60-day returns • free shipping on USA orders $129+
Can anyone compare the new SCM Narration resource with the H&R,T&W book?
- This topic has 2 replies, 2 voices, and was last updated 10 years ago by
.
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
- Posts
Would anyone be able to offer a comparison of the narration content in SCM’s Hearing & Reading, Telling & Writing with the content in the new SCM Your Questions Answered resource on narration? I already own the former, and the latter intrigues me and I’m sure it’s wonderful but I wonder how much new info is there to justify the cost right now. I can’t download the sample and it doesn’t list how many pages or anything.
And darn it all if I didn’t just order that SCM planner a month ago and a few months ago moved away from my beloved CM families, so who can I get to order with me now to get free shipping?? Grrr.
Just kidding. Hats off to SCM for even offering free shipping — very nice!
Good question, MLIP. Here are some comparisons and contrasts that come to mind between the two.
- The HRTW book is mainly a compilation of Charlotte’s words. YQAN is mainly practical application of Charlotte’s ideas and principles in specific situations that moms have encountered.
- Both include the Narration Ideas list and written narration samples from Charlotte’s students. HRTW has a lot more narration samples than YQAN, but YQAN also has a few modern day student narration samples.
- YQAN contains three sample rubrics that could be used (or tweaked) for evaluating your student’s written narrations. HRTW does not have rubrics.
- Much of YQAN can be read on our blog, since it is largely a compilation of blog posts. HRTW is not posted on our blog (though CM’s words can be read online, of course).
Does that help any?
Viewing 3 posts - 1 through 3 (of 3 total)
- The topic ‘Can anyone compare the new SCM Narration resource with the H&R,T&W book?’ is closed to new replies.