Tying topics together

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Kelley
    Participant

    Do you tie the topics of your lessons together?  For example, if this week’s science lesson is about eagles, do you also use a poem about eagles for poetry, a scripture like Isaiah 40:31 for memory verse, a hymn like “On Eagle’s Wings”, and books that week about eagles, etc?  Sometimes I think it would be easier to do this on a weekly basis, but is it too “narrow”?

    Tristan
    Participant

    If you are strictly following Charlotte Mason’s philosophy I don’t believe she suggested doing this because you’re trying to make connections/relationships for the child.  However, not being a strict follower, I sometimes do this in small ways.  So I may share a poem about eagles during our science lesson on eagles.  But I generally wouldn’t coordinate everything for them (a hymn, scripture, art project, poem, picture study, and science lesson all having eagles involved).

    I have seen my children make the connections on their own too.  So if we learned about eagles a few weeks ago and then they come across a reference to eagles in a hymn or scripture verse they may mention it – if it catches their attention/interest.  They may be flipping through a poetry book a week or so after that and come across Tennyson’s poem The Eagle and love it so much they decide to use it for copywork or memory work.

    Another possibility I have seen play out, actually related to eagles, so I’ll share it, is that one year my oldest learned The Eagle by Tennyson.  Then a different year when her siblings were studying eagles after having seen them at the zoo, she taught them the poem.  (They were telling her about eagles and that prompted her sharing the poem.  They loved how dramatic it was and asked for her to write it down for them.  She said, let’s learn to say it together instead.

    So it can work both ways.  One danger of saturating their lessons that I can think of is with so much coordination of topic is they will become bored and tune it out, fail to give full attention, and they’re not feasting at a broad varied table of ideas.  Who wants to go to a feast where every dish is made with some form of eggs, or some form of fish, etc.?

    Monica
    Participant

    I don’t have the time to tie everything together like that, but if I think of a particular poem that fits with what we are studying, I might choose that poem on Friday, when we do poetry study.  Often I’ll choose a poem that corresponds with the season or something in history we’ve studied.

    I do love, though, like Tristan mentioned, when the kids make the connections themselves.  It’s encouraging and heartening when the kids make the connections themselves.  Or, for example, when we’re at the library and they come across a book about something we’ve studied and say, “Oh!” showing that they recognize the topic.

    The only time I have done a blend of CM and unit study, which is what you seem to be alluding to above, is when I did Five in a Row with my girls when they were 5 and 6.  It’s a great program, but I don’t prefer that type of study for older kids.

    Kelley
    Participant

    I guess I should mention this is our first week of trying to be total CM in our methods, and I’m still trying to work out some kinks (and will probably be trying all term long!).  It seems like some tying in and overlap is easy to do and lets me streamline a bit.  But I am also concerned about the “feast” that I want to present to her.  So it’s just trying to find balance here.

    We’re doing Tennyson’s The Eagle this week!  My daughter wanted to learn about eagles for science.  It has been fun!

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • The topic ‘Tying topics together’ is closed to new replies.