The Charlotte Mason Elementary Arithmetic Series

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • April
    Participant

    We got our daughter’s (8.5 years old) neuropsych eval back and I’m wondering if The Charlotte Mason Elementary Arithmetic Series might be doable for her.   She has visual impairments of complete left visual cut along with “Swiss Cheese defect” which is basically her right visual field that is left has holes in it like swiss cheese. She is functioning on a 3-4 year old level depending on what area was being assessed. These quotes are taken from her eval, “Given Daisy’s visual impairments, visual schedules and aids will not be as helpful for her as they would be for another student (she is low IQ). She may benefit from a multimodal approach to learning in which she has an opportunity for hands on and verbal learning, with minimal demands on her visual skills. I recommend teaching to mastery (i.e., 100%) instead of teaching to partial mastery (i.e., 80%). Like other students with an intellectual disability, I would describe Daisy’s style of learning as “fire drill” learning. She will benefit from and perform better when she can learn skills in the setting that she is expected to use them. It is important that adults working with Daisy understand that she is a concrete thinker. Abstract concepts will continue to be difficult for her as she ages and progresses. As much as possible, information should be broken down into simple step by step instructions to help her understand what is expected of her.” Thank you for your input.

    Morgan Conner
    Participant

    My child was diagnosed with math disability and ADHD at about age 8 through a neuropsych eval as well. Although I knew something was wrong it was still tough to read it in black and white. So first of all-hugs to you.

    In approaching her disabilities we traveled the path of ‘latest research’ for a full year. She worked diligently through all of those skills like subitizing, number lines, etc and by the end of the year she still didn’t know her math facts and felt ‘dumb’ (her words). She hated math. I hated math.

    When someone recommended Richele’s handbook (the Arithmetic Book 1 wasn’t available yet) I decided to forego the ‘latest research’. I trusted Miss Mason with other subjects so why not math as well? One of the most striking things about Richele and her work is the dependence on the Holy Spirit which is also a principle of Miss Mason’s. Through her encouragement (via the DVD and handbook) I let go of notions of where my child ought to be. I was able to put aside a ‘manual’ and look at my child in the face and work with her instead of against her. I was able to invite the Holy Spirit into our math work because I wasn’t too busy worrying about what the ‘experts’ said. Peace descended on our homeschool. My daughter still has disabilities. But she is making steady progress. She enjoys math and no longer calls herself dumb. I was able to hear Richele Baburina speak on math recently and I have never felt so much awe and wonder and beauty in this particular aspect of God’s creation.

    The beauty of Miss Mason’s math approach (practices) is that is lines up perfectly with her principles. Richele Baburina’s Living Math honors my child as a born person. I started where my child had solid ground and worked out from there. She emphasizes that there is no behind-there is just where the child is. Her book also tells us to work at our child’s pace.

    I want to add that my child has peripheral vision loss as well. Her entire left field of vision is missing (due to a surgery at age 3). She has learned to compensate on her own and I just am sure to take it into consideration if I notice her struggling with something.

    So in summary-I wholeheartedly recommend this math and all of Miss mason’s practices to you!

    April
    Participant

    Oh Morgan thank you so much for your response.  I felt convicted in my spirit when I looked over the sample saying yes, this is what she needs.  She had a right hemispherectomy at age 6 to disconnect her whole right hemisphere of her brain.  She has struggled greatly due to long term neglect, trauma, constant seizures for the first 3 years 3 months of her life dying in an orphanage and then 2.5 years ago we caused more trauma for the sake of saving her life.

    What you said, “Richele Baburina’s Living Math honors my child as a born person.” I love this.  I’m not worried about Daisy being “behind” we have known since we brought her home she would always live at home, but I do want her to have as many abilities as she can in the most gentle God honoring way.

    Her greatest challenge,that we have yet to figure out how to overcome, is the wiring in her brain is not correct for using her vision.  She does not use direct vision to look at an object unless we move the object over and over until she is forced to…she uses her limited peripheral.  Due to this and her not being able to do most of the neuorpsych testing they said there is no need to give her a label of any learning disabilities because she is just low intelligence.  I don’t buy it for a second.  She just finished a 550 piece puzzle all by herself.  We really have zero clue how she is doing them, but she loves puzzles.

