clarification on Cm

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • jill smith
    Participant

    I just started jumping in and reading Charlotte Mason companion and love it. I am on chapter 15 and so far so good.

    I am wondering since we just started cm last year and I didn’t really implement all of her ways, is it to late to start with my children now?

    I have two dd ages 8, 11 just turning these ages in less than a couple of months. I also have a son who is 13.

    I just want to make sure with the copy work (spelling wisdom I am suing it the correct way) do I start my 8 year old in it as well? she is just beginning to read.

    I love her view on vocabulary, writing down words they don’t understand in their reading and have them look them up.

    I am a little confused on the Narration part. what does she consider the early years?

    what about composition?

    how many narrations a day and what age do you start the written narrations?

    spelling is an eye soar around here for sure. Is spelling wisdom enough or could I use All about spelling?

    I am trying to get it all figured out before next year. Thanks for your help.

     

    2Corin57
    Participant

    I’m just going to c/p, to make it easier to reply.  🙂

     

    I just started jumping in and reading Charlotte Mason companion and love it. I am on chapter 15 and so far so good.

    I am wondering since we just started cm last year and I didn’t really implement all of her ways, is it to late to start with my children now?

    It is never too late to start CM!

    I have two dd ages 8, 11 just turning these ages in less than a couple of months. I also have a son who is 13.

    I just want to make sure with the copy work (spelling wisdom I am suing it the correct way) do I start my 8 year old in it as well? she is just beginning to read.

    I would wait. Technically CM doesn’t recommend starting spelling/grammar until grade 4. While SW/ULL can be used at age 8/grade 3, it’s not necessary. Where she is just beginning to read, I would really give her more time to develop that skill without the pressure of mechanics. Some (Trivium Pursuit) even recommend holding off until grade 5/age 10.

    I love her view on vocabulary, writing down words they don’t understand in their reading and have them look them up.

    I am a little confused on the Narration part. what does she consider the early years?

    The early years are PreK and K, basically 0-5.

    what about composition?

    Now, someone else may know more on this, but until grade 3, you would just do oral narration (oral composition). In grade 4 they would start dictation and written narration (which is the beginning of composition). And that doesn’t mean they jump into a 500 word essay either. Start small and slowly build. Start with a sentence if you need to, and then slowly build up to more. Also, something I do – if I catch my son writing anything for “fun”, I do NOT correct it. If he asks for spelling help, I give it. But I do not correct spelling, grammar etc… In these younger years, it is more important to encourage an enjoyment of reading and writing, than to weight them down with mechanics.

    how many narrations a day and what age do you start the written narrations?

    ^^Written narrations begin in grade 4. How many narrations per day will be a matter of preference. We normally do 2 – one for whatever the topic of the day is (ex. nature study, science, history etc…) and one of required reading.

    spelling is an eye soar around here for sure. Is spelling wisdom enough or could I use All about spelling?

    That is completely your preference 🙂 For many kids Spelling Wisdom will be enough. There are others who may require more. I can see me using AAS for my daughter, and SW for my son who basically has a photographic memory for spelling. He sees and writes it once and that’s it, he has it.

    I am trying to get it all figured out before next year. Thanks for your help.

    Just remember, you make a curriculum work for you. Tweak as necessary. You are not a slave to the program. So if it says start something at grade 4/age 9 and you know your child isn’t ready – then don’t start it yet. If you know your child is going to do better with AAS than SW, then use that.

    jill smith
    Participant

    Does anyone use the Enrichment studies? If so do you enjoy them?

    what do you all use for Science? I like Apologia but its a little much for me. We are currently using CGC.  We usually start Apologia in middle school or high school. What about English for Middle school (8th grade). I’m not all about diagramming sentence, I feel writing will work for that. Anyone have an opinion on this? I just don’t want to fail my kids in any area.

    Sonya, do you have any input on these matters?

    what about geography?  I  see there is a lot out there and we have tried the ones on the CM and my kids didn’t get into it to much. I want something fun and engaging.

    nebby
    Participant

    2Corin gave great answers. I just wanted to add that if you are new to CM you might want to have all your kids ease into written narrations. Make sure they have the hang of oral ones first.

    I don’t know what you mean by Enrichment studies. For science before high school I just like to do nature study and read living science books like the Storybook of Science. Geography we do map drills and again read books though you can also try the Visits to… Series from SCM.

     

    nebby
    Participant

    Also of all the grammars we’ve tried I like KISS which is free online best.

    retrofam
    Participant

    For geography there are many different ways to do it.  Puzzles,  card games,  board games,  maps, travel videos.  Map Tangle is a game like Twister that my younger ones like.

    We are currently reading “Operation World” which is from a missions group. We read about a country and pray for them. There is a children’s version also that is called “Windows on the World”.

    “How the States Got Their Shape” is another favorite.

    Sonya Shafer
    Moderator

    The Enrichment Studies lesson plan book is one way to combine all of those subjects such as art, music, literature, poetry, nature study, hymn study, habits, handicrafts, etc. You can select your own artists, composers, poet, hymns, and put it all together yourself, if you prefer. Either way works, but I would highly recommend that you do your best to include that wide variety of subjects. Most are done only once a week, not every day, so it adds a nice change of pace and variety to your days and a wonderful richness to your curriculum.

    Our suggestions for science and geography and all the other subjects can be found on the SCM Curriculum Guide. There are lots of resources available, and you should use the ones that will fit your family best, but if you’re curious which resources are our favorites, the Curriculum Guide will give you that information.

    Two other places that might help you as you’re learning and growing with CM methods:

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • The topic ‘clarification on Cm’ is closed to new replies.