We are using EGP w/ my 8th grader and I can’t say I love it, possibly the layout. The one I have has the student text with the TG, so I don’t have a separate one and the answers are right in front of him. Not crazy about that. I think you can purchase them separately, which is what I wish I had done, but not sure if you can. My son seems okay w/ it, but he’s not a complainer unless I really push him for an answer.
I tried making copies of the student pages and that became too much work so I just let him do the work and self correct. I do trust him, but the layout makes me bonkers. It’s such a large book, too! We were using JAG and I thought he was getting burned out so we switched to EGP. I don’t really have any complaints…easy explanations (although it seems each grammar program uses its own language, no joke) and clean, uncluttered worksheets.
We’ll probably take a break soon, and then go back to JAG to finish it up. Then, not sure. But, if I go back to EGP, I’ll check for a separate TG.
hope that made sense.