Charlotte's own schedule – what's the difference between printing and writing?

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Inky
    Member

    So I’m looking at page 117 of Planning Your Charlotte Mason Education, Charlotte’s own timetable for Class 1 (Grades 1-3).

    On Monday and Saturday, her pupils did Printing. On Wednesday and Thursday they did Writing.

    What was the difference? Sonya / anyone else, so you know?

    Sonya Shafer
    Moderator

    I’ve never been completely sure, but my guess is that “writing” involves cursive once the children reach that stage.

    Anybody have more light to shed on it?

    Kate Mom of 1
    Participant

    Creative writing, perhaps? 

    missceegee
    Participant

    Kate, Charlotte did not teach creative writing, especially at those ages. Writing is taught with copywork and written narration. My reading leads me to the same conclusion as Sonya.

    Amy
    Member

    I also thought it refered to cursive/joined writing versus printing/unjoined.

    Inky
    Member

    Thanks – that makes sense.

    Another question – for ‘brush drawing’ that is sheduled with writing and printing on two days/week, I think what she did was use dry brush and teach the child to paint large strokes/letters using their shoulder/arm muscles.

    Does anyone have any further knowledge on this?

    Richele Baburina
    Participant

    Inky, if I understand my reading of CM, this brush work served as a time of drawing instruction and improved head and hand work.

    Charlotte’s students used brush drawing in their nature journals because Charlotte wanted them “drawing from the round,”  meaning from the object itself rather than a linear representation of the object, and she felt that brush-drawing was better suited for this work. She stressed that the goal of the nature journal is to enhance the child’s powers of observation and their appreciation of nature and was not meant as a vehicle for formal drawing instruction. During nature study, the object is more important than the rendering of that object so their instruction in brush drawing took place in another lesson.

    On a personal note, my boys did not love handwriting, even five minutes of handwriting. We incorporated brush drawing into our schedule three years ago and my boys were thrilled (and their handwriting even improved as a result). I know there is a Parents’ Review article on the technique but in short, here is what I do:

    Place a couple of objects on a bookshelf for them to choose to “draw” with their paints/brush. Make sure the objects are close enough for them to see comfortably but far enough away so they aren’t distracted by the detail.

    Instruct them to use just enough water on their brush to pick the paint up with but no more so they are able to draw with the brush.

    The child chooses from the objects to paint.  For example, it might be an lemon, a book and a coffee cup.

    Lessons are kept short – the same amount of time as their writing lesson.

    Have fun!

    Richele

     

     

    http://barefootvoyage.blogspot.com/2009/09/handwriting-brush-painting.html

    teachme2learn
    Participant

    Thank you for sharing, Richele. This is very new to me.  What age would you begin this?

     

    P.S.  It is good to see you back.  I always enjoyed reading your posts.

    Richele Baburina
    Participant

    Oops, I hadn’t actually meant to post that link, I’d remembered writing something about it before and went to see the pics of my kids 🙂  Thanks teachme2learn, it’s fun to be back among you all.

    Charlotte shows it in her timetable for Form I (approximately our grades 1-3). After that, I think art instruction took place in the afternoon for a fee but I’m so very open to correction on that as that’s just what I’ve gathered from available PUS material. In those early years Charlotte says the children find their own way with form and color so it really was as simple as putting the objects up, instructing ever so slightly with holding the brush and the amount of water to be used and how to rid the brush of water if too much was added.

    We work with Japanese inks as well (obviously not a part of Charlotte’s schools) but the whole process is incredible from the careful laying out of the brushes to the grinding of the ink and cleaning up. Remember, no mistakes – only possibilities.

     

    Inky
    Member

    Wow, Richelle, that is so helpful.

    I’m going to give it a try with the watercolor paints.  This is an area I’m challenged in – so the more I can learn about it the better! 

    For a young child, would you recommend working at the table (low, child’s height table) or on a sloping board? We have a child’s art easle – the nearly upright kind that the child stands at (looks like and A frame from the side). Any thoughts?

    I hope you don’t mind me asking you more questions – i’m intrigued because I think this may help my daughter’s handwriting which tends to be cramped and she complains of a sore hand. So, say I place a lemon on the shelf and ask her to draw it, does she just draw the outline, or does she fill it in? Should she make several attempts move on to drawing another object?  How many drawings should I aim for in one session?

    And finally, I’m intrigued as to how CM used brush drawing in nature study.  Did she expect her students to take paints out with them on a nature walk, or to bring objects home to draw after the walk, when they could set up the paints at a table? (I favour the latter for my small children!) I’d love to learn more – do you know are there any tutorials available for brush drawing for nature study?

    Sorry – I hope that’s not to many questions!

    Many thanks

     

    teachme2learn
    Participant

    Inky, while I’m not Richele, I had the same questions as you so I Googled dry-brushing for CM methods and this is what I came up with.  Maybe it’ll help get you started.

    The mother who learns to dry-brush

    Dry Brush Technique for Nature Study

    Techniques of Dry Brush Painting in Nature Study by Sandra Zuidema

    Inky
    Member

    teachme2learn

    thanks so much!

    Blessings

     

    Angela
    Participant

    i know this is an old topic, but does anyone recall where the DVD (?i believe?) is that one can purchase explaining/showing dry brushing… by, perhaps, ummmm… Eve Anderson?????

    only a small glimmer of a lightbulb going off over my head. it’s been years that i remember hearing of this dvd so i may not have the name correct whatsoever. does it ring a bell with anyone?

    teachme2learn
    Participant

    Eve Anderson is correct.  It can be found at http://www.perimeter.org.  I’ve been looking around for more info on it and the other two DVDs in the set.

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • The topic ‘Charlotte's own schedule – what's the difference between printing and writing?’ is closed to new replies.