I haven’t used the book yet, but my son will be doing Notgrass American History this next year at our co-op. It comes with great recommendations.
I’ve heard a lot of warnings about Hakim’s books. IMO, Barton slants things too far his way reinterprets history, and I couldn’t even finish reading (and neither could my son) The Light and The Glory. And I’m a conservative. American history is apparently something people have very strong opinions about. 🙂