    I would love to know what your daughter had surgery for that gave her a left vision cut.

    Thank you for your response and for the message of hope.

    Morgan Conner
    Participant

    My daughter was diagnosed with a brain tumor at age 3. It is diffuse and infiltrative so it cannot be safely removed. However-it has not grown since it was discovered. A true miracle. It covers most of the right hemisphere. When she was first diagnosed they thought it was an aggressive tumor that would end her life in less than a year. She was also having seizures due to the tumor. So the neurosurgeon decided to remove most of her right temporal lobe in hopes of providing more space for her brain to swell and thus giving her more time and to hopefully curb seizure activity. As I said-the initial diagnosis was wrong and the tumor has not grown. We knew that peripheral vision loss was a possible side effect when we agreed to the surgery. And I don’t regret the decision one bit. It did help with her seizures for about 2 years but they came back with a vengeance and so far we haven’t found any good solution.

    The biggest trouble she has with that vision loss is running into things and knocking things over-but occasionally I see her leave off the first words on a page or the manipulatives that might be placed too far left. It has very little impact on her overall though.

    I truly can’t imagine educating her any other way. She really struggles with handwriting also and so the limited writing in this math has also boosted her confidence. And spreading such a wide feast has introduced her to subjects that she excels at and that also boost her confidence. She is phenomenal at recitation. She has such a beautiful way of reading her scripture or hymn pieces that I am frequently moved to tears. A beautiful reminder of how this method is such a blessing to these precious children who would otherwise be cast aside and labeled as less than.

    I am going to add you and your ‘born person’ to my prayer list. I am glad I was able to provide a little help and hope today.

    April
    Participant

    I wish I could sit and have a cup of coffee or tea with you.  It’s so wonderful to find someone who is in the same place.  I would love to get to know you better.

    I love the Charlotte Mason approach.  I’m not a purist, but every time I deviate from it I find we have so many issues, but when we go back to what Miss Mason has taught us and shown us days are SO much more peaceful and enjoyable.  I have not used it for math though as my other three kids are doing CLE math, but now I’m really excited to get  Richele Baburina’s book.  Daisy has tried to start doing narration of books and usually can get 1 point, character, idea out so that’s exciting.  Daisy can’t read or write anything yet.  How old is your daughter now?

    I so very sorry the seizures are back.  I remember them as if they were happening yesterday.  My stomach gets into knots still even though we have been 2.5 years seizure free.  I will pray they will find something that works.  Thank you for adding Daisy to your prayer list. If you would like to connect more you can email me at moose family  95 at gmail  dot com (take out all the spaces and put the @ sign).  We live in Washington for now, but we have two job possibilities that could take us to Idaho or Wyoming.

     

     

    April
    Participant

    I really should have proof read what I wrote. o.O  Oops!  Lesson learned!

    April
    Participant

    Morgan Conner, I’m hoping you see this.  What did you use to teach your child to read?  I have tried AAR, 100 Easy Lessons, and Child 1st Publication SnapWords (she is great at memorizing the pictures, but she doesn’t seem to see letters).  I think I need to maybe do Delightful Reading, Level 1: Playing with Letters and Sounds and see if that will work, but thought I would ask you before I invest more money. Thank you. ~April

    Morgan Conner
    Participant

    Sadly I had not ‘met’ Charlotte Mason until after I had taught my oldest to read. I have since taught 2 others using Miss Mason’s reading instructions found on page 199 of Volume 1 (Home Education). I am currently teaching another of my girls and she is in the stage of just learning letter sounds. I don’t use any bought curriculum-just wooden letters and Home Education! I will send you more details in an email.

    flowersbymo
    Participant

    Please send me via email as well.

    I found these two PNEU articles very interesting:

    https://www.amblesideonline.org/PR/PR12p494FirstReadingLessons.shtml

    https://www.amblesideonline.org/PR/PR08p350GouinReading.shtml

     

     

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
  • The topic ‘The Charlotte Mason Elementary Arithmetic Series’ is closed to new replies.