and I don’t do that well when I am not present in body and mind.