I watched one of the videos that Sonya did for Delightful Reading, and it really piqued my curiousity more. I have to be honest that I am a devotee of systematic phonics, but I can see where blending multiple approaches to reading can be beneficial (once the child has learned phonics first … IMHO).
Something that really resonated with me is encouraging that shift from sounding out words to fluently reading, which is where my 7yo (first grade) seems to struggle. She’s had two years of intensive phonics with MFW and I am pleased with the results. She can sound out words and she knows many rules, but she does not read smoothly enough to always comprehend what she’s reading, since it takes her a while to get through the reader. I feel that DR would complement her needs and abilities well.
I think that for my “natural”, 5yo reader I will work with her on DR with her sis, but do more intensive phonics alongside, so she gets the best of both worlds. I think that the decoding (phonics) skills are so important but so are the encoding. There is value to teaching reading through several approaches. I am going to marry DR with All About Spelling with my 7yo next year, as well. Maybe even let my 5yo daughter sit in as well to sharpen her natural reading skills.