Once they have the basics for pretend play (and it sounds like you have plenty, especially if you are low on space), I try to aim for other creative options than toys. From my experience, they do just want a lot and they don’t want to part with it. It has been a process to help her learn to weed through and get rid of things. (It’s also tough for me because I have two girls so I also think, “Do we need to keep this for the younger to play with?”)
They inevitably get toys (dolls, barbies, etc) from family without us asking. But this year we are renting a fully furnished house with only a fraction of our “stuff” here. It is a smaller house and we are a long distance from family. We just the girls’ (5 & 2) birthday party and specifically asked for small, creative, and consumable gifts. We got some great surprises – Ed Emberley’s Thumb Print book (this would be a great gift along with some washable stamp pads) and some other craft projects.
One thing I am considering for the girls’ Christmas is Magna-Tiles. They rock. There were some in the house we are renting and the girls have used them for everything from pretend pizza to a car garage. http://www.magnatiles.com/ If I don’t get them this year, I will next year when we move back to our stuff.
Some other great ideas that are on the girls’ Christmas list from family include: easel size art pad, alphabet stamp set, beauty set (nail polish, nail file), playfoam, and of course books.
Christie – I am intrigued by the play silks (and they would pack so small when we move
). What size are they and how many would you recomend as a starter set?