Cost of Gen-Deut, Habits, Handicrafts, and Picture Study

Tagged: ,

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • HSMom03
    Participant

    I priced out the books suggested for Gen-Deut… I think it was around $200-$250.  That is everything suggested for 1st grade/family, but does not include the few books (3 I think) that were suggested for borrowing from the library.  Am I doing something wrong?  Everyone is always raving about the low cost of the guide, but once you add the books in… and I know that books are $$$ in general but just wondered if I am going about this the wrong way!  I would welcome any tips.  Maybe buy books 1 term at a time?  Not sure if that would help much.  The low cost of the guide loses its appeal once you add up everything else.  I am already passing up on RightStart ($265) and thinking of going with the less expensive Math-U-See (which I actually do think I like!).  Last but not least, when I priced out things for Habits, Handicrafts, and Picture Study.  I think that came to $140!  It just seems like 1st grade should be relatively inexpensive.  I love the suggestions on here, then I find other things I want to “add” in 🙂 and then cost really gets out of control!  I would love to hear others thoughts.  Thanks again!

    Tristan
    Participant

    A few possibilities for history:

    – Use the library for more of the books.  This cuts the cost more but you have the hassle of trying to get books in when you need them.

    – Buy all the books used where possible.  I tend to start keeping an eye out for the books a year ahead but start now checking local and online used books. 

    – Also remember that if you’re going to have several children going through the level eventually you’ll not have any purchases to make in history for each subsequent child doing the level books or family books you buy for the first child.  (I have eight children so it’s a big savings to buy reuesable books like this instead of some workbook based curriculum you buy new for each child.

    – One more thing, you are free to replace books if some are too hard to find/expensive to buy for your budget.  So, for instance, if you can’t get a copy of Pyramid by Macaulay inexpensively and didn’t want to use a library, you could replace that book with a different one on pyramids that you find at a lower price. 

     

    For Habits, Handicrafts, and Picture Study:

    It is easy to want it all right from the start.  😉  Choose one thing for this year and make do on the rest.  So you might buy the habits book and then just do handicrafts on your own (library books or dvds, internet tutorials, etc), and picture study with library books or looking at free paintings online.   I usually save the paintings as a screensaver for my computer.  🙂  Free and easy.

    I wouldn’t buy a handicrafts dvd for a 1st grader.  Did you have a handicraft in mind that you think your 1st grader can do and would enjoy doing long term?  At this age I think it’s easier just to let them explore materials freely, without the structure of ‘lessons’. 

     

    YES, homeschooling costs some money.  The cost is flexible so long as YOU are not married to one particular publisher’s products.  In the early years I did far more library and less purchasing (a budget for the year of $50).  Now I’ve got eight children and so it is worth my time to purchase more materials.  Our budget is around $500 for the family.  I’ve got 5 officially schooling next fall and have already made our purchases for next year in that budget.  A lot of things I used for older ones are coming into use again for younger siblings now, so the biggest purchases are toward the oldest child.

    HSMom03
    Participant

    Thank you Tristan, that was really helpful!  That really simplifies things for me.  Love, love your ideas for habits, handicrafts, and picture study!  Yes, I do want it all, haha.  That $200-250 for history was including even the books that were listed as optional.  Right now optional to me means… I need it! 🙂

    I don’t even really mind spending on their education and our budget is probably average.  I just know how easy it is to overspend and want to make sure I don’t do that. 

    Thank you!

    sheraz
    Participant

    I sent you a PM.

    Tristan
    Participant

    I’m glad it was helpful – and I tend to be on the ‘optional means we need it’ side where books are concerned too.  🙂 

    TailorMade
    Participant

    Here are a couple of links that might help cut costs in the habits/handicrafts areas.

    http://www.charlottemasonhelp.com/2009/07/habit-training.html

    http://www.charlottemasonhelp.com/2009/07/habit-training.html

    We choose the artisit(s) and then use the internet and library for picture study.  Wink

    sheraz
    Participant

    Something else that I will mention – it is okay to substitute books. I know that it is so hard – especially if you are new to homeschooling and you don’t want to miss anything, but when a single picture book can cost $20 with no used options, then I think that it can become necessary, especially for the younger grades.

