Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Amanda
    Participant

    Hi! I recently saw “Laddie” listed on the SCM literature lists. I’d never heard of it before & haven’t read it yet, but based on the summary it seems as though the book focuses on the brother/sister relationship in a positive & uplifting way? I’m wondering if it would be the kind of book I could read to my 7yo. son to give him some encouragement or a good example for being a kind/thoughtful/etc. older brother? Or is it more suited to an older age, or not really right for that purpose? Thanks in advance! 🙂

    Amanda
    Participant

    Any thoughts?

    RobinP
    Participant

    I love Gene Stratton-Porter.  I haven’t read this particular title though I know it’s a favorite for many.  I usually think of her writing as being for slightly older but a great book spans the ages.  Personally I would do this as a family read aloud and let the book speak as it may rather than targeting it for a specific person and specific behavior.  The lives of the characters coupled with family reactions and discussions mean more, I think.  Not that you plan to bash him over the head with it.  ?  I just think of Charlotte’s reminder that the Holy Spirit is our teacher and will use these books (His Word and life itself) to guide us.

    Karen
    Participant

    We listened to Laddie on librivox and my girls really enjoyed it.  It’s about a boy with one arm who goes to work for a logging company, falls inlove with the daughter of a rich man, and saves the logging company from some bad guys.

    I can’t remember where the sibling relationship comes in. Maybe Laddie was a relative of someone important in the book, but he didn’t know it or something. I think Laddie was an orphan. It has been about 2 years since we listened to it. My girls would have been about 10, 8, 6, and 4.

    In my opinion, it would be a hard book to read aloud – old words, old phrases, long sentences, lots of description, etc. That’s why we listened to it – in the car, on short trips (errands, dr. Appt., etc.) Over the  course of a summer. I think it’s definitely a book to take in small doses, b/c of the old way it’s written.

    There was nothing objectionable in it, and the old language was sweet when talking about how much Laddie loved Angel. It was definitely a good book.

    RobinP
    Participant
    Melanie32
    Participant

    I think the above description by Karen is about the book Freckles by the same author.

    Laddie is actually from the point of view of the youngest girl in a big family. She is a around 8 or 9, I think. The story does include her older brother’s romance and marriage as seen through her eyes. I really enjoyed reading it years ago but my children haven’t read it yet. I think it would be a good family read aloud but I wouldn’t choose it as a specific read aloud for a 7 year old.

     

    Amanda
    Participant

    Thank you all so much. Yes- that review was VERY helpful. It’s certainly a book we want to read, but I think we’ll save it for a little later, and just as literature 🙂

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • The topic ‘"Laddie"?’ is closed to new replies.