I recently purchased A Child’s Book of Character Building 1 and 2, and I’m not sure it is going to be for us, either. I hadn’t put words to it, but I think it may be for reasons similar to yours. We have read Missionary Stories with the Millers, and we all loved it! We have Wisdom with the Millers and plan to do that this year. We will also be doing Making Brothers and Sisters Best Friends.
If anyone has not read The Jesus Storybook Bible, I highly, HIGHLY recommend it. I think I would have to rank that book as our family favorite out of all of the storybook Bibles and devotionals we have, and we have many. 🙂 I have seriously considered giving it as a gift to adults; I love it that much. We have also done Big Truths for Little Kids, and we still go back and review from time to time. I like to use it alongside our other Bible readings. We also have Mighty Acts of God. I thought I loved it at first, but there were several typos that drove me a bit batty, and for whatever reason, it kind of fizzled for us. It is on our shelf right now, and may or may not come back out in the near future. We are currently reading through The Story for Kids. I am so-so on it, but my children seem to be enjoying it.