    I would buy the habits book first – that is the most crucial part to making your days smooth and easy down this road you are on.

    I like Tristan’s ideas about the handicrafts/art – let them go with supplies. They love and learn a lot from the freedom. 

    For picture study, I guareentee you that if you will google CM Style Picture Studies, you will have a lot of free ideas pop up.

    LindseyD
    Participant

    http://www.abebooks.com is a wonderful place to get used books for very good prices. Over 50% of the books I buy from there for our schooling cost less than $4 with free shipping. I do buy all of our books now, but in the beginning, we used the library A LOT. I see books as an investment that will bring many happy returns. Very rarely do I buy a book that is only read once. After it’s used for a lesson, my children are practically fighting over who gets to keep the book on their personal shelves in their rooms. Then they enjoy it over and over again for years to come. Not bad for a $4 book. 😉

    I personally wouldn’t buy a handicraft DVD for a 1st grader, either. When I think of 7yos doing “crafts”, I think of things like watercolor painting, drawing/coloring, or carving soap to learn how to use a knife. At least, thost are the types of things my kids were doing at 7. Even a set of really good watercolors will cost you less than $5 and will last a while. We focused a lot of life skills at that age, which required no books, just instruction and perseverance on my part. 

    Laying Down the Rails is a resource you can buy once and it will have infinite kickbacks for the rest of your parenting career, so yeah, it’s worth every penny. 

    As Tristan said, homeschooling does cost money. When people try to tell me homeschooling is too expensive, I am quick to remind them that public schooling isn’t much (if any) cheaper. Sure, the “school” may be free, but you’re still buying new school clothes, supplies, backpacks, lunch boxes, paying for lunches, field trips, gas to and from school, time off from work when they’re sick, class parties, and more. I’d rather spend my money on books.

    Hope that helps,

    Lindsey

    HSMom03
    Participant

    Thanks for the abebooks link!  There was a similar website mentioned on this forum a little while back and I need to search and find out what it was.  It was another good one!  

    That is a good point that maybe a 6-7yo doesn’t need a handicraft DVD.  The cardboard & paper and crochet ones are appealing to me right now but maybe I am getting ahead of myself? 🙂  I suppose I could search for a book… or even get one from the library.  Other than that, we already have Artistic Pursuits K-3 Book One that we haven’t used yet.  I am also interested in Drawing with Children and another watercolors book/program I found.  I usually end up buying too many things per subject and then I spend the year deciding which one we should “stick with”.  Then we don’t actually “complete” any one thing!  Guess skipping around isn’t THAT horrible but I’d rather be a little more focused this year.

    I have Laying Down the Rails already, I am now interested in the 2-book companion set.  $46 I think.

    I really don’t mind spending on their education, I just tend to overbuy!!  I LOVE buying school stuff :).   I just want to make sure I am getting what we actually need.  It’s hard to figure out but this thread is helping me.

    If I can find the Gen-Deut books for a good price then I will probably go that route this coming year.

    HSMom03
    Participant

    sheraz – great ideas!  I think it is wise put the habits books 1st.

    TailorMade – thank you for the links!

    Thank you everyone…

    RobinP
    Participant
    pangit
    Participant

    I always check bookfinder.com for any books that I need. Bookfinder checks a bunch of different sites and then lists them, best price first (including shipping) nada column for new and one for used. If you click on the one you are interested in, it will take you to the site. Often times abebooks is the cheapest. It so teems another site is.

    bethanna
    Participant

    Keep in mind that you can resell books when you are finished with them (if you want to) or if they are not “a good fit” for your family. The money from that sale could be put back into your budget for more books! 🙂

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)
  • The topic ‘Cost of Gen-Deut, Habits, Handicrafts, and Picture Study’ is closed to new replies.